On "Spirituality"
By CosmicConservativeOn my previous post a comment was made about my view of "spirituality" which essentially expressed surprise that I would even bring up "spirituality" since in general I seem not to "believe" in such things.
That's unfortunate since my view of spiritual things is, in my perhaps self-centered view, complex and subtle.
But first I must approach the whole concept of "belief." This is a very critical thing to understand about me, especially since so many people toss around the idea of "belief" with such casual abandon that it becomes a ubiquitous, inchoate rationale for any philosophy or ideology. Which is unfortunate because I think "belief" is a key attribute of most religions, but not much else.
One thing I see and hear a lot from people is that "you have to believe something." For example, if someone challenges a particular religious concept of the creation of the universe, it is not uncommon to hear the retort "well, you BEELLIIEEVVEE in the Big Bang, that's the same thing!"
Except it's not.
See, here's the problem. In the purest, most intellectually profound, philosophically important sense, I don't "believe" anything. I "accept" certain things as practical reality, but that's not the same thing as "belief." For example, I accept, as a practical reality, that if I step off a roof, I will fall. But I don't "believe" any explanation of why I fall. I don't "believe" in gravity. I accept as a practical reality that I will fall.
This is why I don't follow any particular religion. I simply don't "believe" any religious back story. They all sound equally absurd and unrealistic to me.
But this is also why I'm not an atheist. I find it just as hard to "believe" that there IS NO GOD as I find it to "believe" that there IS A GOD. There simply isn't sufficient evidence to reach a rationally defensible conclusion on the subject of the existence or non-existence of god.
Oh I have IDEAS about God. But they don't match any religion that I have ever encountered. And for most people, my ideas about God would no doubt qualify as heresy or worse. So I don't talk about it much.
Now, as a matter of practical use of language, I will frequently use the word "believe" in the colloquial sense, and could well do so in this very post, but I don't apologize for that. It is virtually impossible to communicate with others without relying on colloquialisms. But take my word for it, I don't "believe" anything in any sense of the word which implies that I have any certainty whatsoever about the fundamental nature of the universe.
So, getting back to "spirituality"... well, what is "spirituality?" I'm sure there are thousands of mutually incompatible definitions of the word, but I'll go ahead and explain what I mean by the word. It's pretty simple.
The universe as we observe it appears to follow certain immutable principles. Among those principles are things like the Laws of Thermodynamics (particularly the second law), and other things like the Theory of Relativity (which describes limits to causality and the direction arrow of time). My view of this can be generalized as the concept that our universe is governed by physical laws that appear to be unbreakable.
Now, remember I don't "believe" anything. So I don't "believe" this. However, I am willing to accept as a practical reality that these limits describe reality better than anything else humans have ever used to describe reality. And my experience and review of the history of the world indicates to me that these principles effectively describe pretty much everything that can be objectively verified.
As an example, I accept as a practical reality that death is permanent and irreversible. I know there are all kinds of stories from just about every religion on earth about death being reversed. I don't believe them. I know there are millions of stories from people who claim to have encountered "spirits" who were once living humans. I don't believe them. (Besides, I find the whole concept of the spirits of my ancestors "watching over me" infinitely creepy. If spirits are watching me all the time, they are seeing lots of things I don't want them to see, ranging from me picking my nose to me perhaps throwing childish temper tantrums. Such voyeurism is highly objectionable to me on principled grounds.)
In spite of this, I don't reject the notion that there is something beyond the expression of universal principles such as thermodynamics. In fact I, like pretty much every human being, desperately HOPE that there is something beyond what we understand about those principles. This is in large part because I don't like what those laws predict about the final disposition of the universe and everything in it.
But beyond even that, I have some odd notions about things such as "free will" and "physical continuity". I find it philosophically unappealing to conclude that our universe is completely deterministic, and I find it equally philosophically unappealing to conclude that our universe is driven by some combination of deterministic laws and random quantum effects.
Neither of those explanations allows me to explain "free will."
I think I've said before on this blog that there is nothing that is as important as the concept of "free will." Nothing. Without free will there is no purpose to the universe, no hope for individual accomplishment and no purpose in valuing the concept of "quality of life."
And yet free will is completely outside the ability of our current understanding of the principles of the universe to explain. In fact, our current understanding of the principles of the universe would seem to exclude free will as a concept.
Perhaps I should say that although I don't think I "believe" anything, the only thing I MIGHT BELIEVE IN is free will. But that's purely a selfish thing. I want to believe in free will because I can't conceive of a universe with any meaning or purpose in the absence of free will.
So, in a nutshell, my concept of spirituality is totally and inextricably intertwined with the concept of free will. So when I talk about how I need to work on my "spiritual side" that can almost always be interpreted as a need to address making better choices and exerting more willpower to make those better choices.
My pursuit of understanding "free will" takes me to some pretty weird places too. I wonder sometimes if the "real world" is just some sort of illusion and our "spiritual nature" is expressed through the real world as part of some process to provide growth opportunities, or even testing, of our moral compass. In that sense my concept of "spirituality" wanders into the realm of religion. But it wanders strange, uncommon and potentially untracked paths through that realm. During those moments I can entertain the notion of extra-physical continuities of will, something that might be construed as a "soul". However, when contemplating that possibility, I rarely venture into the brightly lit venues of organized religion, tending towards shadowy realms with treacherous philosophical foundations where anthropomorphic interpretations are almost rejected out of hand, even if that leaves the realm unformed and chaotic.
In that sense I am a deeply spiritual person. It's just that most people probably would not recognize my travels in that realm as what they mean by "spirituality."
Not sure if this helps or not.
Comments (45)