Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The perfect Tebow game today...

By CosmicConservative
Heh... Tim Tebow looked like a total and complete bust for 55 minutes of today's game. He even fumbled the ball once, but was lucky that the Broncos recovered. Every Tebow hater in the nation was salivating at the opportunity to throw a fusillade of "I told you so's" at the Tebow fanbase. Virtually every sports reporter in Denver was gleefully polishing off their Tebow deconstruction as the final minutes ticked off the game clock with Denver down 15 - 0, Tebow's QB rating hovering around 45 or so and Miami looked to be saving Tony Sporano's job for another week. Then, as if on schedule, Miami went to a prevent defense and Tim Tebow suddenly became Joe Montana. An 80 yard drive and it was 15 - 7 with less than three minutes left. An onside kick. Denver recovers a fumble, then Tebow leads a 50+ yard drive to make it 15-13, and then waltzes into the end zone with 17 seconds left on a successful two point conversion to tie the game and take it to overtime. I am sure that wet, percussive sound I heard was the exploding heads of millions of Tebow haters across the nation, heck, across the WORLD who simply could not process what their eyes were telling them. The winning field goal in overtime was really pretty much anti-climactic at that point. I have said for years that the main thing I really like about Tim Tebow is how he drives all the right people absolutely insane. The beauty of today's game is that all the Tebow haters have plenty of ammunition from this game to keep calling Tebow a terrible NFL QB. I'm already seeing the general Tebow hater narrative coming out, which is that Miami threw the game on purpose to keep their hopes alive for Andrew Luck. Personally Tebow played about like I expected him to today, as did the Broncos. I don't know how many calm and rational sports analysts will bother to look at this objectively, but those who do should notice the following things about the game today:
  • The Broncos look to have implemented a significantly different offense for Tebow. Not just a few plays here or there, they look to have introduced several new plays, and new blocking schemes, etc. That takes time for the team to get used to. Assuming they stick to it, I expect the team to execute better as they get more used to the scheme and to Tebow's habits.
  • The Broncos offensive line is still a horrible unit. They couldn't protect Tebow on three-man rushes during the prevent defense. If anything the Bronco's offensive line has been over rated, and they are acknowledged as one of the worst in the NFL.
  • Tebow definitely still has some "deer in headlights" reactions to defensive schemes. However, for the most part today, he managed to avoid turning the ball over.
  • Denver's defense is still, and always has been, the key to Denver improving as a team this year. Today the defense kept them in the game long enough for Tebow to pull a miracle out of his back pocket. I will be surprised if that ends up being the only time it happens this year.
  • This game would never have gone into overtime if Matt Prater had not missed two makable field goals in the first half.
If nothing else, Denver games are going to be entertaining this year.

Comments (19)

Drax
Wish I could have seen it. All I really got out of it was two things: 1) When they went to no-huddle, Tebow made things happen (regardless of the "prevent defense" which didn't prevent...) 2) He don't give up.
CosmicConservative
I think the "he don't give up" narrative will be more and more important as things go on, because Denver has a tough schedule for the rest of the year. I believe that when the schedules for this year were announced, Denver's schedule was rated as the most difficult schedule of any team, and that was before Detroit suddenly became an elite team. Denver has the Lions, Patriots, Jets, Chicago, Buffalo and Minnesota as their non-division games left this year. Their combined record so far is 23-17. Take Minnesota out of that and their combined record is 22-11. Then they have two games against KC and one more each against Oakland and San Diego. Given Denver's current state, just looking at relative strengths against opponents, it is hard to see Denver winning three more games. Maybe they beat KC at home, take Minnesota on the road and steal one against either Oakland or San Diego on the road. That would give them a 5-11 record, and would give Tebow a 4-7 record for the season. Quite honestly I would consider that to be a reasonable goal for the Broncos. If they end up 6-10, I think that's a major improvement over last year, and 7-9 would be near miraculous. Although I have to say I would love it dearly if they were to manage to beat da Bears... At least they have that game in Denver, so maybe there's a chance.
CosmicConservative
8/8? Are you delusional? Let's say they manage to split their division games, something they haven't done in years. That would mean beating Oakland in Oakland and San Diego in San Diego and splitting their two remaining games against KC, we'll say they win their home game and lose on the road. That puts them at 5 wins. Of course that means they go 3-1 in their remaining divisional games against San Diego, Oakland and KC who are currently a combined 11 - 8 against basically the same teams that the Broncos are currently 2-4 against. Give them Minnesota as the most likely win against a non-division opponent. That gets them to six. That means to get to 8-8 they would have to win two of the following games: - New England (5 - 1) - Detroit (5-2) - Buffalo (4-2) - Chicago (4-3) Let's say that they manage to somehow win just TWO of their remaining divisional games (more than I actually expect them to, but within the realm of possibility). Then they have to win THREE of those non-divisional games I listed. I just don't see it. If they manage to pull that off, especially if it is clearly due to Tebow's play, I will have to hop on the Tebow bus. But right now I stand by my previous posts. A 4-12 season is probably what will happen. 5-11 is a major surprise and step up. 6-10 is a turnaround worthy of note. 7-9 is a friggin' miracle. 8-8 is pure divine intervention.
CosmicConservative
Oh yeah, that "probable win" in their schedule against Minnesota? Well Minnesota pushed the unbeaten Green Bay Packers to the limit today. They are better than their record. The Broncos are not. Not yet.
Drax
Okay. Here's my thinking. First, this season is weird. Kansas City S.U.C.K.E.D. for the first four games of the season. Maybe they still do. They sure in heck CAN be the suckage. That's the possibility of 2 wins. I think he can win them both. Vikings are the suckage. That's another win. That puts them at 5 wins. Only need three more for 8-8. Which Detroit team shows up next week? They have lost two in a row and can't stop the run and can't stop the pass. Oakland got shut out by the Chiefs this week. Won last week on a prayer. Carson Palmer hasn't had a good season since 2006. The Jets? They can be beat. Almost were by a not-so-good San Diego team and should have been. Which Sanchez will show up? Can they stop Plaxico, the only legitimate weapon who can make Sanchez look like a NFL QB? Then San Diego. See above. Got beat by the Jets. Barely beat Denver. Barely beat KC. What team shows up? Then the Bears and Bills. Either game is winnable. I give Denver a good shot at winning 8 if things fall into place.
CosmicConservative
I concur with all the weaknesses you have described. Denver's weaknesses are far worse than any of them.
Drax
But, Denver has Tebow and they don't. Hah! +1 and Lol in your general direction!
CosmicConservative
So I had an email exchange today with a local sports reporter who has been one of the Tebow bashers that claims to have no anti-Tebow bias. So, after he and his partner on air today viciously attacked Tebow's first three quarters, sneering openly about his less than 50% passing rating (4 of 10) during that period, I instant messaged them about their tiresome Tebow-bashing. Of course he accused ME of having a bias against HIM because he was so sure he had no Tebow bias. So I sent him stats from John Elway, Steve Young, Michael Vick, Troy Aikman, Brett Favre and one other QB showing how ALL OF THEM except Favre had a lower than 50% passing percentage FOR THEIR FIRST FOUR ENTIRE GAMES, not just three quarters of ONE game. Then I dared him to write a column comparing Tebow's first four games to John Elway's first four games. In doing so I pointed out that after Elway's first season, where he started ELEVEN GAMES, Elway's passer rating was barely above 50, his percentage completion rate was 47.5%, he threw 14 interceptions and 7 touchdowns and somehow he still managed to be considered a quality QB for a Broncos team which had been to the Super Bowl less than a decade earlier. Essentially I showed how Tebow's first four games, from a pure statistical comparison, are roughly TWICE AS GOOD as Elway's first four games. I'll see if he has the guts to do it.
Andy
That'd be interesting if the guy did write something factual. I'm no NFL fan, but I'm happy for Timbow. I have a suspicion that he will prove the gaggle wrong over many seasons of success. The guy's a winner. It's just that simple.
Drax
I don't know if Tebow will be a successful NFL QB. But, I know, without qualification, that if he isn't - it won't be his fault. I don't know how many 1st round QB's wound up on the dustbin of history after being drafted by a horrible team which stayed horrible as an institutional paradigm. Dozens surely. Just as surely as how many late round picks (or non-drafted free agents) who have become stars and even legends because they had the good fortune to fall into a good system. If Denver actually tailors its offensive scheme to play to Tebow's strengths while bringing him along as a pocket passer, then he will have success in Denver - and Denver will have success with him. If, instead, Denver treats him (as they did last week I maintain) the same way that Vince Young was treated in Tennessee, then he will suffer the same fate - but more quickly than did Young. Hey Young could have stayed on Tampa and we wouldn't have to listen to him jabber on about how Tebow has to become a pocket passer. Yeah, Young. That's what YOU'RE known for. (I have always maintained that his passer rating is so high because he was ABLE to run in situations where other QBs either had to throw the ball away or attempt a bad throw and be intercepted.) Had he stayed with Tampa, we never would have heard of him. Hey Elway! Maybe you could have gone with Colts and be remembered for - being drafted by the Colts. Hey Brady! Good thing Bledsoe got hurt in HIS superbowl run. Nice gig if you can get it - just ask Cassell.
Drax
Uh...just realized that I had two "Youngs" in that rant. The Tampa one is, of course, HOFer Steve Young.
CosmicConservative
@Drax - Yeah, I figured out the dual Young references. I'm a little miffed at Elway for his comments about Tebow. If I had a platform where I could ask Elway a question, I would ask him this one. "John, why is it that you are setting a standard for Tebow's success that would have put YOU on the bench and probably traded YOU to a different team after two full YEARS with the Broncos? Are you aware that your first two NFL seasons were so abysmal that you were then compared to some of the worst NFL draft busts in history? Why the Tebow hate John? Do you want Andrew Luck that badly? What happens if you get Luck and he ends up performing as badly as YOU DID when you started in the NFL? Will you abandon him as quickly as you seem prepared to abandon Tebow?"
Yup
Bledsoe never had the killer instinct to win a Superbowl. Cassel and the Patriots are a perfect example of tuning your offense to fit the capabilities of your QB. Alex Smith's a great example of how badly it can go if you don't.
Drax
Smith's not a bad example of how it can go when you do, as well...
CosmicConservative
I was listening to another sports talk show on the way home from my writing class tonight. The points I made above about Aikman, Elway and others was actually brought up. The anti-Tebow guy's argument at that point became "Well, those guys were consensus #1 draft picks, and Tebow wasn't even certain to get picked at all!" So I'm thinking.... OK, so when someone comes into the NFL with the expectation that he is the best player in the draft, that means our expectations for that player should be LESS than for someone that we thought wouldn't even be drafted at all?" I mean... how many brain cells does it take to come up with that argument? Geebuz... Sometimes I am just stunned by the stupidity I hear on the radio...
Drax
I really don't understand why anyone anymore gives much credence to where anyone is taken in the draft - especially quarterbacks. It's a coin flip as to whether even the #1 overall QB pick will end up even being a starting QB let alone a good one.
Yup
(to Cosmic's thinking and Drax's post - not what the radio idiot said).