Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

ESPN: Brady vs P. Manning

By CosmicConservative
I thought this was an excellent story on the relative careers and accomplishments of Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning.
Webster's defines a rivalry as "competition for the same objective or for superiority in the same field." That means Tom Brady and Peyton Manning have a rivalry. A phenomenal one, actually. And yet, it doesn't feel like one. via Bill Simmons: Tom Brady and Peyton Manning -- the rivalry - ESPN.
I guess I'm not sure where Bill Simmons gets the idea that "it doesn't feel like a rivalry." It sure feels like one to me, and has for years. I was the one saying Brady was an elite QB way back before the huge 2007 season where Brady and the Patriots redefined offensive dominance. You remember that season, it was the one where a poorly thrown ball into double coverage by a desperate Eli Manning (irony?) stuck implausibly to the receiver's helmet and cost Brady his fourth Super Bowl ring. Still, I think that much of what Simmons writes in his article is pretty good analysis and not bad writing either. I've been saying for almost a decade that my expectation is that in the end Brady will end up with more rings than Peyton, and that over time Brady's legend will grow while Peyton's will diminish. In ten years I expect Brady will be near the top of everyone's list of "greatest QBs ever" while Peyton will be near the top of everyone's list of "greatest individual performers ever." Brady will be remembered in the way Joe Montana is today while Peyton will have more of a Dan Marino vibe. Just sayin'

Comments (28)

Drax
LOL. You think the "greatest QB ever" is somehow different from the "greatest individual performer." Sigh. The QB does what he can. It's all he can do. How he does what he can defines how good he is at his job. If he has a crappy term around him, what the TEAM can may not be as much as a TEAM can do with a crappy QB but great everywhere else (ask Dilfer and Marino). We'll never agree on this. For some reason, you continue to insist that ranking individual performance in a team sport is fundamentally one of team performance rather than individual performance while I insist that individual performance should be the single factor in ranking individual performance. But, I guess Dilfer is greater than Marino or Kelly and Bradshaw is the greatest QB of all time.
CosmicConservative
Heh, no, Joe Montana still probably has the most legitimate claim to that, or maybe Bart Starr... Dan Marino is almost certainly known as the "best individual performer" at the position of NFL QB, but very, very few "experts" list him as the greatest QB ever. It's not just me who says that Joe Montana is the more "elite" QB than Dan Marino, or that John Elway was "the one who can't win the big one" until he won the big one. Go check out the top rated QBs of all time yourself. And ten years after Peyton retires, unless he runs off a string of Super Bowls in his last years, as Elway did, you'll see Peyton ranked below Brady. That's just the way it is. It's not just me, you know, it's the supposed "experts" who put those lists that always seem to have Joe Montana ranked much, much higher than Dan Marino. I would say your approach is in the minority here, not mine. LOL
Drax
Just because someone is an "expert" (and you must put quotes there, because in an area of absolute opinion, there are no "experts") doesn't mean that he is right. The problem is that I don't agree with your (and their) PREMISE, i.e. that a team's success is FOUNDATIONAL in determining how well an INDIVIDUAL plays when measured against other individuals playing the same position. I can agree, but only to an extent, that a QB has more impact on the success of a team in football than any other individual player in, probably, any team sport - for good or ill. But, I have already demonstrated in another thread how, had OTHERS played differently in the same game (or had officials RULED differently) then Brady would have either ZERO or ONE ring. In other words, HIS PLAY was sufficient ONLY to bring him to the level of never winning a ring or only winning one. Yet it is always said "Brady has won three rings." BS. BRADY hasn't "won" a damn thing. The PATRIOTS won three. BRADY, through his play, EVEN if he's given credit for each and every play by every other player on his team on all three Super Bowl runs, ONLY "won" one. The other two (either in the SB itself or in the run-up to it) would NOT have been won if Brady's INDIVIDUAL PERFORMANCE was all that was at stake. In other words, after Brady had done all Brady could do, SOMEONE ELSE did something, something over which Brady had NO CONTROL which allowed the game to be won. Had that person (or persons) NOT done that thing, the Patriots would have lost. Yet Brady gets the credit. Yet, "he won three." That's lazy thinking. It's onion peel thin analysis. Where is the rationality in giving him credit for all three when, by his own efforts, he could ONLY have possibly "won" one (again, this is even giving him credit for the play of each and every person throughout the season and playoffs - as well as the playcalling)? It literally beggars my imagination that this passes for rational argument. I can, without any hesitation, say that Brady is is the top tier of QB's in the history of the game. All I have to do is look at the numbers. And, I can say that his play in the playoffs and in the SB's plays some part in that conclusion. But, what I WON'T do is determine his place in football history BASED ON THE PLAY OF OTHERS. You can. You do. So do most. It takes a supremely excellent quarterback to break out of this mindless mindset -- a Tarkenton (who, daily, falls down the ladder of "the greatest") or a Marino (not Kelly, because "he lost" four SB's). When a Marino is compared to a Bradshaw, even the most mindless of "experts" who put so much weight on the team's success in evaluating an individual's place in history, can't force the words "Bradshaw was a better Quarterback than Marino" out of his mouth. (Well, 99% can't. There are a few who will do so, there always being some of the mindless mob who are even more mindless than the rest....) This mentality is WHY LeBron James went to Miami. Had he stayed in Cleveland, he would have been dependent on management to get him the supporting cast he needed to win a championship. After seven years of substandard support cast and "moves" by management to win a championship which included getting an over-the-hill Shaq (and that was their BEST move), he knew that he had to go somewhere where he could win a championship. Why? Because if he didn't win one, he would NEVER be one of the greatest of all time in the opinion of the opinion makers. He would be a Barkley or a Stockton or a Miller or a Malone or a Ewing who always get, "Sure, he's a great player, but he never won a ring, did he?" What utter nonsense.
CosmicConservative
Well, I doubt either of us will convince the other. I think there's more to the role of QB than can be measured in statistics alone, and that there is a reason that QBs in football, goalies in Hockey, centers in basketball and pitchers in baseball are measured by wins in general, and by wins in big games in particular. I'm no johnny-come-lately on the Brady bandwagon. I have been a fan since his first season and I pointed out how he was the sort of QB who won championships many, many times over the years. I've compared him to Montana again and again. He has the same qualities as Montana. He is completely unflappable under pressure. He just oozes confidence in the huddle. He cheerleads his teammates on the sidelines. He demands the best performance. And year after year he has done all this with second-tier receivers, except in 2007, when he HAD top-tier receivers and did nothing but set individual performance records that Peyton himself hasn't matched. And that's with a coach who is acknowledged to be a conservative coach who favors safe, high percentage run and short pass in general. Manning calls his own plays. That's a coaching decision. I have no doubt Brady would do just as well if he were asked to call his own plays, but that's a rare, rare thing these days. Brady may not call every play but he has to make adjustments on every play, read defenses and manage the offense on the field. I am not the only one who thinks that Brady is the best reader of defenses in the game. Opposing teams think so too. In the end our disagreement is as much about style as anything. I think Brady's style is a better style to win championships. I think it's the same style that Montana, and even to an extent, Aikman, had. Brady is not Manning, he's not going to blow you away with his arm and he's not going to scream and yell at his receivers when they drop balls or run the wrong routes. He's not going to rely on his arm or his legs. And he's going to win. And I don't think it's a coincidence that he has one of the best records in big games in the history of the game. I think it's due to his style of play. His style survives the emotional push and pull of big games. He and Joe Montana define "cool in the huddle." And, as I said, we can check back again in fifteen years and revisit this debate. I'll still be on the Brady bandwagon.
CosmicConservative
.... also, Peyton Manning is currently 9 - 9 in the playoffs. Brady is 14 - 4 I think. If Peyton loses today, he'll have a losing playoff record. I think there's a reason for that, and it has to do with his temperament and style. If his teams are good enough to get him to the dance, and set regular season record after regular season record doing so, what happens to that same team when the playoffs start?
Drax
Yeah. We'll never agree. I agree that Brady is one of the best of all time. However, this is not based in the smallest part - even the tiniest particle - on whether or not his TEAM won the Superbowl - just on how HE performed in those games (as well as the run up to them). Call me silly. I only judge someone on how HE does - not how someone else does. Just foolish that way, I guess.
CosmicConservative
Part of their "individual performance" is how they set the tone, raise the level of play and keep the team focused. I've made this point dozens of times. You simply either don't agree that one player can bring up the play of other players by their leadership and simple presence, or you don't think it matters in team play. I think it makes all the difference in the world.
Drax
I've said many times that a great player (or leader - or both) can raise the level of play for those around him. I've made that argument in the Montana/Rice connection and, currently, am making it in the "should we play Teebow" debate. I'm sure you've read this by me many times. I don't deny this. It's part of the "individual performance" I grade when judging quarterbacks. It's one of the reasons I have held Favre in such high regard, i.e., his being able to do so much with so little (as compared to having 8-10 HOFers on his team as Bradshaw or Starr) BY raising the level of play of other players. But, it doesn't make "all the difference in the world." It makes a SMALL difference. Jerry Rice would be Great no matter who was throwing to him. Ronnie Lott would be great no matter who was on throwing the ball on offense. Bill Walsh would still be a great coach (and co-ordinator and innovator) regardless of who was playing. Put them together, however, and you get something which is more than the sum of its parts. (As I pointed out with Brady/Moss in their historic run.) I think I've made this statement (or similar ones) DOZENS of times on this blog. Yep. Dozens. You must have missed them. Or have forgotten them. But, I ALSO say that no matter HOW good you are, you can only do what you do with what you have. The QB ain't in control of personnel. He ain't in control of what anyone does however much he is able to influence others (those who choose to be influenced - they're all big, rich, grown, professional athletes as well....). He doesn't control the special teams. He doesn't control the kicker. The doesn't control the defense. He doesn't design plays. He only infrequently (except Peyton) call plays. In fact, about the only thing he absolutely controls is what he does (and even then, what he "does" is almost always decided by someone else). And, he can do everything perfectly and his team lose the game. Or, conversely, he can play like crap (aka Manning in the playoffs) and win a ring. It's amazing to me that so many "experts" place so much weight on "getting a ring" - on the overall "ranking" of a QB - except when they don't. When a "mediocre" QB wins a Superbowl, the "credit" goes to someone else (or to the defense, or special teams. Or, he was a good "game manager." (That was Brady in his first, maybe first two, Super Bowls. Credit was given to the coach and "the team" (remember the introduction...)) Dilfer was a good manager. Etc. Etc. But, a mediocre career (Namath, Bradshaw) is forgiven and the player is elevated to legendary status if he wins the big one (or more...) regardless of whether he is deserving when his career is considered in toto. Brady is so good because he does what he coach tells him to do, i.e., throw short, safe passes for the most part, and take a few shots down the field when the circumstances permit it. Take Brady out of the equation and what do you have? Oh yeah. Matt Cassel and 3600 yards and 21/11. Close to an average Brady season. Do I give credit to Brady for being ABLE to do what his coach says? Sure. The ability to execute is what it's all about. (And, when he GOT a weapon...yeah, he and coach knew what to do with it...) But, I don't, for a second, forget that he is a product of the TEAM and the STAFF. What he does with it is up to him, but he doesn't have any CONTROL over ANY of that. He only has control over whether he EXECUTES the plays given to him. We'll see what you say later - if Cutler wins a big one ... or two. He's in the running for one right now and, amazingly, he's playing well. Imagine that. Different coach. Different team. Different scheme. Different personnel. Playing differently.
CosmicConservative
Cutler is an interesting one to bring up. He isn't really playing that much better than he did in Denver, if you look strictly at statistics. He's thrown fewer interceptions this year, but he's still throwing more than he should. He's ranked right in the middle of the pack for QBs by rating, he's thrown 16 interceptions vs. 23 touchdowns... Those aren't terribly different stats. I don't get to see and hear him every week so I don't know if he's actually grown up a bit or not. I hope so. He's certainly had enough incentive to do so. We'll see how he does in the playoffs this year. I've already given the guy props for his success this year. If he wins a Super Bowl, I'll give him the credit he deserves. Cassell may have had a similar regular season statistical performance to Brady, but then again, Tony Romo has had better years than Brady three of the last four years, so regular season isn't what we're talking about here. How did Cassell do in the playoffs? I've seen interviews from Super Bowl winning players and when discussing Montana, Brady or Aikman the players all say the same thing. Those three QBs simply oozed confidence and calmness. The famous story of Joe Montana pointing into the stands and saying "Hey, there's John Candy!" is a great example. Everyone who was in that huddle says in that moment they were convinced that they would win, even though they were trailing and pinned back deep in their own territory. I've heard similar stories of Brady and Aikman. The stories of Peyton in the huddle in those same circumstances are all about his intensity and his fire and his competitiveness. That's all good, except that it doesn't calm down the team. I watch playoff football, and I've watched a lot of Peyton Manning playoff games. In my opinion, when the chips are down and the Colts are behind late, Peyton is frantic, his feet dance like a maniac, and he shouts at his teammates if they miss a play. Brady radiates calm confidence, while Peyton radiates frantic desperation. That's what it looks like to me.
CosmicConservative
I'll give Peyton credit for staying cool in this game, but I can't believe he called a running play on three third and longs in a row. That was just amazing. The first two worked, so I guess he figured the third time would too. But whatever you call that, it sure can't be called desperation. Bad play calling, maybe, but not desperation.
CosmicConservative
Well, the Jets play calling was just as bad.
Drax
Yep. Great game. Peyton shouldn't call the game. I'm convinced that this is the reason he is seemingly "frantic" at times. He has more to think about than do other QB's who, for the most part, simply have to think about their reads, and, whether or not to call off the play (there's more, I know, but game planning ain't one of them). And, no matter how good he is, I don't think that ANYONE is good enough to be a professional quarterback AND an offensive co-ordinator at the same time, when compared to someone who does nothing BUT coordinate. And, I think that this is one of the reasons for his lack of success in the playoffs. The other teams have time to prepare for him, but he doesn't have the same time (either throughout the season or during the game so to make changes after 1/2 time) to play against the elite teams every week in the playoffs. The only SB he won, was won despite him. But, why on this green earth would you give Cutler any "credit" for winning if his PLAY is the same as his PLAY was while you were reaming him out week after week? If HE ain't any better, then you might be able to say that the team won despite him or something, but to exchange disdain for "credit" because the team won without him changing one iota befuddles me.
CosmicConservative
I still can't seem to get this basic concept across. For a QB their statistical "play" isn't the whole measure of their effect on the game. When Cutler was on the Broncos he had a net negative effect on the team. He was petulant and aloof. He was whiny in the huddle, according to reports. He blamed his receivers for incompletions and blamed his linemen for his interceptions. If he's grown up enough to stop doing that childish crap, then he's a totally different QB, even if his actual stats are almost identical. That's my point. You do make a good point about Manning and the potential impact and extra pressure he has due to calling his own plays. I hadn't really considered that. He must be under one hell of a lot of pressure, especially in playoff games. The Jets really kept him off balance today. He only had one true great pass the whole game. It will be interesting to see how Brady and the Patriots deal with that same defense.
Yup
When the game can be controlled and Manning can keep reading what the D will do - Manning will win. But you keep Manning rattled and you've got a chance to beat him. Brady doesn't rattle that easily. What's Brady at right now - 335 throws without an interception? What was Favre's record - 20 throws without an interception?
Drax
One of the reasons I allow that Brady is, already, one of the all time greats, is his ability to control the ball. This year (like last year with Favre) he is having an historic season even for him. But, he is "dinking and dunking" the defenses, seldom taking down the field shots. (Of course, this is the way the Patriots have played for the past decade or so..) Personally, I feel that this is the way to go if you're able to pull it off. It moves the ball and is less likely to result in a turnover. (Wes Welker thanks coach and QB for his future induction into the HOF...) CC: I'm sorry. I thought you were actually talking about how a Quarterback played the game when you were discussing which Quarterbacks were best in playing the game. If you're talking about the best LEADERS in the game, then you need to start adding some other position players into that equation. It is highly unlikely that Cutler has changed one iota. People don't change much at that stage in life. Everyone knows that "winning fixes problems." If the Bears are winning, then Cutler, WITHOUT CHANGING A THING - including his world view - or how he relates to players - or anything else which might impact his or others' play - might present a different VIEW of himself to others since this would be the first season as a Pro that he was on a winning team. Maybe he, like just about every other football player (or coach) simply is in a better mood since he's winning. Maybe the critics don't constantly question his play or mental strength since the team is winning so he doesn't have to face that after every game (or every day as he meets the public or reads/listens to/watches the press). Maybe (and I find this most likely) absolutely nothing has "changed" about Cutler except the circumstance he finds himself in, i.e., a better team with a better coach actually winning instead of losing even though HIS PLAY hasn't changed one iota. And, not faced with the constant question of his ability to play (even though he's playing about the same as ever before) perhaps he doesn't act petulant since, well, there's nothing to act petulant about.... Maybe...just maybe -- the perception of him has changed when the reality of him hasn't. (And, the "leader in the huddle" stuff, the "he made me believe we could win" stuff is about 99% ... "stuff." The same people who say such "stuff" (the Cris Carters, Keyshawn Johnsons, Jerry Rices, etc.) say, at the same time, that this "winning attitude," this "air of confidence" stuff is absolutely meaningless unless and until the quarterback can actually consistently EXECUTE...and THEN you have some reason to believe that the "air of confidence," the "winning attidude" that a QB might exude is JUSTIFIED. And, is it somehow surprising that, once you've done it over the years that, when faced with the same situation yet again, you "exude confidence" that you can do it again? Almost EVERY veteran QB has that aura because ... wait for it ... wait for it ... almost every VETERAN QB HAS "been there - done that" and his team can take a remark like "Hey! There's John Candy!" from the QB in a serious situation and INTERPRET it as supreme confidence whereas, in the same situation another QB, full of confidence of his abilities, might say the same thing and have every person in the huddle wish that he was paying attention to the damn game... I guarantee that if Montana had done that in his Rookie season, it would have been a completely different reaction...
CosmicConservative
Joe Montana gave an interview where he was asked about the John Candy thing. According to him at that time, Harris Burton, one of his offensive linemen, was known to be a celebrity watcher, he enjoyed spotting people in the stands, it was a sort of hobby of his. At that time, with the 49ers pinned back on like their six yard line with less than 3 minutes in the game, and trailing by 4 or 5, Burton was getting visibly stressed out. Joe spotted John Candy and pulled Burton over and pointed Candy out to him. It wasn't some off-the-cuff random remark. It was a deliberate and specific attempt by Joe to calm down a key player in the huddle at a key time using his knowledge of that player's own interests. And it worked, and when Burton calmed down, the whole team calmed down. How a quarterback or ANY player who "leads" does that leadership IS part of how they play. It's not a separate thing. It's part of their package as a player. And it counts. I can't comment on Cutler, although I have heard some people say that he has grown up a lot this year. I don't watch the Bears every week, he may be the exact same person he was. But I suspect he has grown up a bit. I don't buy the idea that people his age never change. People do change, and if anyone has ever had a reason to change, it's Jay Cutler. Would I like to have Jay Cutler as the Denver QB? Not the Jay Cutler who was here when he was the Denver QB. Leadership and maturity alone are not enough, because Kyle Orton has that in spades. The ideal is to have a player who has both the ability to perform and the ability to lead. That's Brady, Montana, Starr, Aikman, Jordan, Bird, Kobe, etc... They exist, and they make their teams better. Everybody acknowledges it and recognizes it, and that's why they get credit for leading their teams to championships. As I always say in these sorts of things, the eventual measure of this will be how Peyton and Brady are viewed in 2020, not in 2010. We'll revisit their careers, impact and ranking in the all time lists then, OK?
Drax
Again, while it's a given that a good leader is, well, good at leading, and, by definition is better at leading than is a bad leader (and, thus is able to get more out of his followers than is a bad leader), I don't give it as much weight as you do. The coach is the "leader" of the team. The QB is, usually, the "leader" of the huddle. But, no matter how well someone leads, he can't make anyone run faster, jump higher, or be stronger. The QB can do everything right and still lose. (Ask Vick. Had Akers made those two FG's, then Rodgers will still be "winless" in the playoffs - although he'll get the credit for the "win" even though, had Akers done his job, he would have lost - and played EXACTLY the same game. And the Vick experience would be on-going, with him credited for the "win" even though the difference was on the execution of a person entirely out of his control - either way.) That's my point. It has always been my point. Vick "lost" the playoff game; Rodgers "won." Their relative positions would have been reversed based entirely on whether or not Akers makes his kicks. Yet, here we are. Again arguing the relative ranking of Quarterbacks over their entire career based on whether or not they "won" a single game - even when those "wins" are demonstrably ones which, had circumstances entirely out of the QB's control been different, would be "losses." It just befuddles me. Always will. I judge the CAREER of a QB on ... his CAREER.
CosmicConservative
See, I don't agree with your fundamental premise here, which is that the only difference between Rodgers or Vick being the "winner" was a couple of missed field goals. There is absolutely no way whatsoever to predict the direction or outcome of the game by saying "If only Akers made that field goal." Because if Akers HAD made that field goal (or any other similar "game changing" activity occurred) then the game is totally different from that point on. Instead of getting the ball back where the kick was missed, there would have been a kickoff, perhaps the kickoff would have been returned for a touchdown. Who knows? Every single aspect of the game from that moment on would have been completely different. The coaches would have called different plays, the receivers would have run different routes, the QB would have thrown different passes or handed off different balls. There is absolutely no way whatsoever to say "if only those field goals had been made, Vick would be the winner." Had that first field goal been made, the second field goal would have never happened. Oh, there might have been some OTHER field goal attempt by Akers, but it would have been at a different time, at a different distance, with a different hold and different wind.... The only thing you KNOW is that the Packers won the actual game that was played. Had that first field goal been made instead of missed, the Packers could still have won the game. You'd have to go visit an infinite number of alternate universes to know all the possible outcomes of the game had Akers made the first field goal. And in how many of them would Rodgers have ended up winning because of OTHER decisions, leadership and execution? Nobody knows. We only know that Rodgers ended up the winner of THIS game. That's all we can know.
CosmicConservative
By the way, you do know that Tim Tebow's name is spelled "TEBOW", not "TEEBOW" don't you? Just wondering, you seem to spell it "TEEBOW" a lot.
CosmicConservative
... oh, and hey, remind me who threw Michael Vick's pass with 33 seconds left that was intercepted in the Packer's end zone? I forget... Oh, and here's a quote from one of the receivers in Vick's huddle there at the end...
"I just feel we rushed that last play and we didn't have to rush it," Jackson said. "That's what I was trying to say. 'Just down the ball, just spike the ball, just kind of get back to the huddle and regroup.' But he called 'All go.' We just ran what was called so that's neither here nor there. It's just unfortunate."
Yeah, no reason to put any of the loss on Vick's shoulders... none at all.
Drax
Wait a minute. Back it up. What did RODGERS do in the game that, had Akers made those two field goals, would have won the game? The whole last four minutes would have gone differently. Vick, if ahead, wouldn't have tried to throw that pass. Rodgers would have had to go for it on 4th and long. That's the point. Either you can admit or you can't that, the two players could have played the same exact game in the same exact way with the same exact results but, if Akers makes those two field goals, you have different winners and losers. I don't know how this can't be a simple admission of fact.
CosmicConservative
There is no way of knowing if the Packers or Falcons would have been ahead at "that point of the game" if Akers had made his first field goal. The whole game would have changed. That's my point. Playing behind instead of ahead Rodgers and the Packers would have made different decisions. Making or missing a field goal is not a binary thing that can be considered 3 points plus or minus. It changes everything about the game, from field position to coaching strategy to fan reaction... There is no possible way to say "well, if Akers had made those two field goals..." It is simply a total cause and effect non-sequitur. It is exactly as meaningful as saying "If only the beer had been better."
Drax
Okay. How about Manning and Sanchez? Folk makes the Field Goal with no time left, and Manning "loses". He misses it, and Manning "wins." Or how about the BCS championship? Or Superbowl 36? Or Superbowl 25? Or the 2009 NFC Conference Championship? Etc. Etc. Etc. In each case, with no time left, a field goal made or missed determined the winner. The QB "lost" or "won" based on whether the kicker made it or missed it. In each case, each QB did enough to win - because each QB WOULD HAVE WON depending on what the kicker did. Or Special teams punt return, or kick-off return (Ask the Giants. Did Eli do enough to win had Deshawn Jackson not run that kickoff back for a TD with no time left?) The list of Superbowl (or playoff) games which were DECIDED based on events entirely out of the control of the QB are legion. Yet, the QB continues to get the "credit" or the "blame" for the wins and losses even though - had these other events - completely out of the QB's control - gone the OTHER WAY, the QB would have been on the OTHER END of the "win" or "loss" equation. These examples are so numerous that any attempt to rank QB's on "wins" in Playoff Games (especially Superbowl games) when, by definition, the QB who "won" did just enough to LOSE had the kicker missed, the official ruled differently, the punt returner fell down, the defense not get an interception return for a TD -- etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. - simply beggars the imagination. I rank the career of a QB based on his career.
CosmicConservative
I'll grant you that there are games where the game is lost or won on a final TD, return or field goal, and in those cases you really can say "if not for..." However, barring some jarring miracle play, like the Kyle Orton pass that was deflected into Brandon Marshall's hands which he ran for a 70 yard touchdown with time running out, or a punt return for a touchdown with no time left, even most "last second" plays are part of a "last minute drive" where the goal of getting the ball into field goal range is every bit the QB's responsibility and they deserve credit for making the plays to get them there. Sanchez vs Peyton is an interesting one to discuss. There were several plays that led to that "last second field goal" that "made the difference between Peyton or Sanchez being the winner." Here are some of them: 1. Peyton calls a running play on 3rd and 8, gains 2 yards and has to settle for a field goal when a TD would have put them ahead. 2. Peyton has another 3rd and 8 and throws the ball just short and low and the receiver can't catch it, forcing the Colts to kick another field goal with almost a minute left on the clock. This field goal puts them ahead, but only by 2 where a TD would have put them ahead by 6. 3. Sanchez makes a critical third down pass which puts the Jets just into field goal range, and then makes a great second down throw to put the Jets into easy field goal range for the winning field goal. Sanchez makes two great plays in the final minute. Peyton blows two similar plays. That was the difference in the final few minutes of the game I was watching. Had Peyton made either of those plays, and gone on to score a decisive touchdown, or at least run another minute off the clock, the Colts probably win. Had he made that final 3rd down play, the Colts definitely win. I mean, seriously, what were the odds that any NFL kicker is going to miss a 32 yard field goal? You can't really say that was an "either/or". NFL kickers make that kick 95% of the time. Folk didn't win that game, Sanchez did.
Drax
I guess it's purposeful. My point is that each quarterback played well enough to win or lose and "won" or "lost" based on what someone else did. Sure, the QB got the team in a position to win by getting into field goal range. That's why I say that "each quarterback played well enough to win or lose." Sure, the QB put the team into range where a "pick six" or a punt/kick-off return decided the game. That's why I say that "each quarterback played well enough to win or lose." But the DECIDING FACTOR was the play of someone else. The DECIDING FACTOR was entirely out of the control of the quarterback. The DECIDING FACTOR determined whether the quarterback "won" or "lost" the game when the actual QUARTERBACK PLAY was definitively and simply enough to win OR lose and the "win" or "loss" was ENTIRELY decided by the play of someone else completely out of the quarterback's control. (And, the notion that Sanchez won the game is simply laughable. He played an almost competent game and made some plays at critical times (plays that had he played competently the rest of the game, he would not have had to make). L.T. and Ryan's defensive scheme "won" that game.
CosmicConservative
LOL, Drax, you were the one who claimed that games are frequently decided at the end with only seconds or a few minutes left, and tried to use that to show how neither Peyton nor Sanchez was the deciding factor. I think my recitation of the final four minutes or so of the game YOU CHOSE to use as an example is pretty much an almost perfect example of my point about the play of key players at the true key moments of the game. Peyton blew his chances, Sanchez made the most of his. That's all there is to the final five minutes of the game. Both teams and players made plays and missed plays for the first 55 minutes. That last five though, Sanchez outplayed Peyton. That's all that was necessary to win the game. You can claim that a field goal was the deciding factor, but I think any coach or player in the NFL, if asked what play and what player made the difference, would not pick Folk.
Drax
Sigh. You apparently don't understand my argument. I say that each QB played well enough to win the game. This is demonstrably true as each Quarterback in each of the cited instances was in a position where he could have either won or lost - without doing more - UNABLE to do more and "won" or "lost" based solely upon the performance of someone else. This is demonstrably true. I demonstrated it above. Many times. In some of the biggest games in the history of football. I'm not saying that the play of the various QB's don't, throughout the game - or even on the final play - make a difference in whether the game was won or lost. Of course his play contributes - many times (most times these days) moreso than any other person. But, that ain't the argument. The argument is that QB's can be RANKED in their greatness based on whether or not they have won superbowls. I have demonstrated that EVEN IN THOSE SUPERBOWL WINS, whether or not the QB "wins" or "loses" can come down to a single play over which the QB has no control, yet, that QB gets "credit" for the win. In an earlier thread, I compared Warner and Brady. I demonstrated that, head to head, had a single kicker not made a kick, then the Superbowl wins would be 2 each, instead of Brady 3 and Warner 1. Of course, had an official made a call a different way, then Brady wouldn't have gone to another SB, and it would be Warner 2 and Brady 1. Etc. The point is that you rank these QB's as if they "win" a game. It's laughable. QB's seldom "win" a game. They don't design the plays they run. They don't call the plays they run. They don't run the ball that they hand off. They don't catch the ball they throw. They don't block or create a lane. They don't defend. They don't kick. They don't return kicks. They are part of a team. And, many times, they are only the most important part of ONE THIRD of the team - and frequently the least important third. Anyway, we've beat this to death. I'll keep ranking Quarterbacks based on his actual play. You'll keep ranking them based on how many Superbowls they've "won."