Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

State of Emergency?

By Dadman
Pat Buchanan's latest contribution to the immigration debate is being released today. State of Emergency: Third World Invasion and Conquest of American is decidedly apocalyptic essentially making the case that current immigration trends are irrevocable and that Western civilization is lost. I have mixed feelings about his thesis. Admittedly, Buchanan's arguments stir up the little reactionary in me to some extent. Reflecting on the recent immigration demonstrations across the country and the obvious reality that many of the demonstrators continue to maintain a strong allegiance to their home countries, I find myself on the same apocalyptic page as Buchanan. On the other hand, I realize on another, perhaps more rational level, that the offspring of these immigrants will in all likelihood become fully assimilated into U.S. society. It's just a matter of time. This is what I hope to be the truth and that the dire predictions of the West's imminent demise turn out to be greatly exaggerated. What do you think?

Comments (2)

CosmicConservative
I've said before that given the choice between Europes immigration problems and our immigration problem, I'd take ours any day of the week. I am one of those who believes that the immigrant population from Mexico on balance provides positive impacts to the US. This is why it has gone more or less unchallenged for so long. Plus it is an important safety valve for Mexico that has helped keep the lid on a potentially explosive political situation there. Having said that, I don't like it much in spite of how little I find to be alarmed about. I don't like having our laws ignored and mocked. I don't like the fact that although the overwhelming majority of illegal immigrants are hard-working decent folk, a significant number of them are hardened criminals who have done irreparable harm to law-abiding US citizens. In general I am a believer in obeying the law (thus the "conservative" part of "rational conservative"). This includes laws I don't like. So rewarding lawbreakers bothers me on principal. If I were "immigration czar" for this country I'd do the following, more or less in this order: 1. Announce that the U.S. would start enforcing immigration laws strictly, with particular emphasis placed on U.S. citizens breaking those laws (primarily employers). Then I would actually do it. 2. Build several miles of strategic fences along the border in the areas where the most inconvenience to the border crossing could be achieved with the least investment of time and materials. 3. Buy a fleet of robot camera airplanes and helicoptors and patrol the border with them, using them to spot illegal crossings and arrest and deport them immediately. 4. Work out a workable program where Mexican nationals could legally come to this country and do the work they want to do and we need them to do. But do this by rewarding the legal applicants first. 5. Repeal, revoke or refuse to recognize the provision in the Constitution that says you are a US citizen if your mother steps over the border while in labor, just to get a free pass to this country. Most of these would take some actual investment, but nothing close to the investment we've made in Iraq. Through all of this I would be working hard in diplomatic channels with Mexico to focus on the joint benefits of creating a legal way to accomplish what both societies have been doing illegally for my entire lifetime.
Dadman
I disdain illegal immigration too for all the reasons you've mentioned. The fact that the MSM and illegal immigration advocates continue to frame the argument in terms of civil or human rights when the issue is clearly and simply illegal vs. legal immigration REALLY annoys me. I'm just not sure that even the levels of illegal immigration we are witnessing spells doom for our nation as Buchanan argues. I think I'll read his book so I am better informed on all the nuances of his thesis...and hope he is wrong...