Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Plaster frustrations...

By CosmicConservative
Arg… so you would think that it would be simple to find a local supply of one of the most common materials on the planet… Gypsum is an amazing mineral. It is one of the softest minerals known, and is very easy to carve. Pounded into dust and mixed with water it can be poured into molds to cast just about any conceivable shape. “Plaster of Paris” is essentially gypsum plaster. It’s called “Plaster of Paris” because Paris happens to have a huge deposit of gypsum which has been mined and used in this way for over a thousand years. You are almost certainly nearly completely surrounded by gypsum as you read this since gypsum is the primary component of drywall, which is the most common construction material used to create interior walls in homes and office buildings. Prior to the adoption of drywall as an interior building material many interior walls were made from strips of wood which were overlaid by plaster to create an integrated interior surface. However, much of that plaster was actually lime based plaster with gypsum plaster added as a way to accelerate the setting of the plaster since lime based plasters take days or weeks to fully harden. There is a wide variety of different types of gypsum plaster used in everything from home construction to fine arts to dentistry. “Dental plaster” which is used to create casts of teeth for the purpose of preparing crowns or bridges is a particularly high quality form of gypsum plaster which sets harder and captures finer detail than regular “plaster of paris.” But it’s basically the same stuff as plaster of paris. A sack of high quality casting gypsum plaster is typically about a dollar per pound, so a 25 pound bag of it costs about $25. Lower quality plaster of paris in bulk can be even cheaper than that. Hobby stores generally carry plaster of paris at huge markups but even so it’s still usually pretty affordable at maybe $4 or $5 per pound. With all of this understood you would think it would be pretty easy to go out and buy a bag of high quality gypsum plaster for casting items from molds. But you would be wrong. Or at least I have so far been unable to accomplish this. I can buy a 25 pound bag of high quality casting gypsum plaster for about $25 online. However, that 25 pound bag has to be shipped to me at a cost generally of about $25, which essentially doubles the price of the plaster. I suppose you could say it’s still cheap at $2 per pound, but it drives me crazy that I can’t just go to a local craft or building supply store and buy a 25 pound bag of it. But I can’t seem to find anyone who sells it. I have called half a dozen local dental supply companies to purchase a 25 pound bag of dental plaster. None of them can sell me a bag. Either they only sell to licensed dentists, or else they don’t actually have the bags on premise and they have it shipped (with shipping cost added) to the purchaser from their own supplier. Most building supply stores sell construction grade plaster which is intended to patch drywall or else to replace the older traditional lime based plaster to repair damaged moldings or wood work. That mixes into a mud-like paste, which works well when applying to a vertical surface, but which does not pour into molds very well. So here I am, just a hundred or so miles from an actual TOWN named “Gypsum, Colorado” and I can’t buy a bag of high quality casting gypsum plaster without having it shipped from ARKANSAS at my own expense. Sigh… what a world.

Comments (15)

Drax
Why not try Amazon? They have some for sale. Maybe get it shipped with free shipping even.
CosmicConservative
Hmm... I haven't looked at Amazon. The specific matereial I am looking for is called "Merlin's Magic." It's a high quality gypsum plaster designed specifically for casting small hobby items.
CosmicConservative
Just looked through Amazon's offerings... Shipping doesn't appear to be free on the heavy items. They don't seem to have Merlin's Magic, but the closest thing I see is probably the same thing, called "Pristine white casting powder". They have it for $16 for a 5 pound bag (so about three times the "bulk rate" for the same product) and with $11 shipping, to bring the total for 5 pounds to $27 or over $5 per pound. I can get a 25 pound bag of Merlin's Magic from the manufacturer and have it shipped from Arkansas for $50 total, so about $2 per pound for the same product. For less than twice the cost I get five times the product... I can't pull the trigger on the Amazon deal with that known...
CosmicConservative
There's a ton of places online where I can get Merlin's Magic or comparable "high quality" gypsum casting powder. The problem is that they all sell it in bulk and the shipping fees are pretty much the same as the product costs... I can get a 50 pound bag but it will cost about $50 with $50 in shipping... There was one place that offered to ship it in those one price for anything you can stick in it boxes (forget what they call them) but when I tried their website, they appear to be out of business.... sigh...
Andy
Cosmic, have you tried JoAnn fabric & craft stores? Pam bought some from them a while back, and it was pretty reasonable. I think they sell it online too, but probably not in 25 pound bags. But, I think they were running a free shipping deal on purchases of 50 bucks or more the other day.
CosmicConservative
Andy, hmmm... no I haven't tried Joann's that's an excellent idea. The Cosmic Wife shops there all the time (in fact I think she has a time-share on their fabric aisle). I will check it out.
CosmicConservative
Hmm.... according to their website, JoAnn's has a couple of potential plaster of paris products, but they look like basic PoP, not the "refined" or "pristine" or "high quality" versions that are sold for miniature casting... But since I'm really only planning on using it for structures and terrain, that might not be an issue. I think I'll stop by JoAnn's tonight on the way to my writing class and see what I can find... Thanks for the tip Andy!
CosmicConservative
Well, JoAnn's website showed they had some casting plaster, but they didn't have any in the store I went to. But there was a Michaels right across the street and they did. Five pounds for about $6.50, which seemed like a good deal. I'm about to whip up a batch and do some casting...
Andy
Shoulda' thought of Michaels! My Mom taught art classes at the store on East Texas for several years. Slipped my mind... Gittin' slow in mah ole age.
CosmicConservative
The results of the first casting episode with the "premium casting plaster" are somewhat mixed... The stuff is quite a bit more dense than the "Lightweight Hydrocal" which I expected, but it's still surprising how much heavier the cast pieces are. The stuff takes almost a full day to fully cure. However, it cures enough for de-molding in about the same time as the Lightweight Hydrocal. You CAN complete the curing in the microwave, but I haven't tried that yet. Using this new material is messier. It's more viscous and stickier than the Lightweight Hydrocal, which makes it more difficult to pour. I ended up with goop on my hands, on the molds and on the floor. The viscosity and stickiness makes it harder to avoid bubbles. It's hard to be certain without deliberately breaking pieces, which I'm not willing to do, but this new material does seem to be much more durable than the Lightweight Hydrocal. There is definitely a satisfying heft to the resulting items. Other than the mess though, the stuff seems to work pretty well. I am considering mixing the Lightweight Hydrocal and premium casting plaster together to see what happens...
CosmicConservative
Heh... sure, I'll post more boring plaster comments. :) I think this Artplaster is as good as I am likely to get. I checked out some commercial plaster casts at JoAnn's today and they were virtually identical to the Artplaster results. To get more durable than that I'll probably have to move to the casting resin, which is about as durable as you can get outside of metal casting. It is much more durable than the Lightweight Hydrocal and is at least as good, if not better, in capturing details from the mold. The two mushroom men I made with the Artplaster are very detailed, and much sturdier than the Hydrocal ones I cast. The only "problem" with the Artplaster is that it is much denser than the Hydrocal. That means if I create a chunk of terrain with a whole bunch of casting needed, I'll probably use the Lightweight Hydrocal for some of it, just to keep the weight down. That is why they made the Lightweight Hydrocal anyway, it was originally marketed to railroad diorama hobbyists whose dioramas can be as large as a kitchen table with cubic FEET of cast mountains, rocks, buildings, bridges, etc. For that purpose, cutting the weight in half is a great idea, plus those pieces mostly only get looked at, they don't get played with or played on. For my purposes I think the Artplaster is going to be just fine, and since my largest terrain elements which use plaster are about the size of a sheet of notebook paper, weight isn't really an issue. Yet. I am very pleased with the results of the Artplaster. And it's much cheaper than the Lightweight Hydrocal to boot.
Andy
Cosmic, I love it when a plan comes together! Be sure and post photos of the work. Ya' know, I had gotten in to woodworking a while back. Odd for me, because I've never really had a hobby. Quit golfing at about 25. Quit hunting when the kids came along. Really love to fish, and Daddy lives right on Caddo Lake...just never seem to find the time. But, I was really enjoying woodworking. I was taking old furniture and modifying the pieces for various uses around the house, building really pretty decorative shelves for gifts & our use, etc. Then one day a big storm came through, and a huge pecan limb took out the power line back to the shop where all my work took place. I thought, "Well, I'll get around to running a new one out there when I get a chance." That's probably been 5 years. I suck.