Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NFL 2011 week 9

By CosmicConservative
Well, last week I complained because, of the roughly even dozen games I was interested in during the weekend, only one of them ended up being a victory for the team I was rooting for. This week is almost the reverse. Not quite (because I didn't have nearly as many games I was interested in) but still of the games I did care about, only one of the teams I was rooting for lost (NY Giants beat the NE Patriots in Foxborough). Probably the game with the most interesting story line for me was the Broncos/Raiders game. This is a game that the Broncos were supposed to get embarrassed in (as they did last week vs. Detroit). The local sports station personalities were almost universal in predicting a blowout of such monstrous proportion that Tim Tebow would be demoted to the bench by halftime and his career in the NFL would be over forever. Instead Tebow had a 98.3 QB rating, threw for two touchdowns, ran for over 100 yards and directed a confusing option-style offense that seemed to completely befuddle and overwhelm a Raiders team who had until then been pretty good against the run. In the end the Broncos ran for almost 300 yards, with Willis McGehee having over 160 and Tim Tebow having almost 120. Tebow fans have for two years been saying "let the guy play his style of football and he will win!" Well, yesterday I think it's fair to say that Tebow played his style of football and won. Now, that doesn't mean that other teams won't watch the tape and figure out how to stuff that style in future games, but for whatever it is worth, in three games so far this season Tim Tebow has won twice as many games as Kyle Orton won in five games, and in Tebow's first six overall NFL starts his results make John Elway's first six overall NFL starts look downright embarrassing. I had this listed as a loss for the Broncos in my prognostications for the rest of the season, but had also listed this as one of the games they would have to win to reach five total wins for the season. The amazing thing is that at 3-5 for the year at the halfway point of the season, the Broncos are right in the midst of the AFC West race since the other teams are all 4-4. If Denver somehow manages to pull off a miracle upset against Kansas City in KC next weekend, then they will be at 4-5 and tied with two other teams with either Oakland or San Diego at 5-4. It may well end up being an interesting NFL season...

Comments (4)

Drax
Heh. KC absolutely SUCKED this week. Dunno what they will look like next week. But, it's one of the games I have listed as a likely win for an 8-8 season. PLAYOFFS BABY, PLAYOFFS!
Drax
The thing that gets me on the Teebow issue is this: The criticism on him is that he "can't" throw from the pocket (what pocket!!!?) as is required for an NFL QB. Huh? Tell every NFL QB (especially Peyton Manning) that you can't be successful with a high percentage of plays called from the shotgun. Remind Staubach/Landry of this "fact." But, beyond that, the PROBLEM is that, in the minds of the coaches/management, Teebow doesn't fit the "prototypical" NFL QB. What utter crap. You have the players you have. Those players have the skillsets they have. You make your game plans so to play to the strengths of their skillsets and minimize the weaknesses. Pretty frippin' simple. You have Emmit Smith? Cool. Unfortunately, you believe that the "prototypical" RB in the NFL is one who bounces to the edges rather than one who pounds out the yards between the tackles. So, you make a gameplan which attempts to force Smith to conform to your preconceived notions of what is the "prototypical" NFL running back rather than conforming your game plan to his skill set. Yeah. That's smart. Or, Randy Moss. You believe that the prototypical WR is one who runs across the middle (Wes Welker - Michael Irvin - Keyshawn Johnson) and not one who tries to "stretch the field". So, you have Randy and send him across the middle time after time. This notion that Teebow needs to learn "how to play QB" is just STUPID. In 2010 in three games, he was 1-2 with a horrid team. He was 5/3 TD/Int. Oh, wait! He was 11/3 cause he RAN for 6. In 2011, in four games, he is 2-2 with an even WORSE team. He has 8/1 TD/Int rate. (9/1 with his single rushing TD). Just think! He could be like Peyton and set a rookie record for interceptions! Or go 1/15 like Aikman. Oh, wait. He can't, because he's ALREADY BETTER THAN THEY ARE relative to winning and taking care of the ball.
CosmicConservative
No argument from me Drax... By the way, I again this weekend heard the argument that we should have higher expectations for Tim Tebow than we had for John Elway because Elway was teh "consensus #1 pick" and Tebow was projected to go in the third round... I still can't quite wrap my brain around what sort of mind would come up with that argumetn...
Andy
The mind that could conceive that argument is the lib sports media. They hate the guy. He will prove them to be foolish, and blinded by bias. Timbow is just one of those guys...he will go about his job in a workmanlike fashion...everybody with a platform will throw darts...he'll dodge them by just being Timbow. Eventually, the dart throwers will get tired of it, find another target, and remind everyone of just HOW MUCH they believed in the guy. (Trust me...all the detractors have said a nice thing or two about him that they've saved links to...just in case). Even though I'm not an NFL watcher, it is interesting to see this thing unfold (thanks for the update/news). I did not know the Broncos are now 3-5. They could easily end up in the playoffs. Jeepers...short of it is, the guy is just good. I listened for 4 years down here in the SEC how, "Well, he's a great college QB, but he'll never make it in the pros!" BS