Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The evolution of wings...

By CosmicConservative
A recent study of velociraptor and deinonychus dinosaurs has perhaps finally provided a highly plausible rationale for one of the most vexing evolutionary questions of them all. How did wings evolve? The evolution of wings has been one of the most contentious debates in evolutionary theory from the time of Darwin. It is still one of the main issues that is latched onto today by those who challenge the theory of evolution. One of the major arguments that has been difficult to answer in the past is "what use is half a wing?" This question is asked because evolution is said to occur in small steps, but wings are a major departure from all other use of limbs. So if evolution occurs in small steps, then wings should have evolved bit-by-bit. But until the wing provides actual flight, up until now anyway, the argument has been that partially functioning wings provide no evolutionary advantage, and as such would not be selected for, which would negate the further development and stop wings from ever evolving in the first place. But this study seems to me to have a plausible explanation, based on a study of velociraptor claws and comparing them to modern eagle or hawk claws.
Evolution of flapping These findings could shed light on the evolution of flight in birds, researchers said. Such feet could have led to the evolution of flapping. "When a modern hawk has latched its enlarged claws into its prey, it can no longer use the feet for stabilization and positioning," Fowler said. "Instead, the predator flaps its wings so that the prey stays underneath its feet, where it can be pinned down by the predator's body weight. The predator's flapping just maintains its position, and does not need to be as powerful or vigorous as full flight would require. Get on top, stay on top — it's not trying to fly away." In much the same way, raptor dinosaurs might have flapped their feathery limbs to keep stable. [Photos of Fossil Feathers] "We see fully formed wings in exquisitely preserved dromaeosaurid fossils, and from biomechanical studies we can show that they were also able to perform a rudimentary flapping stroke," Fowler said. "Most researchers think that they weren't powerful enough to fly — we propose that the less demanding stability-flapping would be a viable use for such a wing, and this behavior would be consistent with the unusual adaptations of the feet." "There's an old question on the evolution of flight — 'what use is half a wing?'" Fowler told LiveScience. "I think we have provided the most complete and defensible answer." Read more:
This is the sort of analysis that I like.

Comments (4)

Drax
Yet another "yawn." Hey! Did you know that eggs are now GOOD for us?
CosmicConservative
Heh.... well, I think this work is a good step towards explaining the "half a wing" conundrum. I still think the "you can jump farther or even glide with half a wing" is another good argument. Between the two I think I can sleep comfortably with the idea that wing evolution isn't a major concern for me. At least for birds. I've still got issues with the evolution of the insect wing...
Dadman
It's a good analysis, but it's speculative analysis. And even though there's really no way to definitively validate the speculation, it's just a matter of time before this analysis becomes established 'fact' in evolutionary theory. And over time speculation is piled on top of earlier speculation...and the process continues. It's a process that bothers me, mainly because scientists at some point become very dogmatic about these kinds of speculative analyses, and condescending toward those who have doubts. Anyway, critics of evolution have recently focused their attention on the complexities of biochemistry and the intricate, precise, and systemic interactions between complex molecules that make life possible - like the Kreb's cycle or the coagulation of blood. Their argument, simplistically stated, is that these very complicated biochemical processes could not have evolved in increments, or piece by piece, in a process driven solely by natural selection. I'm not enough of an expert to know if there is any merit to their arguments, I'm just passing along the argument...
CosmicConservative
The recent focus of criticism on complex chemical reactions is an extension of the "half a wing" argument. There's actually a whole bunch of things that fall into that general category. In fact this has been such a contentious area even within the field itself that it at one point fractured the theory into two parts, one which focused on tiny incremental modificataions, and one which championed the idea that major differences could appear quite literally overnight through genetic mutations. I've never been dogmatic about evolution. As an agnostic I see no problem with theorizing that some process or intelligence has guided at least some aspects of evolution. My only problem with that is the circular reasoning of it. "Something that complex could never have happened without something guiding it!" "OK, what would that something be?" "God." "OK, so God must be much simpler than this thing." "What? No! God is mysterious and complex!" "Um... OK, then what created God." "Nothing." "...."