Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

NASA plays the media...

By CosmicConservative
A NASA press release announcing "an astrobiology finding" -- something that will impact the search for extraterrestrial life -- has sent shockwaves through the blogosphere. The press release simply announces an event, set for Thursday at 2 p.m. EST, to discuss an astrobiology discovery "that will impact the search for evidence of extraterrestrial life." via FoxNews.com - Rumor Roundup: Has NASA Discovered Alien Life?.
Gotta give NASA credit for this from a PR perspective. The announcement a few days ago that there would be a press conference to reveal something new about the search for extraterrestrial life has really stirred up the blogosphere. I guess I can't really call myself "CosmicConservative" without weighing in on this before tomorrow's press conference. My guess is that the quote above is the key to the whole thing. They believe they have discovered something that impacts the potential discovery of extraterrestrial life. That's what they say. So, what could that be? Well, there are a couple of likely candidates based on other space news stories I've seen lately, and based on the areas of expertise of the scientists giving the press conference. First, and most likely, is that they believe they have discovered a different "marker" which could be detected at a great distance to indicate the likely presence of life. Right now the most well-known "marker" for life is atmospheric oxygen. Since oxygen is one of the most reactive elements around, it tends to get bound up in chemical compounds very rapidly. Thus it is thought that atmospheric oxygen (not ozone, that's a different thing) would be an almost certain indicator of living processes. Methane is another potential marker, as is any evidence of chlorophyll. Exobiologists spend a lot of time looking for tiny bits of evidence of those markers. But those are well known markers. But oxygen based life may not be the only form of life, particularly at temperatures where water is not likely to exist (water is generally thought to be necessary for life, and is also, not coincidentally, considered an excellent source of oxygen if life is present). The problem is that water based life requires a very narrow range of temperatures (called the "Goldilocks zone" in exobiology). So it may be that NASA scientists have come up with a strong theory of, for example, life based on a methane/ethane cycle that operates similar to the water cycle on earth. If so, perhaps their models predict a chemical presence similar to oxygen that would be a good marker for methane/ethane sea-based life. This would potentially greatly increase the number of candidate planets for life since most of the planets we discover are either too close or too far away from their sun for liquid water. Of course there could be any number of other chemical bases for life, so perhaps they have postulated one that would fit with an early Mars environment. Who knows? But I suspect it is something like that. I doubt they have discovered any proof of life outside of earth, something like that would have leaked by now I'm certain. But discovering a non-water based possible means to support life could probably be kept under wraps. The other possibility, much less likely imho, is that they have discovered one or more of the more common markers on one of the newly discovered planets that are close to or in the Goldilocks zone. That would be huge for us since that would imply a potential colonizable world. But again, that would probably be big enough that it would have leaked by now. We'll see. I am curious.

Comments (8)

JSullins
Cosmic, you're way off: "Ladies and gentlemen of the press, thank you for joining us today. The news we have to share is going to change everything we understand about space, life, and politics." *raise* "Politics?" "Yes. You see, we have found conclusive proof that President Obama was in fact not born in the United States. He is an alien. An alien from Alpha Centauri. We are prepared to make public (mostly through Wikileaks) a manifesto outlining a plan to conquer the Earth by systematically and thoroughly crippling the nations most likely to oppose invaders from another planet." *gasps* *newsfeed goes dead*
CosmicConservative
On one of the technology/space blogs I read (I don't remember which one and can't look them up from work) reports a rumor that the announcement is indeed about using a different "marker", in this case arsenic, which would be comparable to oxygen (meaning if it is found in any quantities it probably is a biological source), having been discovered in significant quantities on Saturn's moon Titan. If true that would pretty much be exactly what I was suspecting in my option #1 above.
JSullins
What I've seen is that it's all about Arsenic and bacteria that have Arsenic in their DNA instead of Phosphorous, which was previously thought to be a necessary element for life. This bacteria (found in yellowstone) don't need no stinkin' phosphorous, and does it's thing with an Arsenic-rich environment.
CosmicConservative
You nailed it jsullins. NASA is saying that they have discovered a bacterium living in Mono Lake in California which has its DNA incorporating arsenic in the place of phosphorous. These bacteria respirate with arsenic. But the bigger deal here is that the DNA of these bacteria is freaking alien DNA, man! In other words, we have discovered truly alien life. It's just coincidental that it was discovered on earth. Even more important is the implication that if there are TWO versions of DNA, there could easily be three, or a dozen. Basically "life as we know it" has just become a huge unknown again. Which is really cool in my opinion.
staylor
This is pretty cool. And not to brag I grew up on the shores of Mono Lake and live only about twenty miles away from it. It is a cool place with a unique ecosystem, I just did not know that it was alien life forms cool. Its going to be popping up in sci fi books in perpetuity now.
JSullins
...I for one welcome our new poison-bacteria overlords...
CosmicConservative
Hmmm... according to Cosmic Log, a science blog, they didn't "discover" this new DNA, they essentially forced existing bacteria to use arsenic in place of phosphorous. That's different, but still fascinating and still shows that arsenic-based DNA is viable. (Although I should also point out that some scientists are questioning if the NASA scientists have actually proven that the arsenic is being used by the cellular metabolism or if it has just contaminated it.)