Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Earth's moon could become a planet

By CosmicConservative
CNN.com - Earth's moon could become a planet - Aug 18, 2006
But here's the thing. Earth's moon was born in a catastrophic collision more than 4 billion years ago. It started out very close to the planet but has been moving away ever since. It's currently drifting away about 1.5 inches (3.74 centimeters) every year. For now, the system's barycenter is inside Earth. But that will change. "If the Earth and moon do survive, then the barycenter will eventually move outside the Earth as the moon recedes," Laughlin told SPACE.com. "At that point the Moon would be promoted to planetary status."
This is a good example of why I think the current moon/planet designation proposal is plain stupid. They set it up specifically to allow the moon to still be called a moon, but the definition they chose so they could do that (that the center of gravity of the earth-moon system is within the radius of one of the bodies, in this case, the earth) is not permanent, and one day it will no longer be true. So with the proposed plan an object could be a moon on Monday, and a planet on Tuesday. Or, as the article points out, if a spherical "moon" has an orbit that is eccentric enough (a thin ellipse instead of a fat circle, for example) then it would be a moon for part of its orbit and a planet for other parts. It's just plain stupid. Hopefully they'll wake up and come up with a designation that sticks to the actual physical properties of the body, and if that makes Pluto a minor planet, or the moon a planet, so what? This is actually a classic case of the human obsession to classify things. It's not "science" it's "semantics." But it gets more press than the discovery of a new body larger than pluto did.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.