Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Experts Fault Reasoning in Surveillance Decision - New York Times

By CosmicConservative
Experts Fault Reasoning in Surveillance Decision - New York Times
Even legal experts who agreed with a federal judge’s conclusion on Thursday that a National Security Agency surveillance program is unlawful were distancing themselves from the decision’s reasoning and rhetoric yesterday. They said the opinion overlooked important precedents, failed to engage the government’s major arguments, used circular reasoning, substituted passion for analysis and did not even offer the best reasons for its own conclusions.
Am I the only one wondering if the reason this judge got this case is because her political views and her general lack of legal competence were well known? Heh, am I the only one wondering if her political views and general lack of legal competence are closely related phenomena?

Comments (4)

Avery Davis
Every article that I've read on this says that legal experts left, right, and center have suggested Judge Taylor is at least competent to extremely well qualified. I suspect she know this case is going to be appealed and will almost certainly end up in the Supreme Court and she intentionally delivered a weak rational to assure the next higher court has good reason to re-examine the case. Also, knowing that the Specter-Cheney bill is threateing to send all cases dealing with the illegal wire tapping back to the FISA court without a chance to examine the constitutionality of the president's actions, Judge Taylor went over the top in expressing her opinion hoping the reaction would propel the case through the courts faster. If the Specter-Cheney legislation passes before any of the wire tap cases make it to the SCOTUS, we won't get a ruling on the core issue - does the president have inherint authority under the Constitution to issue wire taps on Americans.
CosmicConservative
You are awful generous to this judge whose own side says has issued a blindingly stupid argument. Do you really believe that you have to issue a stupid ruling to get the notice of higher courts? Yes, I think you are right that she gave this a casual effort because she knew it was going to get appealed anyway, but that is sort of the definition of incompetence, isn't it? As far as FISA is concerned, don't be surprised if the SCOTUS rules that to be unconstitutional. Bush is not the first President to say it does not apply to the Executive Branch, Clinton said exactly the same thing. Don't be too sure that the SCOTUS might not take up the core question here. This has been festering between the Legislative and Executive branches for decades. Since the War Powers Act, at least. I am not usually a fan of the SCOTUS ruling on major issues, but when the other two branches are clearly at odds, that's when the SCOTUS should weigh in. Maybe they will.
Avery Davis
SCOTUS can't evaluate the core question unless a case is appealed to it, which is why I believe Judge Taylor is trying to move the case along quickly. She issues a blatently over the top opinion hoping the defence will opt for a direct appeal to the next higher court instead of dragging the case out in her court. Nothing Judge Taylor has done in the past suggest she's incompetent, a 1st year law student wouldn't issue a ruling without citing precedence or revelant statutes, and this ruling is a total screed against the defense. I know it's easy to just rant and rave 'blah blah liberals blah A.C.L.U. blah blah activists judges', but how about some intellegent debate about why a federal judge would issue an opinion that would make any law student blush?
CosmicConservative
Avery: Again you seem to be asserting that Ann Taylor believes that demonstration of rank incompetence is the best way to get a decision appealed. This is nonsense. Why don't you try that logic on an actual judge and see what he/she says? I don't believe I said a word about the ACLU, I simply said that Judge Taylor's ruling was lambasted by right and left together. You are the one defending it, and defending it by claiming that an incompetent decision is some sort of strategy move. You're full of it this time Avery.