How good is "good enough"?
By CosmicConservativeThis is a post that originated in my gaming activities, but I think it has relevence beyond that, so decided to post it here instead of on my gaming blog.
As most of you know, I have been expanding my gaming materials at a rapid pace for the last few months. For several weeks I was creating as many as a dozen playable game miniatures per day, sometimes even more than that. As a result my collection of available miniatures, terrain and other items has grown from a small collection of a couple hundred items, to a large collection that is near or a bit beyond 1,500 items. The largest part of this collection is my game miniatures collection which used to fit in a couple of plastic collectible trays, but now sprawls across a dozen 13"x24" foam trays and overflows even that to the tune of about 50 or so miniatures I don't have room for at this time. It also includes a large number of terrain elements, some structures and even some digital artifacts, such as drawings, maps, sounds and even a few videos.
Of course I have done a lot of research into other people's gaming activities as a part of this buildup of materials, and doing so has caused me to contemplate the whole idea of "practical aesthetics" vs "aesthetics for aesthetics sake."
Which takes me back to the miniatures. My collection of 1,500 or so miniatures includes several different sources for the miniatures. But in the end they can be broken down into the following categories:
1. Professionally made commercial grade pre-painted game miniatures.
2. Professionally made commercial grade un-painted game miniatures.
3. Commercial grade toys repurposed as game miniatures.
4. Commercial grade toys used as raw materials for custom miniatures.
5. Professionally made or commercial grade miniatures with custom modifications.
6. Custom miniatures made from scratch by me personally.
The question of "how good is good enough" came to mind while contemplating my collection of dragon miniatures, which are made up of miniatures from all six of the categories mentioned above.
Technically all you need to play the game is some sort of token which represents the characters and monsters that are in the game. In other words a "dragon" could easily be represented by a simple featureless block of wood, and the characters fighting it could be represented by various small coins or bits of paper.
So in that sense "good enough" is not much of a standard to meet.
But what really set me off on this line of thought was a series of posts on a miniature making message board which demonstrated what I thought was a strange inconsistency of opinion on what is "good enough."
One thread began with the post "Paper miniatures" and the poster described how he/she had satisfied their gaming needs by printing out images on thick paper, then cut them out and mounted them on flat plastic bases. The end result was a two-dimensional paper figure taped to a plastic base. The general reaction of the message board participants was very favorable, with many commenters remarking on the low cost and utility of the paper "miniatures."
Another thread began with a post on custom painting and requested criticism and comments on the quality of a paint job on a professionally made commercial grade un-painted miniature (from Reaper minis, perhaps the most respected manufacturer of game miniatures in the world). The commentary on the resulting quality of the paint job ranged from "great job" to "I'd never use something that ugly."
Now, some of the very same people being critical of the paint job on the Reaper mini had posted favorable responses to the printed out paper minis. Yet while they seemed to accept the printed, folded paper miniature as acceptable for gaming, the far superior and better looking commercial miniature did not meet their standards because they considered the paint job to be below their standards.
So I posted some of my "frankensteined" dragons which were made out of lizards which had been modified by adding wings made of foam and necks and other dragon elements made out of epoxy putty. While most of the responses were very positive, there were again some comments about how some players would never accept as a dragon a miniature that was based on a cheap plastic gecko. And yet some of these same people seemed to be just fine with the paper printed out dragons taped to plastic bases.
To my mind, by any objective measure, my lizard-based dragons are far superior to the cheesy paper printouts of dragons that were posted. They are solid, three-dimensional, require skill to sculpt and paint and actually look like dragons.
And yet they don't meet the expectations of some people who are just fine with a folded up piece of paper printed out on an ink-jet printer and taped precariously to a plastic base.
In the end the only thing I could come up with is that the printed out "dragons" are acceptable to those people because they were INTENDED to be dragons by the artist, and they matched the players' expectations of what a particular dragon was "supposed" to look like, while my lizard dragons, or the painted miniatures did not conform to those same expectations.
But I don't know if that's the case. That's just speculation. Still it is almost as though the definition of what is "good enough" for use in the game is based on what the original intended use was for the item, not what it's final execution turned out to be.
I can't help but think this is an important thing to understand about how people value objects and assign "quality" values to them.
I was reminded of the classic scene in "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" when the author attempted to fix his riding partner's loose handlebars with a piece of aluminum cut from a soda can and the riding partner was outraged that his expensive, high-quality motorcycle would have incorporated into its chassis a bit of soda can, and instead went to a motorcycle repair shop and paid a lot of money for a "shim" which was essentially functionally and materially identical to a bit of soda can to be installed instead. Only then was he satisfied that his bike had been "repaired" properly.
Food for thought...
Comments (2)