Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Tebow mania...

By CosmicConservative
So I haven't commented much on the NFL season yet this year. I could have commented on Brett Favre's churlish comments about Aaron Rodgers, and how classy Rodgers was in responding to them. Or I could point out that Jay Cutler continues to be mired in mediocrity at quarterback. Or I could talk about how Tony Romo has been channeling the good, and more importantly, the bad of Brett Favre. Or I could comment on the struggles of Michael vick, or the startling rise of the Detroit Lions... But instead I'll focus a little closer to home. In yesterday's Denver Broncos game vs. the San Diego Chargers, Kyle Orton was so dismal (QB rating of 27 I think) in the first half, that new coach John Fox decided to, what the heck, send Tebow in to see if he could spark the team. And spark the team he did. Tebow almost led an unlikely comeback and did manage to make the game a nail-biter quite literally to the last second before San Diego managed to walk away with a 29-24 victory. Tebow's numbers weren't stellar, 4 of 10 for 78 yards or something like that, but he did pass for one touchdown and run for another, and much more importatly, he turned a rout into a competitive game. So now the town is all abuzz with rumors of Tim Tebow becoming the starting QB for the rest of the year. That might happen, but so far the Broncos front office and coaching staff has been much less than complimentary when discussing Tim Tebow's potential QB role. In fact in my opinion they have gone out of their way to talk Tebow down, constantly talking about how Tebow has not mastered the pocket, how his throwing mechanics are still not NFL QB standard, and how he tends to tuck and run with the ball while the potential for a completion still exists. I dunno about all that. It's probably all true. But what I do know is that in the four or five games Tebow has played, he has made them all fun to watch. And isn't this whole game supposed to be about having fun? Anyway, I don't have a lot invested in Tebow, and I still think Denver's problems do not start with who receives the snap from center. But just from a pure fun perspective I prefer Tebow to any of Denver's recent quarterbacks. Cutler was whiny, petulant and immature. Orton is cold, quiet and lacks a strong arm. Tebow just brings an energy and optimism to the game that is downright palpable. I say let him play. Most of his problems yesterday were the sort you would expect from a backup QB who sees few reps in practice with the first team. Give him time to practice and play with the first team and I suspect a lot of those bounced passes or overthrows will go away. Denver has a bye this coming weekend, so the opportunity to debate the QB position has never been better. I don't dislike Orton and would be fine to see him continue as the starter, but I think he is a well-known commodity and his skills are adequate but not stellar, and he has very little spark to fire up the team. We just need to see what Tebow can do given a real opportunity, and if a 1-4 cellar dwelling team isn't the right place to feel out a new QB, I don't know what is...

Comments (17)

Drax
The guy knows how to win, if winning's possible. Dang near pulled it out yesterday, and, had he gotten the pass interference call in the end zone as he should have (dunno why they won't call that on hail mary's) he would have won it.
Andy
I don't follow the NFL, but I remember hearing for three full college seasons, "Yeah, the guy's a great college QB...but he'll NEVER make it in the pros!" Monors.
CosmicConservative
Well, as of this morning Tim Tebow is officially the starting quarterback of the Denver Broncos. So I guess by definition he "made it" in the pros. He's listed on the roster as the team's #1 QB. Now it remains to be seen what Tebow does with this opportunity. I have mixed feelings about Tebow. I love his story and root for him to succeed. I really like his "intangibles" which to me are not intangible at all. Anyone who follows my postings about football in general, and quarterbacks in particular, knows that I greatly value leaders who raise the level of play of the people around them. A great deal of success in sports has to do with confidence and swagger. Tebow brings that confidence and swagger. By all accounts he has done something that is nearly impossible in pro sports today. He has managed to win the team over even though the team was quite happy with the QB he is replacing. Everyone says the same thing, which is that he's just a genuinely nice guy who truly wants to see everyone do their best. I'm not one of those who agonizes over things like throwing mechanics and foot placement. Sure they are important, but the number of NFL QBs who were criticized severely for their play style and who ended up in the Hall of Fame is legend anyway. A short list of QBs who heard a lot of the same comments about their play that Tebow hears about his would include John Elway, Steve Young, Michael Vick, Cam Newton, Randall Cunningham, Ben Roethlesberger, Doug Flutie.... I wish Tebow the best. I think he will find it more difficult to defeat defenses that are designed specifically to contain him. He will have to learn to be a pocket passer to succeed because that's what you have to do when the opposing team stacks eight men on the line and dares you to try to scramble. And that's exactly what they will try to do with Tebow. It's probably good that his first game as the starter will be in a very friendly atmosphere. At halftime in the Denver-Miami game the 2009 National Champion Florida Gaters, for whom Tim Tebow was the QB, will be honored. There will be quite a bit of pro-Tebow sentiment even among the Dolphins fans.
Drax
What I get a kick out of is the specious knock on Tebow's mechanics, when, frankly, what they don't like is ... Tebow. He is a white QB who wears his religion on his sleeve. Only blacks can do that. Here's a scouting report on Tebow before he was drafted: "often works out from the shotgun, and lacks top-shelf arm strength. Has an elongated throwing motion, and throws sidearm way too often, so his basic mechanics will need to be restructured. Footwork is awkward and, when forced to work from under center, is clearly uncomfortable. Too impatient in the pocket and will yank the ball down, try to ad-lib, especially when his top option isn't available to him." Oh, wait...that's the scouting report on KYLE ORTON! http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/draft05/columns/story?columnist=pasquarelli_len&page=qb_ratings
CosmicConservative
Fixed it for you. It is pretty hilarious how Orton's scouting report reads almost word-for-word how people knock Tim Tebow...
Andy
Drax, I am really glad you posted that link (and that Cosmic fixed it). I REALLY needed to read that. It has nothing to do with football...just something I'm going through, and working out in my head. And Cosmic, I really appreciate your comment at 11:02...you're talking about a guy that just "tries hard." I've got that same kind of respect for Timbow. Sheesh! It would take WAY too long to 'splain that idiotic comment. But, thanks to both of you guys.
CosmicConservative
Oh, a quick comment on Tebow mania, both for and against. I don't know about the "black" part of the equation, but the Christian part of the equation is clear. The divide between Tebow haters and Tebow fans is almost exactly the same divide as liberal vs conservative. Virtually EVERY media figure in Denver is anti-Tebow. They sneer, they insult, they make derogatory comments they think are cleverly disguised but are transparent as glass. The number of Denver radio personalities I have heard laughing at Tebow after Orton won the starting position is pretty high. Those same people insisted that Brady Quinn was above Tebow on the depth chart. But when push came to shove, Coach Fox didn't put Quinn in the game, he put Tebow in. I have to admit that one of the main reasons that I want to see Tebow be a huge success in the NFL is that it will piss off all the right people.
Drax
Gotta wonder about Denver's Front Office (Elway especially) motivations here. If we assume that they were being honest when they said that Orton provided the best chance to win, and, up until the moment the change to Tebow was made, they maintained that position, then, substituting Tebow for Orton makes the team WORSE in THEIR (often repeated and clearly stated) OPINION. And, Elway's explanation was not, in any way, an endorsement of Tebow as being a better option than Orton. He didn't even ATTEMPT to claim that Tebow's substitution made the team better. Therefore, why the change? The first thing that went through my head was that they might be getting into the Andrew Luck sweepstakes. The second thing was that they have given up on the season, and they are putting in Tebow to let him fail so to shut up the fans so they can get on with running the team without the constant pressure to put Tebow in the game. In either case, the RESULT would be, if they are RIGHT (that Tebow is a downgrade for the team) then they appear to be purposefully attempting to make the team worse - so to have a chance in the Andrew Luck sweepstakes. But, could that be true? Would the front office of an NFL team PURPOSEFULLY make moves to make their team WORSE? Hard to believe in football (happens all the time in baseball and basketball). But... They just put Brandon Lloyd, the single legitimate receiver they have, on the trading block. So, that's TWO MOVES they have made which, in the eyes of every pundit (just about) makes the team worse. The ONLY THING LEFT for them to do to solidify my almost opinion that they are intentionally downgrading their team so to have a chance at Andrew Luck would be their OFFENSIVE PLAY CALLING while Tebow is under center. If they don't style their offense to Tebow's strengths and, instead, TO HIS WEAKNESSES, then there will no longer be any question. They have two weeks to design a game plan for their next game. I'm really curious to see what they do...
CosmicConservative
The stated reasons for Lloyd's trade trial balloons are 1. The new offense they are putting in is designed to exploit Tebow's strengths and that isn't nearly as much a passing offense as the Orton offense was. 2. Eric Decker has been one of the very few bright points for the Broncos this year, he has developed into a legitimate threat at WR himself, plus they have Eddie Royal coming back from injury, and he looked awfully good himself before he went down with an injury last year. Plus they have a new young WR in Demarius Thomas who looks pretty promising. 3. Mostly because of #2 the Broncos front office is hoping to trade for one (or more) of the many positions that they are truly weak by cashing in on one of the very few positions where they have some depth. The idea is that losing Lloyd leaves them with a still solid WR corps, while adding some defensive line strength (for example) really helps an area where they are suffering badly. Last week Denver started rookies in three of four defensive line positions. Alternatively they would look for more offensive line strength to play into Tebow's style of extending plays and running the ball. I saw the Lloyd thing and while my immediate reaction was much like yours, I can actually see the rationale here. It's not absolutely certain this is an entry into the Andrew Luck sweepstakes.
CosmicConservative
Don't be surprised to see Orton himself on the trading block...
Drax
Too much money for him. Couldn't even trade him to Miami before THIS season... As to the stated reasons...they're the stated reasons. I give them no more weight than any other statement from a front office. We'll see. I hope they give him a chance. If they do, they'll be out of the sweepstakes for sure.
CosmicConservative
I think there's a better than average chance that even if they do keep the current offensive game plan, even without Brandon Lloyd, Tebow will outperform Orton and win more games that Orton would have. As QB of the Broncos Orton managed to win his first six games (coincidentally before McDaniels' coaching staff was discovered filming opponents illegally) but since then he is something like 6 - 22 or so. Tebow can lose two out of three games and still have a better win-loss ratio than Orton. I doubt Denver will be in the Luck sweepstakes regardless.
Drax
I'm betting on 8-8, hoping on 9-7. He can win some of the close games. Going to try to pick him up in my fantasy leagues for bye weeks...
CosmicConservative
I don't play fantasy football. I do know that Tebow scores somewhat better in the new ESPN "Total QB rating" than in the old "Passer rating" system which is biased towards pocket passers. If fantasy football scoring is biased in the same way (which seems possible since it was probably in part based on the passer rating system) then Tebow may not be the best way to win a fantasy football game even if he helps Denver win games. I personally do think that Tebow will help the Broncos and the reason why is that the main problem that the Broncos have had in the Orton era has been a total incompetence in the red zone. Orton has pretty good stats between the 20 yard lines, but in the red zone he is abysmal. I believe he was the worst rated red zone QB in the league last year, and this year he has been worse. I believe there's a reason for that, and that reason is that Orton's style of play is particularly vulnerable to the collapsing of defenses close to the goal line. He does not have a laser arm, so he can't thread the needle like a Manning, Brady or even a Romo. He has to rely on precision route running, and that gets harder and harder as the zones shrink. Plus he is about as mobile as a fork lift and rarely is able to extend a play with his feet to allow pass protection to break down. I don't remember the last time he had a run for a touchdown from more than a yard or two out. And on top of all of that, Orton has a very fast clock, so he does his reads, and if there is nothing open, he dumps the ball and settles for a field goal. I've seen so many plays where a Tebow would keep the play alive for ten seconds or more, and Orton does his reads and dumps the ball and trots to the sideline. That alone is going to mean more touchdowns for Denver with Tebow in the game. Or at least that's my take. I like Orton, but Orton will never be a red zone QB. He needs a running game to smash the ball in, and Denver simply doesn't have that facet to their game right now. Tebow is probably their best red zone runner by far.
CosmicConservative
I think 7-9 would be viewed even by Tebow's detractors as a huge victory for Tebow. I think 5-11 is far more realistic. And more than enough to show Tebow is capable to play in this league given a team without the gaping holes the Broncos have.