Webster's defines a rivalry as "competition for the same objective or for superiority in the same field." That means Tom Brady and Peyton Manning have a rivalry. A phenomenal one, actually. And yet, it doesn't feel like one. via Bill Simmons: Tom Brady and Peyton Manning -- the rivalry - ESPN.I guess I'm not sure where Bill Simmons gets the idea that "it doesn't feel like a rivalry." It sure feels like one to me, and has for years. I was the one saying Brady was an elite QB way back before the huge 2007 season where Brady and the Patriots redefined offensive dominance. You remember that season, it was the one where a poorly thrown ball into double coverage by a desperate Eli Manning (irony?) stuck implausibly to the receiver's helmet and cost Brady his fourth Super Bowl ring. Still, I think that much of what Simmons writes in his article is pretty good analysis and not bad writing either. I've been saying for almost a decade that my expectation is that in the end Brady will end up with more rings than Peyton, and that over time Brady's legend will grow while Peyton's will diminish. In ten years I expect Brady will be near the top of everyone's list of "greatest QBs ever" while Peyton will be near the top of everyone's list of "greatest individual performers ever." Brady will be remembered in the way Joe Montana is today while Peyton will have more of a Dan Marino vibe. Just sayin'
ESPN: Brady vs P. Manning
By CosmicConservativeI thought this was an excellent story on the relative careers and accomplishments of Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning.
Comments (28)