Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Don't Ask, Don't Tell final DoD report

By CosmicConservative
As regular readers of this site should know, I'm not much of a "social conservative." I'm mostly a fiscal, foreign policy and constitutional conservative. So the issue of gays in the military is not one that I'm terribly overwrought about. I'm sure many social conservatives will assert that the just released final Department of Defense report on the potential repeal of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" is some sort of politically correct fabrication prepared at the command of President Obama, but, as with most things, until I see some evidence of such malfeasance I will assume that the authors of the report are decent, honest, ethical folks dealing with a difficult question the best way they can. The report itself is long and covers a lot of different areas, including breaking down attitudes according to branch of service and even into units of command within the branches of service. Not surprisingly the Marines seem to be the branch with the most concerns about repealing the policy. But even within the Marines there is only a minority voicing concern over the repeal. Here is the money quote:
Based on all we saw and heard, our assessment is that, when coupled with the prompt implementation of the recommendations we offer below, the risk of repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell to overall military effectiveness is low. We conclude that, while a repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell will likely, in the short term, bring about some limited and isolated disruption to unit cohesion and retention, we do not believe this disruption will be widespread or long-lasting, and can be adequately addressed by the recommendations we offer below. Longer term, with a continued and sustained commitment to core values of leadership, professionalism,and respect for all, we are convinced that the U.S. military can adjust and accommodate this change, just as it has others in history.
Now, just a bit of blogging business here, the above quote was actually lifted from the Volokh Conspiracy because I couldn't copy out of the .pdf file itself for some reason. Other than just wanting to see Obama twist in the wind on this policy for purely partisan reasons, I really don't have any major problem with repeal of the DADT policy, and in the wake of this report I believe that if Republicans stonewall on this issue they will lose a lot of the independent and moderate voters who defected to them in the last election. This should probably be done quickly and Republicans should stay focused on what the American people just elected them to do, which is to control spending, control taxes and stop the rampant stampede towards socialism that Obama has embarked upon.

Comments (41)

Tom DeGisi
Maybe there could be a compromise for the Marines and combat units. It was a really strong minority of the Marines objecting, a majority in combat units, and a rather strong majority of Marine combat units, IIRC. The Marine commandant is against it as well. Based on that, a full repeal of DADT seems like a bad idea to me. No repeal seems just as bad. We don't have women in combat units, so there is precedent. How come I haven't heard anyone else saying what I just said? I'm not that smart. Am I that stupid? Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
I can't see how the Pentagon could justify a different policy for gays in the Marines vs. gays in the Army or Air Force. The Marines are by far the smallest branch of the armed services, and yes they have a great and honorable record of service, but I don't buy the hoopla that the Marines are "better" than the Army, Navy or Air Force. If they try to have a separate policy for the Marines then the issue will become even more partisan and politicized than it already is. So not only would it be a nightmare to administer for the DoD, it would be a major distraction for our military until it is finally brought into line with the rest of the military. I can only imagine the number of lawsuits that would be brought on the basis of unequal protection, for example. If you are suggesting an overall "no gays in combat units" policy, I think that would be equally politically disastrous and equally distracting for the Pentagon. I guess we'll just have to wait and see what happens.
CosmicConservative
Well, the first recourse of the survey objector is to cast doubt on the reliability of the survey itself. Perhaps that is a valid concern. But there's no way to know.
Tom DeGisi
> Perhaps that is a valid concern. But there’s no way to know. Sure there is. Redo the survey in a way that works to maximize the trust of the surveyed. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom, I'm not sure that's really possible either. If people are already that overly sensitive to the issue being surveyed, then a new survey will likely just convince them that the powers that be didn't like the results of the first survey, and will encourage some to ignore the second survey since they will feel that they'll just keep getting surveys until the government gets what it wants. Survey paranoia is increased with each new survey on the same subject.
Tom DeGisi
Well, then you know the first survey wasn't any good. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Well, I'm not convinced that the first one "wasn't any good."
Tom DeGisi
> Well, I’m not convinced that the first one “wasn’t any good.” That's why you check it. 70% of those surveyed did not respond. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
I'm too busy to go dig into it Tom, but I suspect a 30% response rate to a massive survey of that type probably isn't too bad. And all that matters is if it provides a statistically meaningful response, which I suspect a 30% return rate probably does. The issue raised is whether people were disproportionately inclined to dispose of the survey instead of responding if they were opposed to ending the DADT policy. I simply don't think there's any way to know that. That's all. I've done some surveys of my own in the past. I used to work for a software company and we would send surveys out to every single one of our customers. A 30% response rate would have been overwhelming. We usually got more in the 5 - 10% range, if we were lucky.
Drax
CC: I'm glad that you're comfortable with your daughter, against her will (or knowledge, perhaps) showering with heterosexual men. I'm sure that she would have no issue with getting nekkid with people who view her as an object of sexual desire. It's good to not be a social conservative. It makes decisions like these easy.
CosmicConservative
Drax, I'm afraid I don't see it the same way you do. I would rather my daughter KNOW who might view her as a sexual object. The current policy does not protect her from having homosexuals in the shower with her, it just keeps her from knowing who they are. Homosexuals have served in the military forever. Men and women have showered with homosexuals forever. There is nothing about this issue that changes that in any way, except that allowing gays to be open about it lets people know who they are. I suspect most will still stay in the closet in the military anyway. By the way, we had communal showers in college. I spent two years showering with total strangers. Just by the law of averages, I've almost certainly showered with gay men myself. So have you.
Tom DeGisi
Well, I think some of the arguments for keeping homosexuals out of combat units are similar to the ones for keeping women out of combat units. Sexual tension plus combat adds stress. Lack of sexual tension (because your lover is in your unit) plus combat adds stress. Added stress results in more PTSD. There are other arguments for keeping women out of combat which obviously don't apply. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom, I hear this sort of argument all the time. I simply don't understand it. It's actually a total non sequitur. Just like Drax's argument above it seems to assert something that is absolutely known to be false, and use that as a basis for a policy argument. Neither the current policy nor the proposed policy do anything to keep homosexuals out of the military. It just says that if you are homosexual you can't tell and the military won't ask. Which means that homosexuals are (and have been forever) serving in our forces NOW. There is sexual tension TODAY because someone's lover is in their unit. Combat adds stress TODAY. Why do I see so many people on this subject arguing based in the completely flawed foundation that the current military does not have homosexuals in it now? Are you and Drax proposing an entirely DIFFERENT policy, one that demands proof of heterosexuality before you can join the military? I just don't get what you're saying here. It seems to fly totally in the face of the facts as I know them.
Drax
CC: You seem to think that it's okay to be FORCED to shower, dress, get nekkid, sleep with, and otherwise be in intimate circumstance with people who view you as an object of sexual desire. Gee. Maybe we should just have men and women shower and bathe together. Sleep together. Save a bunch of money in quartering, don't you think? After all, it's okay with you to have your daughter be FORCED to endure the stares of others, some of whom she KNOWS to be looking upon her with desire (rather than suspect) when she can't do anything to prevent it. And, since they're "full members" of the armed forces, now, she'd have to endure the advances, some by her superiors. There's no problem with that, I'm sure. And, of course, since she's FORCED to live where she lives (say...on a boat in cramped quarters for 6 months to a year at a pop) since she'll be jammed into a small, 3 layer bunk bed - nut to butt - sleeping arrangement with the person whose advances she rebuffed - that won't cause no problems, I'm convinced! With homosexuals openly serving, you'll have ALL THE PROBLEMS you have with heterosexual male female relationships (and attempted relationships .. and failed relationships .. and forced relationships...) with the ADDITIONAL burden that THERE IS NO ESCAPE. You can't leave your abusive boss at work, because...he SLEEPS WITH YOU. She showers with you. That guy that's chasing after you? Can't get away from him, now. He's got his head nestled against your FEET. He's washing up as you exit the shower. Just a bad, bad, bad idea.
CosmicConservative
Drax... again... everything you describe happens TODAY! NOW! Under the CURRENT LAW!! What is so hard to understand about that? Why do you keep raising this as an issue? Changing the policy from what it is TODAY to repealing DADT doesn't change a thing about whether homosexuals shower or sleep with other soldiers!!! Well, you didn't get that the other two times I posted it, so I guess you won't get it this time either. Let's play a little thought experiment game. Let's say that I was "forced" to shower and sleep with women in the military. Would I leer and ogle them openly? No, I would do my level best to be professional and polite. Would I want to sleep with every woman I saw? No, I'd have some who appealed to me and most who do not. This is true of homosexuals as well. Homosexuals are not deviants who prey on unsuspecting vulnerable heterosexuals. They just aren't. There are certainly some psychopaths in all groups of people, but the vast majority of homosexuals are decent, caring, polite and professional people. Just like the vast majority of heterosexuals. This sort of thing is one reason social conservatives are called "haters." This whole line of argument presents homosexuals as deviant caricatures of themselves.
CosmicConservative
... also, if another soldier is doing ANYTHING to abuse or frighten you, YOU HAVE RECOURSE. You can report them. Of course there will be abuse. THERE'S ABUSE NOW. Back in the bad old days when homosexuals were supposedly BANNED FROM THE MILITARY a group of lesbians took control of a female base and abused several heterosexual women. WHEN THEY WERE BANNED FROM SERVICE!
Drax
You, not having served in the service, not having been in the cramped and intimate confines of a naval vessel for months on end, don't understand the situation. What happens NOW is that people who are believed to be homosexuals are avoided to the extent possible. Those who are homosexual and wish to remain in the service do everything in their power NOT to get into situations where they will be "outed" -- they don't make advances towards heterosexuals (welcome or unwelcome); they don't leer at the naked bodies of their bunkmates; they don't talk about their sexual exploits to the discomfort of their fellows; they don't make passes at their shipmates with whom they're confined for months at a time, etc. In short, THEY avoid, to the extent possible, situations where they put their shipmates into circumstances where they are uncomfortable and could cause them to professional problems. Certainly we KNOW that some people serving are homosexual. Certainly, we KNOW that, when we dress, that there MIGHT be someone who isn't just casually glancing at us -- but are, instead, measuring our junk. But, we also know, for the most part, who they are because we share the beach with them and know who does what and with whom (and who DOESN'T do what with whom...) In my day, those guys showered when no one else was around. They did everything they could to ensure that there was no reason for anyone to confront them on the beach and beat the hell out of them. What you say about all this happening NOW is just false. It's NOT "happening now." Homosexuals are NOT making passes at straights (if they wish to stay in the service). Homosexual superiors are NOT using the power of their position to obtain sexual favors (if they wish to stay in the service). Right NOW, there is an EXTRA LAYER of protection that soldiers and sailors have against the unwanted intimate interaction from their peers and superiors -- they have the hammer of dismissal from the service, something which does not exist vis a vis heterosexual intimate interaction. Now, if it's repealed, then if YOU, a heterosexual, don't WANT to be forced to shower with a homosexual, not only will you have no choice, but the service will BACK THE HOMOSEXUAL. That's the end result. A heterosexual who doesn't want to have sexual advances from homosexuals will no more be able to avoid them than she can advances from heterosexuals today. So, what I said earlier stands. If this is repealed, you'll have ALL THE PROBLEMS of heterosexual relations with the ADDITION of those caused by homosexual relations and homosexual/heterosexual relations. (I know, it exits today to some degree. I did, in fact, SERVE in the military, and have first hand experience with that reality) But, if it's repealed, much of what is problematic with men/women serving in close confines becomes INESCAPABLE, because there ain't no men's, women's, and homosexual quarters. And, any attempt to make them keep their eyes to themselves, keep themselves covered up, stop talking about their sex lives, making advances, and doing all the things which are uncomfortable for some in male/female interaction, is SANCTIONED and PROTECTED. It all sounds good, to "allow homosexuals to serve," but it's just a bad, bad, bad idea.
CosmicConservative
... and I say again. They are serving now. I don't believe that now a simple assertion that someone made a pass at another soldier will get a soldier drummed out of the service. They will want some sort of proof. That proof would work in the new law too.
CosmicConservative
Let's see, I'm 50 years old, almost 51. I've worked most of my adult career in circumstances where homosexuals are essentially a "protected class." True I don't ALWAYS sleep or shower with them, but on trips I have shared rooms with one or two. If you are to be believed, such open encouragement of their lifestyle must mean that homosexuals in my place of business are making passes at heterosexuals all the time. Never happened to me. Never. Not once. I have been a manager for most of my career. I deal with employee relations all the time. I've managed up to 40 people at a time, for long periods of time. I've gone to Human Resources for a wide variety of personal personnel issues between employees. I've had to go to court over one and had to prepare a deposition in another. In all those years, how many times did I encounter a situation where a heterosexual man or woman reported and had to fend off unwanted sexual advances from a homosexual? Never. Not once. Now, in that deposition case I did have to get involved in a case where a heterosexual was fending off the unwanted advances of another heterosexual. Are you suggesting that women should be banned from the military to stop that sort of thing?
Drax
Let's just say that the world of the enlisted man, out to sea for 6 months to a year at a pot, ain't the normal working world, and not even attempt to compare your working life with that of a serviceman.
CosmicConservative
Well, since it is highly likely that the DADT policy will be terminated and homosexuals will be able to openly join the military, we'll get a chance to see if it destroys morale and makes our armed services impotent. I'm betting that won't happen. We'll get a chance to test it out.
Andy
Interesting discussion. I'll go ahead and throw the Iraeli card. It has been 18 years now for Israel, and from all I read it's not a problem...I mean, any more so than regular heterosexual harassment problems. Of course, Israel is different because of conscription. Has it made their forces less effective? Dunno. But, we could copy a lot of Israel's policies and have a much more sane, effective policy in many areas.
Andy
And, I want to go back to Tom's thoughts. You can't get inside the mind of others, of course. But I imagine that those with "strong" feelings on the subject would be most likely to answer the survey. I have an opinion on the subject, but I'm not sure I would answer a numbered survey, knowing that it could be traced to me. Supposing that...roughly 70% either don't care one way or the other, or DO care, but not enough to risk the possibility that their opinion might somehow come back to bite them in the future. I think the idea of a survey is flawed, unless it is compulsory, and totally anonymous. And, it might even be flawed then. I'd just leave it to the Generals, and the CIC. If DADT is abandoned, we'll know pretty quickly if it was a good idea or not. There will be another CIC one day, and different guys/gals in charge of the military, too. It could take a generation to undo any damage that might be caused. But, it might not cause any damage at all. See, that's me...decisive.
Drax
CC: I'm confused. Did I say that allowing homosexuals to openly serve would "destroy morale" or render our services "impotent?" No. You just decided to put those words into my mouth. I said it would cause problems which don't currently exist. Increase existing problems. (Much like allowing women to serve on combat vessels. Has it rendered our Navy "impotent?" No. Has it "destroyed morale?" No. Has it caused PROBLEMS? Uh...yeah.) There is no good MILITARY REASON to further tinker with this issue, only a POLITICAL one. If it doesn't cause more problems than currently exist (which I find to be extraordinarily difficult to believe) then, we're no better off than we are not (unless there is some argument that homosexuals are SUPERIOR to heterosexuals or that serving "in the closet" renders homosexual military performance INFERIOR to their performance serving openly); but if there are problems, then those are problems which are self-inflicted, and, ANY "problem" in the military degrades effectiveness. As I said, it's a bad, bad, bad idea.
Drax
Oh. How openly homosexual soldiers are accepted in other countries with differing cultures really isn't a comparison which convinces me of anything about anything. And, further, like the problems caused by having females in the military (especially on combat ships and in combat units), we really don't hear much about the problems which arise in our OWN military, let alone those which arise in the militaries of other countries...
Andy
Drax, I didn't mean to try to convince of anything by mentioning Israel. I have just always found their policy interesting...just like their mandatory service policy (which I would not be against here, if done properly).
CosmicConservative
Drax, you cannot separate military policy from politics. No more than you can separate school lunch policy from politics. And politics is driven in large part by shifts in social mores. A major shift in social mores in the USA over the past 40 years has been a sharp change in public acceptance of homosexuality. And I mean a sharp change. It is not possible for that much of a change in social mores to not cause political influence on military policy. I am not passing judgment on the policy. I am saying that I don't share the view of social conservatives that we should somehow keep the military adhering to social mores that are outdated by two generations. I was watching a movie the other day. The movie had Audrey Hepburn and Shirley MacLaine as two young ladies running a boarding school. The movie was made in the 60s, somewhere between 40 and 50 years ago. (Wow, time flies). The entire premise of the movie was that a girl in the school accused the two teachers of having a homosexual affair, and the result of that accusation was the total ruination of the boarding school and the eventual suicide of Shirley MacLaine's character. Throughout the movie it was clear that just the concept of a homosexual relationship between two young women was something worth destroying the lives of anyone touched by the two women. That's how our society viewed homosexuality in the 60s. That's not remotely how homosexuality is viewed today. It is my opinion that your view of this issue is not the view shared by the great majority of new recruits in the armed forces. It is my opinion that ending Don't Ask, Don't Tell and allowing homosexuals to join the military will be a blip on the overall historical trajectory of our military services. In fact I don't think it will have remotely the same impact that de-segregating the military in the 60s had. Regardless of the potential for some additional friction in the military, the political reality is that this nation simply cannot treat homosexuals as a protected class in every other social setting, but treat them as pariahs in the military. It simply is not politically possible to do so. That's the reality of the situation. As I said, you and I can certainly voice our opinions on the matter, but the bottom line is that the political and social forces at play here are inevitable. My postition on this is that the concerns stated by social conservatives on this issue are greatly exaggerated. And as I said, we will find out soon enough.
Drax
Well, the "rest of society" ain't the military. The military is DIFFERENT. Radically so. And, within the military, as you go deeper into combat related or extended (and confined deployment) units, they are as different from the rest of the military as the military is from the rest of society. "Society" doesn't have a mission. The military does. How homosexuals are treated in the military (or where or if they are allowed to serve) is a question of military effectiveness, not of political expediency. But, as you say...as Lenin said...politics is, ultimately, everything ... including the military.
CosmicConservative
I might also point out that other than the Marines, none of the brass of the other forces (including the Navy, where people are "forced" to sleep and shower together in the tightest quarters) are objecting to the policy change, and the current Secretary of Defense, who has served under both conservative Republicans and liberal Democrats, champions repeal of DADT.
Drax
And, let me make this clear... Each of the offices, commands, positions you named are POLITICAL offices, commands, and positions.
CosmicConservative
They still run the show. And other than the Secretary of Defense, they all were career military officers. Like the head of the Joint Chiefs of Staff who today told the troops that DADT was going away, homosexuals will be welcomed into the military and if a soldier doesn't like it, they will be out of a job.
Drax
Hmmm. So, the Head of the JCS said that anyone who doesn't like it is "out of a job?" How, exactly, does one in the service who doesn't like some aspect of that service come to be "out of a job?" I suspect that there are tens of thousands of currently serving soldiers and sailors who, when confronted with an aspect of service that they found to be unpalatable, to inform their superiors of that fact so that they can be released from their duty. Sorry. Doesn't work that way. The soldiers and sailors who are FORCED to endure situations they feel are well beyond unendurable will be FORCED to continue enduring them. You don't get to get "out of a job" in the military because you're forced into situations you don't like. What you ARE forced to do is shut up about those circumstances. What you ARE forced to do is put up with those circumstances. What the head of the JCS SAID was what he, as a suck-up political officer in the U.S. military who is charged with carrying out the POLITICAL aims of the civilian authority, was expected to say.
CosmicConservative
{kick kick kick} ... nope, horse still dead...
Tom DeGisi
Going back in time.... > Well, I’m not convinced that the first one “wasn’t any good.” My wife says she heard from people who answered it that the survey was completely bogus and designed to reach the conclusions it reached. She said she heard examples of specific questions which were badly done. So, CC, why would you trust the current executive branch to do anything honestly without political taint? In other words, since you don't trust nearly anything else the Obama administration does, why trust them this time? Yours, Tom
Drax
Well, I do remember when BUSH was President, that THEN the survey reached altogether different conclusions.
CosmicConservative
Yeah, because then the people who wanted to end DADT didn't respond because they knew what the evil BOOOOSH wanted them to say...
Drax
No, it's more along the lines of: "You can make a survey say just about whatever you wish it to by the wording of the questions."