Speeding neutrinos...
By CosmicConservativeI'm sure all of you have seen the T-shirt or poster of Albert Einstein wearing a police hat with his hand up saying: "299,792,458 m/s... not just a good idea, it's the LAW".
Well, it seems that some neutrinos are breaking the speed limit.
My gut reaction to this is that this is probably just the latest false alarm of some experimental result that supposedly "breaks relativity." These seem to happen about once a year if you pay attention to nuclear and/or astro physics. The last big "threat" to relativity that I remember was a few years ago when some experimental result supposedly "proved" that certain particles had to be moving faster than light for certain sub-nuclear events to occur. The "entanglement" paradox is probably the longest running "threat" to relativity that has so far been hanging out there since it implies that information might be able to travel faster than light if you exploit the entanglement of paired fundamental particles.
These things tend to pop up, stir the waters for a while, and then fade away as small adjustments are made to the measured speed of light (a very, very difficult thing to measure) and/or corrections are made to the experimental apparatus or some other thing happens.
Now, as it happens, I don 't believe that the Theory of Relativity is "absolute truth" any more than I think any bit of "settled science" is. I do think it's the best approximation we currently have of the nature of the universe at cosmological scales. However, as I have pointed out here in the past, Relativity has a fundamental problem. Relativity is based on the premise that space-time is "smooth." Unfortunately Quantum Mechanics is based on the premise that space-time is "fuzzy." Both work, but both simply can't be right. The universe cannot be smooth and fuzzy at the same time. Or there is no way to wrap a human brain around such a concept.
So eventually there will be some reconciliation of relativity with quantum mechanics, or else we will have to eventually realize that we simply can't explain the universe in one theory that works on the smallest and largest scales simultaneously.
My guess is that Relativity will have to be adjusted or modified to deal with the fuzziness of the universe at some point. Quantum Mechanics is more or less based entirely on actual experimental results while Relativity is a grand theory based on fundamental assumptions about the nature of space and time. Relativity is, perhaps, the single most beautiful scientific theory ever conceived. It is a breath-taking intellectual achievement that demonstrates the incredible imaginative ability of the human mind. It describes a universe that is so beautifully engineered that Einstein once famously said "If the universe is not as Relativity describes, then God missed a great opportunity." Or something like that.
But I can't help but think that very beauty is the reason it is unlikely to survive the gritty ugliness of Quantum Mechanics without significant alterations at some point in the future.
Comments (11)
equipment problem was discovered and the effect went awayan adequate explanation for the phenomenon which didn't require faster than light travel was proposed. It sounds like this may be a similar situation with neutrinos instead of photons. It is worth pointing out how incredibly difficult it is to track neutrinos. Neutrinos are very special things. To a neutrino pretty much everything in the universe looks like a vacuum. Billions of neutrinos from the sun are racing through your body every second, but virtually all of them pass right through you, your chair, the floor, the earth and the moon and Jupiter if they happen to be traveling in that direction. So I am highly skeptical of any experiment that claims to be firing neutrinos from one source to a detector 500 miles away with any real sense of precision and accuracy. As far as I know the only "practical" (and I use that term advisedly) neutrino detectors are huge underground pools of water with thousands or tens of thousands of highly sensitive light detectors all through the roof of the pool. Neutrinos which (rarely) happen to interact with water molecules generate a tiny flash of light. So the detection that is being done here is almost certainly that sort of detector. For as long as I can remember those detectors have been plagued with technical difficulties as well as having to deal with the fact that neutrinos routinely travel through the earth and hit those pools of water from all angles all the time. There's no way to "shield" them from one source of neutrinos and only look at neutrinos from one direction. So color me skeptical...