Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NFL Top 100

By CosmicConservative
The countdown is complete. Jerry Rice was the final player revealed in The Top 100: NFL's Greatest Players. NFL Network presented a 10-part series, with each one-hour show revealing 10 players in a countdown of the top 100 of all time as determined by a blue-ribbon panel. Each player is presented by a noteworthy individual in the world of sports and entertainment explaining what made that player one of the greats. via NFL.com | NFL Top 100 | Tracker.
Not sure if those of you who follow the NFL saw this. It's worth looking at. Of course there is no way any such list can satisfy everyone, or even most people. Questions like "How in the heck is Chris Carter, not on this list!?!" are perfectly legitimate questions. Is Jerry Rice truly the best player in the NFL ever? I'm a big Jerry Rice fan but is he really the best ever? Better than Jim Brown? Better than Joe Montana (you know, the guy who THREW all those passes for Jerry Rice to catch). Is Joe Montana the top quarterback ever, and does the top quarterback ever really fit as #4 overall? Lawrence Taylor is #3? My reaction to the list is both one of appreciation of the effort and a general sense of overall being a good list of the top 100 players (with a few notable exceptions, like Chris Carter) but at the same time I have major problems with almost every name on the list. I suppose the Peyton vs Brady debate is still underway, but is it even remotely reasonable that Peyton is #8 and Brady is #21? That alone indicates major problems with the entire list. Emmitt Smith, the top rusher in league history, is #28, and is #7 among running backs alone? What the heck is the point of running long enough and hard enough to set the overall record for yards, touchdowns and all-purpose yards if you end up being ranked below Gale Freaking Sayers!? I like Gale Sayers, but his career was marked by three amazing years and an injury plagued three more years where he was decidedly mortal. How does he get ranked above an Emmett Smith? Because he was pretty when he ran? Because Billy Dee Williams played him in a major motion picture? I call major BS on that. If Gale Sayers deserves that ranking, then so does Terrell Davis. For the same reason. One final comment. Brett Favre ranked above Tom Brady. That's just laughable.

Comments (12)

Drax
My top picks: 1. Jim Brown (a man amongst boys) ... 11 - (Any order is fine) Walter Payton Barry Sanders Brett Favre Joe Montana Gale Sayers Bo Jackson L.T. (the real one) Dick Butkus Red Grange O.J. Sammy Baugh Reggie White Johnny U. Earl Campbell Dion Sanders Bart Starr Peyton Manning And, who is not on my list? WIDE RECEIVERS. I refuse to include anyone who only touches the ball a handful of times (or even no times) a game, doesn't block, doesn't tackle, and, in general, doesn't play football, as a great football player. It's like listing a pitcher as one of the greatest baseball players of all time - they're PITCHERS...
CosmicConservative
Heh, any list that doesn't have Emmett Smith in the top ten isn't worth debating... The guy wasn't only the running back who had the most rushing yards, rushing TDs, first downs and all purpose yards in history, he was also a world class blocker, both in the backfield and downfield. If you want to say "they need to be a football player" then they don't come more "football player" than Emmett.
Andy
Emmett Smiff! Wide receivers block, and they tackle. And they run their assignment play after play after play. And, a GREAT one makes every QB, and the other receivers better. And, they make the running game better, too. Just sayin'...
CosmicConservative
Barry Sanders was a great runner, but he would not block. And most of those great, awesome, mind-blowing runs where he ran and ran and ran, back and forth, dodging linebackers and linemen, making people cry for his awsome moves... Ended up with a four yard gain. I watched Sanders. He was fun to watch, but he was not a complete back. He did not block. He did not catch. He ran. Drax, you talk about how a player has to be a complete football player and then you put Barry Sanders in your top ten because he ran pretty. I'd take Emmett any day over Barry Sanders. Most people look at running backs and think "total yards" but in my opinion, by far the most important statistic for a running back is first downs. Emmett Smith had almost twice as many first downs in his career as Barry Sanders did. I have to admit that my #1 would probably be Jim Brown too though.
Drax
Heh. I left off a few. Elway Smith And, I must say that the reason I included Sanders and Sayers is because they were just so purdy to watch. And, no, Andy. No receivers. Ever. EVER EVER EVER. (And, for the information of all...every good player on every team makes every other player on that team "better." That's how it works in team sports.)
Yup
True that Andy, WR's draw a certain portion of the defense away allowing other's to do their jobs. That's when they're not catching or blocking or tackling. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EdV_txH50cg
Andy
Glad to know that Yup understands the game of football. :)
CosmicConservative
Good wide receivers know when to block downfield, or on screens or draws. Jerry Rice was known for being a good downfield blocker. So was Michael Irvin. Deion Sanders, on the other hand, was known for being a great runner and pass defender, but his blocking and tackling was pretty laughable.
Drax
Yeah. It's that "pretty laughable" part that makes me leave wide receivers off the list. They're playing a position where they CAN be a "laughable" blocker or tackler (or even actually PLAY when their number isn't called) and still go to the HOF. But, I will admit that leaving Rice off my list does leave a bad taste in my mouth. Or Ronnie Lott. But, ... a rule's a rule. NO WIDE RECEIVERS! EVER!
Andy
Hey Drax! Even though I totally disagree, I respect the hell out of ya'! I mean, once you make a rule, there's no reason to crawfish, or make exceptions. If it's a rule, then DANGIT, it's a rule!
CosmicConservative
Heh, this is a bit harsh, but the "if it's a rule, then DANGIT, it's a rule!" comment sort of forces me to quote Emerson: "A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines." Not that I think Drax is exhibiting a foolish consistency, it's just one of my all-time favorite quotes is all. :)