Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Jill Carroll's story

By CosmicConservative
Why is CNN.com devoting their "front page, above the fold" real estate on multiple days to the story of Jill Carroll? Am I too cynical in thinking that they are overtly trying to repair her image after her seeming "Stockholm Syndrome" response on first being freed?

Comments (2)

anonymous
From the Monitor website. Please do your homework.... http://www.csmonitor.com/specials/carroll/QA/index.html Q.Peter Grier: "When released from Iraq, you had stated that you had been well-treated by your captors. After your trip to Germany and return to the US you then indicated that you were not treated well. For a seasoned correspondent, which answer was truthful?" – Cecil E. Perfoy, Maui, Hawaii A. Jill Carroll: "Well, obviously, the latter. I wasn't well treated. But keep in mind, I wasn't doing this as a reporter. I was a hostage which is different. I wasn't working, I had been attacked, essentially. So, the reason why I said in the beginning that I was well treated, those words I said, in that video that came out that said I was in one room and went to a bathroom once, and that was all; those were the exact words I was told to say by the insurgents who captured me. They said if I ever said anything more, or anything different from that, essentially they would come kill me, essentially. So, I was never to tell anyone anything else aside from those exact words that I said. So, when I got out, I was still absolutely terrified. People seem to think that when you're free suddenly you're just back to who you were and that you're feeling safe and everything's great again. Not at all. This kind of thing just shakes your sense of security to the absolute core for a long, long time. And so, I had just gotten out. I wasn't about to say anything wrong. I wasn't about to violate what they wanted me to say. They want me to tell the world that I was well-treated, and that's what it took for me to get home and get away and never have this happen again, then so be it. I didn't care. After a few days, in your mind, you start to get a little better sense of yourself, and also being away and out of Iraq, and being in Germany and being back in the US you begin to feel sort of ... I began to feel a little safer about saying things, and not sticking to the script that I had been given by the captors to say. But, when I said that, the captors had told me maybe two hours before that they were going to kill me. So, it's a little hard to come from that, and two hours, then switch, and be like, oh yeah, well, now I'm back. Let me be myself again and tell you the truth about how awful it was. I was afraid they would come get me again. I did whatever I had to do to keep that from happening."
CosmicConservative
anonymous: How in the heck does anything you posted indicate that I "didn't do my homework?" If you don't believe that there was widespread suspicion of "Stockholm Syndrome" in Jill Carroll's case, you simply haven't been reading the blogs. Yes, I know Jill has on several occasions attempted to explain her behavior, and I personally on this blog said that it seemed reasonable. But I'm only one blog. Other bloggers and other pundits have not been as forgiving as I have. And it is my speculation that at a time when we have terrorism alerts running rampant, war in Lebanon, Iran being implicated in that war and North Korea flaunting world opinion and the UN, it seems odd to me that CNN would devote three (so far) front page stories to Jill Carroll. Frankly her story is simply not that compelling and having it so prominently on display makes me believe there is more of an agenda than simply reporting the news. You may not agree, but that doesn't mean I "haven't done my homework." Sheesh.