Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The End of Evolution

By Dadman
The evolution vs. intelligent design debate is a fascinating one. As a person of faith I happen to believe a supreme being is in no way precluded from utilizing natural laws and forces to achieve his or her objectives. With that in mind I've often wondered if the process of natural selection has been nipped in the bud where humanity is concerned. After all, even the weakest among us (either mentally or physically) are empowered by the advancements of civilization to pass on genes to the next generation...warts and all. Here's an interesting article that addresses the topic. What do you think?

Comments (7)

CosmicConservative
I think that the most amazing thing about science is how few scientists actually seem to learn the lessons of the past. A hundred years ago scientists, particularly physicists, were publicly saying that we had learned all there was to know about the universe, that Newton's Laws and Maxwell's Equations explained it all and that there was no more progress to be made, the rest was just going to be calcuations. Then within a decade Einstein introduced Relativity and Bohr, Heisenberg and others introduced Quantum Mechanics, two of the most revolutionary theories in the history of mankind. These scientists should read "The Singularity" before they make bigger fools of themselves. Not only is evolution of humanity alive and well, but it is about to accelerate dramatically when it becomes self-driven by genetic engineering, nanotechnology and hyper-medicine. They are not only wrong, they could not possibly be more wrong. Of course that's just my $.02.
Dadman
Self-driven evolution is not exactly evolution in the pure sense of the word. It's bio-engineering. The question is has human natural selection been short-circuited? The article actually references the self-driven kind of evolution you mention. At the very least, it's an interesting question.
CosmicConservative
Heh, you caught me, I didn't read the whole article, I got about three or four paragraphs into it and said "here we go again."
Spence
I agree with Cosmic. They couldn't be more wrong. We are part of the largest human gene pool ever, and it gets bigger and more diverse every day. No one knows what the next challenge will be or which set of people are the best prepared to face it.
qwerty182764
For those who dream of a better life, science has bad news: this is the best it is going to get. Our species has reached its biological pinnacle and is no longer capable of changing. This is highly emotional. Of course things will get better. The fact that our DNA no longe has selection pressures on it doesn't mean that life is as good as it will ever be. It just means that over the course of 10's of thousands of years, assuming we keep our hands off of our DNA, the lack of selection pressure will lead to our slow wandering away from fitness. This does not preclude technological, social, or personal improvement. Civilization will continue to function as it always does. In fact, this lack of guiding selection pressure is dependent on civilization operating as it does - shielding us from the viscittudes of nature that would weed out the weak. In less than 10000 years (assuming Islam doesn't conquer the Earth and put us perpetually in the dark ages), I fully anticipate that we will have begun actively messing with our own DNA in an attempt to improve our traits and lifespans, making our escape from natural selection a moot point.
qwerty182764
In addition, human populations are now being constantly mixed, again producing a blending that blocks evolutionary change. This couldn't be more wrong either. It might not have to do with evolution, but haven't these guys ever heard of hybrid vigor?
CosmicConservative
I think that if you came back and looked at the earth in 1,000 years, you would be hard pressed to find an individual who had the physical attributes or mental capacity of the average human being of today. You'll see cat-people, snake-people, augmented people, cyborgs, fully AI individuals, etc. If that isn't "evolution" I don't know what is.