Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Guitar blues...

By CosmicConservative
Why do I still suck at playing guitar? I can play tons of chords. I can finger notes clearly. I can handle many songs in the songbooks I have, but only in terms of playing the chords. I got no rhythm. I got no soul. I got no spark. I got no jones. Put a guitar in my hand and I can do scales, chords and even blues progressions until my fingers bleed. But I can't make MUSIC. What the hell's wrong with me?

Comments (25)

CosmicConservative
Oh, that's real helpful Dadman. And so compassionate too. Thanks.
Dadman
What? I'm just guessing there might be a correlation. Artists feel or intuit their way through their art and music is certainly no exception. Talented musicians not only know the chords, scales, progressions, they know how to put them together to create wonderful arrangements of music. Writers put familiar words together in ways that can, if arranged correctly, produce a work of art. Visual artists arrange color, lines, perspective, texture, etc. to create masterpieces. They FEEL their art and I think it's related to fully grokking the aesthetics of whatever medium they are using. You asked a question. I'm simply trying to offer a plausible answer. I hope you didn't take offense. I don't think there is anything wrong with you at all...
Dadman
Didn't mean to sound uncompassionate. Very few human beings are true artists. I don't consider myself one of them by any stretch. I think musicians, painters, illustrators, etc. are wired up in ways the rest of us don't really understand.
Andy
Dadman's right. It's a "wiring" thing. I learned the piano as a kid...three years of lessons. Even though I could play, it didn't really sound like "music." My oldest son never took a lesson, and even his most awkward early efforts sounded like something one would want to listen to. After a month or two of him playing around on it, you could sit and listen all day. He's just wired for it.
CosmicConservative
These are not the responses I was looking for. "I want to play the guitar and make music" "Tough luck bozo, you just don't have the knack." I don't deal with that sort of thing well...
JSullins
Well. I may never have told you this, Cosmic, but I was a musician most of my life. Started in the 4th grade and was playing up until I got married, roughly. Did gigs, played in countless, countless orchestras, even a stint in the Fort Collins Symphony. I think you and I have some similar personality tendencies... Although I mastered the "craft" of my instrument, I often also struggled with musicality. Then, while in college, I learned a "trick." For me, the trick to musicality came with getting in touch with pain. Not physical pain, of course. I'm talking about your disappointments, your yearnings, and your unfulfilled dreams. Once I did that, and paired it with the right kinds of music selections, it worked very well for me. For awhile, I had quite a solo career going. Of course, once I met my girlfriend (now wife) it all kind of broke down. My suspicions are that this would work for you, though. You and I often approach the world the same way I think -- analyze it and manufacture the appropriate response to it for a given situation. But, with music it takes a different approach than what comes naturally to an analytical person. Try my trick :) It doesn't really work with "happy" music, though, so... heh.
CosmicConservative
Good points jsullins... No, I didn't know that about you. What instrument do you play? Do you still keep your hand in? I played trombone in junior high school and my freshman year in high school. Both of the band teachers I had made all brass instrument players learn all brass instruments (except trombone, actually, only trombone players had to learn trombone). So I learned to play trumpet, cornet, bass, french horn, baritone, even tuba. Of course, as any brass player knows, most of those have exactly the same fingering and just a different range. I thought I was a pretty good trombone player, I was first chair most of my time in the band (until I got thrown out for having a trombone fight with the second-chair trombone player, I think I've mentioned that before...) I also dabbled in the piano and managed to learn a few songs and seemed to have some little knack for tickling the ivories. But for some reason I just can't seem to meld with the guitar. It's probably because I don't practice finger-picking as much as I should. That's the way I really want to play guitar, but I find learning the techniques to be incredibly difficult. Just pounding out chords doesn't really appeal that much to me, and "lead guitar" seems mostly to be about mastering certain techniques that sound great when you have background music, but just annoys my family when I try to do that solo. On the "pain" thing.... Hmm... "getting in touch with pain".... I guess I am afraid that I don't really have a clue what this means. Besides, in my life that's a mighty reservoir backed up behind a massive and towering dam. Messing with that thing just might result in a cataclysmic flood that leaves nothing behind but mud puddles and rubble.
CosmicConservative
... one of the things that interferes with my guitar playing enjoyment is that I just never seem to be able to get comfortable holding the thing. I'm not sure why. I have medium sized hands, I can finger many chords that much more accomplished guitar players tell me they never mastered. I have very good manual dexterity and can control each finger separately. My arms are reasonably sized and I can reach up and down the neck comfortably. But I've never felt truly comfortable holding any guitar. It just feels sort of unwieldy and clumsy. And all but one of my guitars are auditorium style ("OOO" in Martin terms) so I'm already playing a slightly scaled down instrument. I wonder if I should pick up a mandolin or something to see if I find it more comfortable...
JSullins
Musically speaking, unleash your cataclysmic flood... that's what I mean. My instrument (being coy and secretive now) was a type that allowed for mournful expression, if one wanted to do that. With a guitar, perhaps that would be more difficult. Still, what I mean by "getting in touch with pain" would go something like this: Select a piece of music that resonates with you. By resonates, I mean that... well... the music can make you feel sad or mournful or full of longing when you hear it. Sappy, I know, apologies. You may want to hear a recording of it, in fact probably this is the way to go at first to find what you're looking for. Once you've found something suitable, don't try to reproduce what you heard, though. Instead, get yourself alone somewhere, if you can, to practice it. Then, while you play, think of the things I mentioned in my last post. When playing, it should be as though you are telling someone all about the things causing you pain, as you would in an earnest conversation. But instead of using words, you push out the things you would say with your instrument. You make your plaintive points with the sounds instead. I'm being melodramatic, and it certainly makes me queasy, heh. Still, it's all true. Unlocking this kind of thing when you are an analytical type (again I'm asserting that you and I both are) does not come naturally, at least not without some effort until you get the hang of it. In regard to techniques, etc: It is tempting to dwell on these. And they certainly have an important role. However, you can play musically at almost any level as long as the music you are attempting lies within your technical means. Learning more techniques just open up your selections, but you can still play the way I'm talking about with simpler selections, if that's all that's available to you.
JSullins
Heh, and by the way... You've now heard more on this topic from me than I've ever told anyone ;)
CosmicConservative
... me and the vast audience of CosmicConservative International.
JSullins
Gah! Well at least nobody knows my true identity ... <__>
CosmicConservative
The closest I've come to being "musical" on the guitar is when I sit down and pick out a melody of my own. I went to the trouble of learning the blues chord and scale progressions so I know how to pick out notes that are "in tune". In fact doing this it is surprisingly easy to reproduce the melody of many, if not most, pop songs. I've "arranged" a couple of tunes that I play, and I do tap into my feelings when I play the melodies I've arranged. I've also incorporated slides, hammer-ons, pull-offs and some vibrato into the melody. One of these days I might even lay down a chord background and do a dual-track recording of the thing to see how it sounds with accompaniment. But other than that I mostly just pick at the guitar or pound on a few chords that I like the sound of or just go through the song books I have playing the chords and, on occasion, some melody. On rare occasions (like when I'm completely alone in the house) I'll even try to sing along. But in general if you put a guitar in my hands, I can't do anything remotely interesting with it.
CosmicConservative
> …and what happened to my smileys there… Foiled by the auto formatting embedded in Wordpress, I'm afraid.
Logan Morgan
I am a musician. I have a BA in music and I earned a living at it for several years. Here's the real deal: Thomas Alva Edison said: "Genius is 1% inspiration and 99% perspiration!" You MUST play 3-6 hours per day for at least 7 years. If you do that, you will be a very good musician. I promise. The reality is, you have other interests and commitments that are probably more important. You have made other choices. But, it's never too late. Good luck. Logan
CosmicConservative
LOL, that's not a hobby, that's a JOB! I'm sure there's some pill I can just take. How long before we get those brain/internet jacks installed?
JSullins
To determine that date, use the following formula: D = L + 24h Where: D = Date of brain jack availability h = hours L = Expected lifespan of Cosmic
Dadman
Perhaps the next time you ask questions on your blog you can include some guidance on the kinds of responses that will meet your approval. Good luck with your guitar playing. I'll stand by my assertion that some people have it (artistic talent/apptitude) and some people don't. All the practice in the world will not make me a Mozart or a Van Gogh. It will, perhaps, make me better than most people, but talent matters; it takes good to great, and is often utterly inexplicable...
CosmicConservative
Heh... I guess I'm touchy... you see, you so frequently make comments about my lack of aesthetics that I took your comment as saying "Of course YOU can't play guitar because it requires aesthetics." I took it the wrong way perhaps. I concur that to be a Mozart requires something ineffable in the talent department. But I think there's a range of abilities when employing musical instruments, and even if I can't be Mozart, I should still be able to do SOMETHING interesting with the guitar. At least I think so.
Dadman
YOU frequently make comments about a lack of aesthetics. I doubt I'd ever mention it if you hadn't first made the observation here on your blog. I'm merely pointing out there MIGHT be a correlation, but I'm completely open to being completely wrong...
CosmicConservative
Whatever my presumed lack of aesthetics might be, I have defended my aesthetic appreciation in discussions many times, so while I acknowledge that in some areas (I usually mention fashion and interior decorating as probably the two most egregious areas) I've also pointed out that I feel pretty confident in my ability to demonstrate and appreciate aesthetics in many other areas, particularly music. I think perhaps there is a bit of both your assertion of aesthetic limitations and jsullins assertion of bottling up my emotional reactions to things. I wonder if there might be some correlation between those two things in a larger general context.... Perhaps my biggest problem is that I am wound too tight and can't just let things go musically. I dunno. I guess I'd prefer that the problem be that I bottle things up too much because I might have a shot some day of overcoming that. If I truly lack the aesthetics necessary to learn to be musical, I'm not sure what I can do about that.