Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Two more movie reviews

By CosmicConservative
Super 8: Really great movie, on so many levels. Really should have been promoted as a "Fathers' Day" movie, that's really what it was in its soul. Two fathers linked by one tragedy, whose children teach them a lesson about forgiveness and moving on with life. It was a pretty awesome monster movie too. Lots of clever cinematic references to Hollywood's sci-fi past. Several very good subplots being woven together into one compelling story. Unbelievable performances by a group of kids, not just one or two. And as if that's not enough, a pretty nice trip back in time to my own youth. Probably the best movie I've seen this year. Really deserves some serious attention from the Academy. My only beef was the stereotypical evil, xenophobic, military bad guy. Oh well. Minor complaint in a wonderful movie. One huge bonus is that there's no way they'll digitally airbrush the automatic weapons out of this movie. Green Lantern: Not sure what to say about this movie. I've rarely seen a movie that teetered so precariously on the edge of absurdity, and yet still managed to keep some level of story going that I found myself interested in. As an action movie I would put this as pretty standard fare, although the power of Green Lantern's ring is probably the single most awesome superhero device in the history of literature. The thing is essentially "God on a finger". Every time I started to roll my eyes and shake my head, the movie would do something that made me stop and give it another chance. So I dunno... I can't really recommend it since many folks I know would be totally put off by the absurdities, but still, I liked it better than Pirates and wouldn't discourage anyone from watching it. Maybe it's the fighter plane sequences I liked... Hard to say. Something about it left me feeling like it was worth watching. Barely maybe... but there it is.

Comments (11)

Dadman
Elle Fanning is the best 12 year old actress (now 13) I've ever had the privilege of watching. I hope she has a long, successful acting career...and stays out of the Hollywood gutter...
CosmicConservative
I thought Elle did a nice job. (She must be Dakota's younger sister, right?) But I also thought Haley Joel Osmont did magnificent work as a 12 year old, and Jodie Foster in "Taxi Driver" is still something of a near-miraculous performance. And didn't Tatum O'Neil win an Academy Award at the age of 12 for "Paper Moon?" Something like that. How old was Liz Taylor in "National Velvet?" I forget. But young. Natalie Wood in "The Searchers?" Sorry... you sorta tapped a lode there....
Dadman
I didn't say she was the only child actor to do a nice job in his or her role. I said she was the best...12 year old. Of course, that is a subjective judgment and it may be that she's only one of the best I've seen in many years. However, I would put her performance above that of Tatum (in spite of the award). I think the others may have been older than 12 but I dunno. I'd have to check their ages and take a look at their performances again before I would feel comfortable revising my opinion.
CosmicConservative
LOL, I'm pretty sure all but Natalie Wood were 12 at the time. I think Natalie was 15 when she did her "Searchers" role. But I haven't looked it up. And to be fair, as much as I think Natalie Wood is one of the great actresses of all time, I wouldn't call her "Searchers" performance all that impressive. But "National Velvet", "Paper Moon", and "Taxi Driver" were all Academy Award winning movies and the roles of Taylor, O'Neil and Foster were not merely good, in the case of O'Neil and Foster they were gritty, realistic portraits of severely flawed individuals that were the equal of any adult I've seen. I also thought the 12 year old Haley Joel Osmont was freakishly capable as an actor. I wonder what he's doing these days.
Dadman
I'm probably guilty of being a little hyperbolic with my assessment of Elle's acting. I think she's a wonderful actor and her performance in Super 8 was precocious. But, her Super 8 role was admittedly not as substantive as the roles of the other actors you've mention. However, given the right opportunity, I have little doubt the young Fanning could deliver a performance that is Oscar worthy. The talent is clearly present...
Jack
One of the main kid actors in Super 8 is teenager Gabriel Basso. The Basso family is from my hometown, St. Louis, and Gabriel's sister, Annalise Basso, is in my film, Ghost Image. For anyone who's seen my film, she is the little bloody girl that appears from time to time throughout. Gabe, Annalise, and the rest of their family came to the auditions for Ghost Image. The on-screen presence and star-quality of the kids were immediately noticeable. Both kids have gone on to do great things in Hollywood. And to think, back in '06 they were just a couple of anonymous St. Louis county kids going to an audition for a local film. I'm very proud of them!! :-)
Dadman
Jack: So what did you think of Elle's performance in Super 8?
brian1785
Super 8 is an updated version of ET. Don't get me wrong, I liked the movie but really just a remake with a twist in the storyline.
CosmicConservative
Brian, that same logic would say that E.T. was just an updated version of "The Man Who Fell to Earth". I am one of those cynical people who never fell in love with E. T. I thought it was a typical Hollywood "technology = magic" movie. But it was a kids movie and as such I viewed it mostly as a fairy tale. Super 8 I viewed more as an interesting combination of fairy tale, monster movie and homage to Hollywood's past. Yes, including obvious references to E.T. itself.
Jack
Hi Dadman! I thought Elle did a fine job with the material. WARNING: MINOR SPOILERS AHEAD!!! I think her best performance in the film was when her character, Alice, is "acting" in the scene at the train station (just before the train wrecks). She starts out wooden like any typical amateur actor would be, especially a kid pretending to be an adult. But then the performance changes and becomes very believable as she gets into the role. I'm always impressed when an actor has to play a bad, or amateur, actor. All the kids in Super 8 that "acted" in the movie (within the movie) did that convincingly. I know I got a little off-track there. Anyway, I think Elle did a convincing job. I, too, think she has an Oscar-worthy performance in her future. Of course, that is as long as she has the right material to work with. As far as the movie itself. I enjoyed it, and it was a good homage to early Spielberg films except, for me anyway, if felt just a little off. As though it was missing something. Like it wasn't as full or rich as those early films by Spielberg. It was like comparing a real diamond ring to costume jewelry. Maybe it's just that, since I'm much older now, I'm not as swept away by the over-sentimental "movie-magic" as I was then. I should rewatch ET and CE3K to see if they have the same magic for me now as they did then. Maybe they'd feel a little off too these days.
Dadman
Jack: The Elle scene you reference is definitely a good one...and I loved the reaction of the boys. They were all clearly mesmerized. The scene that moved me the most involved Elle and Joe watching the film of Joe's mother. Joe is describing the unique way his mother used to look at him and how it made him feel like he really existed...and then Elle, through convincing tears, reveals that her father should have been on the work shift that resulted in the death of his mother, that he wished it could have been him, and that sometimes she wished it could have been him that died instead of Joe's mom. The scene was VERY well written and crafted with Elle in the foreground delivering her lines directly to the camera and Joe in the background as the home movie of Joe and his mom flickered away. One of the better moments in the film...imho. I enjoyed Super 8 a lot. It's probably my favorite film in a long time. Derivative or not, I wish Hollywood made more films like this...