Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

152 pounds?!?

By CosmicConservative
So, just sorta roaming around with some of the health "tools" that are out there on the web, I stumbled across an "ideal body mass index" calculator, and basically for my height (5'10") my "ideal" BMI is 21.7 which ends up being about 152 pounds, at least according to their calculations. I find that hard to believe. I haven't weighed 152 pounds since, probably, 1980, if I was even that thin then (I was dirt poor and riding a bicycle everywhere so I probably was that thin then). 152 pounds! My current goal is 175 pounds. According to the BMI calculator, that's still overweight! 175 pounds seemed like an achievable goal. 152!?! Not so much.

Comments (15)

Drax
Heh. Ignore that crap. 175 would be great for a 5'10" man. I'm nearly 185 pounds and 1/2" under 6' and am still considered "skinny" by most people.
JSullins
I weigh in at 200, 6ft. If I could get to 180 I'd be happy. And I'd probably look "skinny" at that point. You would look like prison-camp material at 152 pounds, Cosmic. Stick with 175 as a goal for sure.
ASEI
I can't imagine what a 5'10" 152lb man would look like - probably an Auschwitz survivor or something! Diet nazis are insane, don't listen to them. I am 6', 190lbs and up to military fitness standards. (Actually, the Air Force has it's own diet-naziism. Apparently because I eat meat three times a week, I am in critical danger of being morbidly obese, sans any other evidence)
ASEI
PS - one of the things I have noticed that is a little disturbing is the degree to which other people reflexively (and harshly, and stupidly) moralize about other people's weight. I have no idea what, in our screwed up ancestral psychology, would make us regard weight as some deep guide to lifestyle and character; but apparently we do. Even people who pride themselves on their tolerance are advocating sadistic social dominance ploys on "those fat people".
Drax
I read one chart before I responded to this post in which the range of acceptable weight for a 5' 10" man began at 136 pounds. Are they out of their freaking minds? In what world is 136 pounds at that height not dangerously skinny? (Well, mebbe not "dangerously"...but certainly..."seriously"...seriously...)
Andy
ASEI, I am just shy of 5' 9", and weigh in at a whopping 135. Yes, I am considered "skinny" by most, but not concentration camp skinny. Cosmic, I know your frame, and 175 would be just about right. When you get to 175, you may decide to drop some more, but 175 is achievable, and would seem to be a good, healthy weight. Dirt poor, and riding a bicycle everywhere, you were probably at your most healthy (fit) EVER. So, 152 would not be bad for you at all. But, it's just harder to achieve that with limited exercise time, and such.
staylor
It has been observed before that the government standards by which they determine if someone is fat or overweight are unrealistic. I beleive it was once pointed out that Michael Jordon, while he as in the NBA, would have been determined to be overweight under the scale currently in use.
staylor
Oh BTW I am 6 foot 2 and I weigh 195 which puts me in the overwieght catagory... barely. The funny thing that I weighed a little over two hundred about six months ago... when I was actively working out. I was "fatter" when I was in better shape. I think it is safe to say that the BMI is bunk considering that it does not seem to take muscle mass into acount.
CosmicConservative
Well, the BMI calculator has a "hedge" if you are seriously athletic and have a lot of muscle mass.
Boyd
I'm 6'4", and my "ideal" weight is supposedly 204 lbs. I hit 216 once, many, many (many) years ago while I was on deployment in the Navy. Everyone thought I looked gaunt and was on my deathbed. OTOH, it was the only time in my life I ever even dared to wear Speedos, while on the beach in Spain. I fit in with the Europeans, but it still didn't feel right that everyone could tell I was circumcised.
Dadman
Boyd has taken this thread down a very strange path... ;) I weighed about 165 at our 20th reunion (Cosmic and Andy) and I felt very comfortable at that weight. I'm 5'10". Currently, my goal weight is 170 (yes, I'm dropping weight too because old and fat is no way to live). When I got married I weighed about 140 and felt seriously underweight. I was a starving (literally) college student who had very little money for food after paying for tuition, books, rent, etc. I lived on peanut butter, but not very well hence the emaciation. After getting married I put weight on quickly consuming the delicious pies and cakes my wife made for me on a near-daily basis... ...and I haven't quit eating them.
Boyd
Hey, that's what stream-of-consciousness writing does for you, Dadman. :D
pace
For sure many of those 'ideal weight' calculators don't do a good job of taking body type into consideration. I'm 5'8" and my fit weight (what I prefer when I'm competing, not what the calculators say) is around 158lbs which puts me on the threshold of being 'overweight' if I recall correctly. I'd have to lose significant muscle mass to get to the ideal/recommended BMI. My post-holiday weight was 161lbs this year. The previous year it was 168lbs, and it took several months of intense exercise to get it back under control. So, I can certainly emphathize with your weight loss efforts CC. Kudos for what you've achieved thus far!