Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (24)

Drax
Now, now - don't get all sue happy. Plaintiffs' lawyers are already ruining this country. After all, why would Google be responsible for the criminal acts of a third party when, in your opinion, a parent shouldn't be responsible for the foreseeable negligent acts of his children which cause damage to another while they are under his supervision? All that "consistency" stuff...
CosmicConservative
Hmmm... not sure it's accurate to characterize my position as one of not holding parents accountable for foreseeable negligent acts... we might not agree on what "foreseeable" means... The question here, in my mind, is if google should be held accountable for their part in providing a means for criminals to target specific houses for burglary using high resolution photos of a person's house and property. I'm not quite getting the accusation of inconsistency.
Drax
For purposes of fairness and clarity, I'm only referring to your notion that the parent on the ski slope who allowed his child to ski in an area where he could run into adults - and did - and the adult got hurt - and sued. You were opposed to that very much as I recall. I don't know if you can argue that when a small child who didn't know how to ski (and the parent knew this) was in an area where others were skiing - it isn't foreseeable that the child might run into an adult and that collision might cause an injury. But, that's just me. I'd think that a reasonable parent, when he put a small child who didn't know how to ski on skis - he'd do so in an area where the child couldn't cause accidents with others. Foreseeability is the linchpin of negligence. Here, with Google, there is something more - there is the general legal principle that one cannot be held to be liable for the CRIMINAL acts of others, since CRIMINAL ACTS are, in general, deemed to be inherently unforeseeable. (I know it's not entirely true as we all know that it's entirely foreseeable that some criminals would use (and have used) Google or Craig's list or ANY OTHER service or good for criminal purposes. But, as a society, we have to construct tort law so that it doesn't unnecessarily DISCOURAGE the creation of and the use of valuable societal services and goods JUST BECAUSE we "know" that they will be used, by some, for criminal purposes. The societal cost is too high.) The kid on skis, however, doesn't have the same societal implications. We WANT parents to keep a watch on their children so that they don't pose a threat to themselves or others...
CosmicConservative
Just for purposes of Clarity. If you go skiing on a public slope, you are taking a conscious decision to put yourself at risk of a collision with another skier. If you buy a house you are not making a conscious decision to put yourself at risk of having your property photographed for the use of criminals to identify a best path to burglarize your house. In the case of the 8 year old boy, skiing on the green slopes, colliding with an 80 year old man, it is my opinion that the 80 year old man was taking an known risk in getting on skis and going down the slope. I see no inconsistency whatsoever in my opinions.
Drax
You are conflating ASSUMPTION of the risk (which would assume that the RISK IS COMMONLY KNOWN) with the foreseeability of the risk. The homeowner has done nothing, thus, could not assume any risk. The skier, on the other hand, is on the slopes and assumes some risk. Assumption of the risk is a legitimate DEFENSE to the CAUSE OF ACTION (Negligence) but it, by it's very nature, ADMITS the risk. (If there is no risk, then there can be no assumption of it.) A good case for examination of the legal theory of assumption of the risk (and negligence in general) is the famous case of the McDonald's hot coffee spilled in old lady's lap case. (Liebeck v. McDonald's Restaurants). From the Assumption of the Risk defense perspective, McDonald's argued (successfully) that the Plaintiff KNEW that "coffee was hot" and, therefore, had ASSUMED THE RISK of injury when it spilled into her lap. The jury agreed (but was couched in terms of "comparative negligence" which, factually was a recognition that she knew the risk, assumed it, but not completely). When Assumption of the risk is at issue, you must ask: "What risk was assumed?" In the McDonald's case, the risk was that "coffee was hot." All injuries which might flow from the assumed risk ("hot coffee") was on the PLAINTIFF'S head. But, since the coffee was not only "hot," but "superheated," THAT RISK was not contemplated by that customer when she purchased coffee from McDonald's, and, therefore, the injuries from THAT risk were not ASSUMED. In the case of the skier, the 80 year old man was on slopes (actually 60) where he could reasonably expect to encounter certain risks (most based on his own competence and decision making). One is NEVER responsible for the negligence of ANOTHER (well, almost never). That's like saying: "Well, I know he ran the red light and killed your mother, but, you were on the road, and you know that sometimes people run red lights, so you have no cause of action because you assumed the risk that someone would be negligent and kill your mother. The CHILD (8 years old) was UNSUPERVISED. On a ski slope. Where other people were skiing. Had an ADULT been flying around the area "recklessly and dangerously" without regard to the health and safety of others and ran into someone, then - what? The poor sap who was abiding by the rules of the place but didn't see the jerk who wasn't IS WITHOUT RECOURSE? In this case, the CHILD was acting recklessly and without regard for the health and safety of others and injured someone. So, it's what? Too bad, so sad, you shouldn't be on the slopes because you ought to know that the idiots will run over you?
Drax
On the other hand, in the Google case, Google didn't do ANYTHING WRONG. It provided a service which someone ELSE intentionally abused for criminal purposes. Google was breaking no laws. Google was doing nothing wrong. Google is ONLY at fault if you hold it RESPONSIBLE FOR THE CRIMINAL ACTS OF A THIRD PARTY. Compare: You are unwilling to hold the parent (who wasn't supervising his 8 year old child) responsible for the acts of his child (or his own acts for failing to properly supervise the child) - but are willing to hold Google responsible for the criminal acts of a 3rd party for whom Google has no ability to control. Sigh. You really don't see the problem?
CosmicConservative
I just hope someone sues google and we get to see how the courts weigh in on their potential liability.
Drax
Ah, yes. Let the courts figure it out. Good conservative position!
CosmicConservative
Hmm... I wasn't aware that accepting the premise that 1/3 of our government has a purpose was anti-conservative...
Drax
No. Just get a kick out of the dissonance from conservatives who scream and holler about "activist judges" but, when another ox is being gored, they want to "let the courts decide." Understand. This would be making law.
CosmicConservative
No it wouldn't. It would be settling a personal injury lawsuit. It happens all the time. By this logic every time a jury ruled on some deep pocket minor player in a lawsuit, that would be "making law."
Drax
Clearly, you don't understand tort law. In tort law, you have essentially two kinds of causes of action: Those which are directly supported by statutes and those which are supported under case-law (aka "common law"). Common law is, in tort law, causes of action which a court has created a legal theory through which a Plaintiff may recover damages. In every case in which the Legislature hasn't created a direct cause of action but a Court has allowed one ... Every one ... there was the first time that a particular cause of action was recognized as a "cause of action" or a viable "legal theory." That is called "making law." Before the ruling, the cause of action didn't exist. After the ruling, it did. And, once it exists, it, no less than ANY statute, IS LAW. (Except in Louisiana where there is no "common law," even though stare decisis results in no significance difference from our English cousins.) Currently, there is, in most jurisdictions, the common law defense that one can NEVER be responsible for the criminal acts of a 3rd person over whom you have no control. Of course, Plaintiffs' lawyers don't like that bar to recovery and try to carve out exceptions. I have done so myself - successfully. Twice. In one case, I argued that the sued party was responsible for the criminal acts of a third person under a theory of "negligent entrustment." I won that one at the trial level and at the Appellate level. For two years, it was the LAW in the circuit in which I practiced. Then the LA Supremes overruled the decision. (I actually settled the other case AS A RESULT of the first as they argued similar legal theories.) That's called MAKING LAW, and it affects the citizens of the affected jurisdiction NO DIFFERENTLY than it would had the law been passed by the Legislature. Some examples: In Louisiana there is the seminal case Loescher v. Parr. Essentially, a tree on Parr's property fell onto Loescher's cadillac which was parked on a parking lot adjacent to Parr's property. It is important to understand the FACTS as the LA. Supreme court determined them to be. The Court found that it was a FACT that Mr. Parr had no knowledge that the tree had any defect. That is important. Without KNOWLEDGE of the tree's defect, Mr. Parr could not have done anything wrong, and, therefore, couldn't have any FAULT. Without FAULT, there is no NEGLIGENCE since, in Louisiana, it is Civil Code Article 2315 which imparts LIABILITY: La. CC Article 2315: "Every act whatever of man that causes damage to another obliges him by whose FAULT it happened to repair it." Without FAULT, there is no LIABILITY. And FAULT is based on KNOWLEDGE. Without knowledge of the defect in the tree, how can anyone be held to be at FAULT for not taking action to prevent its fall? But, the Tate court decided that it would not be constrained by article 2315, so decided to go against CENTURIES of French and Louisiana interpretation of article 2317, and allow the Plaintiff to recover SPECIFICALLY WITHOUT A FINDING OF FAULT on the part of the defendant. (The dissent in the case is withering.) So, thereafter, lawyers who wanted to find a way for their Plaintiffs to recover, would try to find some way for THEIR case to fall within the legal confines of LOESCHER V PARR, rather than THE STATUTE. THAT IS HOW THE LAW WORKS. We don't look to statutes in tort law. WE LOOK TO CASES. THE CASES ARE THE LAW. When we can find no cases, THEN we will attempt to find some LAW (doesn't matter if created by the bench or the legislature) which can be STRETCHED or INTERPRETED so that recovery can be had by the Plaintiffs. (Bivins v. Six Unnamed Agents of the FBI, for example) THIS CASE will likely MAKE LAW.
CosmicConservative
It is a FACT that Google KNEW that publishing photos of people's property at such a detailed level could be used by criminals to target individual homes. They KNEW this would happen and proceeded anyway.
Drax
I understand that a reasonable person could CONCLUDE that Google knew or should have known that a criminal could use its services for criminal ends. So, too, do knife manufacturers. And, Gun manufacturers. And, Car manufacturers. And Craig's list. And, the telephone company. And FedEX, UPS, Mailbox Etc., USPS And fertilizer manufacturers. And every landlord who rents to anyone. And gunpowder manufacturers. And bleach manufacturers. And Microsoft, Apple. Every MMORPG manufacturer. Every seller of mobile telephones. Every seller of electronic devices. Etc. Etc. Etc. Etc. It isn't a question of KNOWLEDGE (whether actual or imputed) in this case (or in the cases above - many of which have been litigated - and lost - for now) It's whether there should be LIABILITY for making, selling, or offering that service to the public EVEN THOUGH it might be used for criminal purposes. (The cases against the weapons manufacturers is most on point...) In cases such as this (and product liability cases, medical malpractice cases) the question is one of a weighing of SOCIAL UTILITY against the KNOWN RISK. The beginnings of this social calculus was first articulated by the famous Judge Learned Hand in U.S v. Carroll Towing in 1947. In that case he opined that a person's negligence rested on something more than simple "fault" or "knowledge" but HAD to have some other characteristics. He articulated that formula for negligence as follows: "[T]he owner's duty, as in other similar situations, to provide against resulting injuries is a function of three variables: (1) The probability that she will break away; (2) the gravity of the resulting injury, if she does; (3) the burden of adequate precautions. This formulation was later formalized in the law by an actual formula, explained as follows: "This relationship has been formalized by the law and economics school as such: an act is in breach of the duty of care if: B < PL where B is the cost (burden) of taking precautions, and P is the probability of loss (L). L is the gravity of loss. The product of P x L must be a greater amount than B to create a duty of due care for the defendant." (See, e.g., http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calculus_of_negligence) Later, this formula was further modified by SOCIAL UTILITY. This is normally called the "Hand Plus Test." (See, e.g. http://www.professordougholdenslawblog.com/2010/03/6-negligence-breach-of-duty-learned.html) So, in almost every jurisdiction (every one of which I'm aware) - once all these factors are weighed against each other, the conclusion for CENTURIES (well before the formula was ARTICULATED - but commonly understood by Judges, and, for that matter, by juries) - the conclusion was that, without actual knowledge and/or collusion - people (and companies) should not be held to be responsible for the criminal acts of 3rd persons over whom they have no control - whether or not the person (or company) knew or should have known that their product or service might be used for criminal purposes. Everyone KNOWS that criminals use guns, yet we don't hold gun manufacturers liable for this knowledge. Everyone KNOWS that cars are used in the commission of all kinds of crimes and are the instruments of violence in others, yet we don't hold the car manufacturers liable for these predictable criminal acts. Etc. And, this refusal to hold those companies liable for the criminal acts of 3rd persons over whom they have no control - obtains long after the companies have ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE (rather than Google's "knew or should have known") that their products/services would be and HAD BEEN used for such criminal enterprises. And the reason is the SOCIAL UTILITY of the service or good is SO GREAT that imposing liability on those companies represented too great a SOCIETAL BURDEN (as represented by the cost to the company to make the criminal acts impossible to perform - costs passed on to the consumer -- or actually putting the companies out of business because they are UNABLE to make criminal use of their products/services impossible. THIS is the question before the court in the Google case. The question is whether in THIS CASE they will CHANGE THAT LONG STANDING PRINCIPLE, one which has far reaching societal implications. For, if Google can be held liable for the acts of criminals who use their service for criminal ends and people are allowed to sue Google for failing to prevent that criminal use (that's the essence of the complaint because it's Google's knowledge of the likelihood of the criminal use FOLLOWED by the FAILURE TO PREVENT IT that would constitute "negligence.") ... Then, who is next? The SAME LEGAL THEORY could be used against ANY of the companies I listed above. THAT'S what is at stake when courts start "making law."
CosmicConservative
Unless I am badly mistaken the SAME LEGAL THEORY is ROUTINELY USED against the companies listed above. Sometimes SUCCESSFULLY.
CosmicConservative
I get your point Drax. I do think there are some differences between cars, guns, mailboxes, phone books, etc... and Google Maps and Streetview. The main difference, as I see it, is that Google is, imho, invading my privacy without my permission. None of these other companies are. Where is the "opt out" option for Google Maps? I can have an unlisted phone if I like. And if I have a phone number it's because I BOUGHT A PHONE. Google Maps takes photos of my house revealing potential vulnerabilities to criminals without my consent or even KNOWLEDGE. A gun can be used against me, but the sale of a gun does not TARGET me, except in rare cases, and in those cases when a gun sale TARGETS an individual, the seller of the gun CAN AND HAS BEEN held partially responsible for the damages (the guy who supplied guns to the Columbine shooters is IN JAIL). Anyway, I think there is a difference. I get your point, but I fundamentally believe Google is engaged in wholesale invasion of privacy. I don't believe they should have the RIGHT to do what they do. I used to go to great lengths to not have my address or location publicly available on the internet BECAUSE I didn't want child molestors or burglars to know where I lived. Google has taken that out of my hands. Now anyone with an internet connection can, at their leisure, examine my house and property to figure out the best way to do me harm.
Drax
You would have to point me to those cases. The ones of which I'm aware have not been successful. Has Ford been sued because its cars are used in bank heists? Has a fertilizer manufacturer been sued because its product was used in a bomb? Has AT&T been sued because Madoff used its services to bilk his clients? Has any gun manufacturer been successfully sued because one of its weapons was used in a crime? Etc. The answer, I'm almost completely certain, is no. If there have been any successful cases against a company because its product was used in the commission of a crime, then there had to be something MORE than simply offering a good or service to the public which had OTHERWISE legitimate use - but was PREDICTABLY turned to criminal ends. I'd be happy to read any cite.
Drax
Cross posted. I tend to agree on the privacy issue which is a whole other animal. And, I believe that anyone who sued to have his home removed from the service would succeed. Maybe. It's close. It's a valuable service. The social utility is VERY high. Weighed against that is the well-settled fact that we have NO privacy interest in what happens in public, and the outside of our home is, definitively, not private. I dunno. A court could split the baby and force an opt-out provision if it wasn't too burdensome.
Drax
Oh, the Columbine thingie... It wasn't the manufacturer who was jailed, but someone who broke the law in selling the assault weapons to the teens who did the shooting. Has nothing to do with what we're talking about. Just as would someone who collected Google data on homes - using street view to find out when people were and were not home -- and sold that data to someone who used that data to burglarize the homes. Doesn't have anything to do with Google's liability, just whether or not someone using their service broke the law.
CosmicConservative
As I recall in the Columbine case, the gun seller who sold the guns to the adult who then sold them to the teens was also prosecuted. But my memory is vague... Maybe not. You said above that the privacy issue was a "different thing" and that's precisely where you and I disagree on this. The privacy issue is the KEY THING that makes Google culpable imho.
Drax
No. Different issues entirely. If the allegation is that a criminal used Google Maps to stake out and target homes to burglarize and Google is being sued for THAT, then the issue is Google's negligence in offering a service to the public which a reasonable person could foresee would lead to that very use. That very use. Not some other use, but that one. Because the duty we have is to not do things which a reasonable person would foresee would lead to the very injury that the Plaintiff suffers - because if we can't foresee THAT injury than how on earth could we be held to be RESPONSIBLE when that very injury, in fact, occurs? Here, Google's service has nothing to do with "privacy," (nor could it) because "privacy" isn't at issue - what is at issue is a criminal's USE of that service. The service ITSELF doesn't invade anyone's privacy as far as I can tell. (Although some of the satellite views certainly could if they show areas which are MEANT to be private...) I can walk down the street and view your house and determine whether if anyone is at home. You have NO "privacy interest" in my doing so - any more than you would if your neighbor across the street took note of your comings and goings. Because the outside of your home, your entry and exit therefrom, your comings and goings - are IN PUBLIC and can be viewed by anyone who wishes to take note. If there IS any "privacy issue," then it is a separate issue than the use the criminal made of this PUBLIC information (which he could have obtained otherwise - without using Google - just like in the good old days...) If Google DID invade anyone's privacy (i.e., somehow found information which ISN'T available to the public (like its capturing of WIFI information and whatnot...) THEN, since that information ISN'T available to the public simply by looking, the person's whose privacy was invaded might have a cause of action for that invasion. That ain't this case. As to the guy who sold to the guy who sold to the teens...have no information on that. BUT, since the guy who sold the assault weapons to the teens was sentenced to 6 years for selling the weapons and NOT for being an accomplice in the murders - it is reasonable to assume that the guy who sold the weapons to HIM had no more idea what they were going to do with the weapons than HE did, and unless he, too, broke some OTHER law (they were described in the articles I read as "assault weapons" but dunno how accurate that description is...) in the sale of the weapons.
Yup
Aside from that whole argument thing. Same legal case could also apply to municipalities who for decades have recorded your home's exact location, what you paid for it, how big it is, etc. Same for Zillow, any property valuation site, or even news stations that report on something happening on a street and the house behind the reporter gets broken into. I don't see any hope of a lawsuit going anywhere. Google could simply point to the gov'ts expressed claim that there is no right to privacy in public. And they'd clearly show they never entered your house and took pictures. And unless Google's street picture's show a broken down door or broken windows - then for all practical purposes, they haven't given anymore details than the municipalities website gives. One's a picture, one's text (sometimes with pictures) with the same info.
CosmicConservative
I wonder if anyone is going to try to drag Google into this. I can hope...