Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Sarah Palin 2010 vs. Ronald Reagan 1978

By CosmicConservative
I keep hearing people talk about how much "gravitas" Reagan had in the 1980 election vs. Sarah Palin in the upcoming 2012 election. I also keep hearing about how much Reagan had done for the Republican Party vs. Sarah Palin and Reagan's supposed respect and admiration by the American people. Almost all of this is revisionist history at best, and pure bunk at worst. In 1978 it is true that Ronald Reagan had significantly more executive experience than Sarah Palin. He had been a two-term President of the Screen Actors' Guild and a two-term governor of California. But to take that and state that meant that Reagan was more generally acknowledged to have the experience and gravitas needed to run for President is either to demonstrate a complete ignorance of the electoral landscape of 1978-1980, or else it demonstrates a complete willingness to ignore actual history in favor of a narrative that is being used to diminish Sarah Palin. I was alive in 1978. I was 18 years old and had been following politics actively since Watergate. I was a voracious reader of political articles and periodicals, and was involved in debates on a daily basis about Jimmy Carter, Gerald Ford, Richard Nixon and, yes, Ronald Reagan. Let me tell you what the national gestalt on Ronald Reagan was in 1978. By far the overriding narrative on Reagan was the "Bedtime for Bonzo" narrative which the media had been hammering since Reagan's unsuccessful attempt in 1976 to snatch the nomination away from Gerald Ford. Ronald Reagan was routinely portrayed in the press as an intellectual lightweight who couldn't even succeed in Hollywood. He was interviewed several times and the interviews were every bit as damaging to his image as Sarah Palin's interviews were. The New York Times and other mainstream "news" outlets began running "fact checking" stories supposedly choosing only the "top ten" or so "Reaganisms" of the week. A favorite tactic was to find a clip of Reagan mispronouncing some difficult foreign name and replay that on the news repeatedly. At some point in the campaign Reagan mis-spoke and confused some Eastern European nation for another and that started the "concerned stories" about Reagan's supposed "senility." Then they began to question his health and age. In fact his age was such a huge issue that it carried over to his second term campaign where he famously quipped "I won't hold my opponent's youth and inexperience against him" a reference to the 60+ year old multi-term senator, Walter Mondale. People today who talk about how Palin can't be elected because she either is or has been portrayed as an "idiot" simply either have no memory of Reagan's campaign or choose to forget it. In the case of a tool like Peggy Noonan, since she was on Reagan's team, I have to assume she is deliberately "forgetting" the withering attacks on Reagan's intelligence, memory, mental acuity and age. The parallels with Palin are actually quite stunning. Reagan got past all of that not by being Governor of California, nor did he run for national office. What Reagan did was to take the position of host of a GE television series where he would be both the narrator of the show, and he gave a short monologue where he lauded the exceptionalism of the American system. He also went on a sustained lecture circuit where he gave conservative lectures in auditoriums across America. It was these shows where Reagan spoke directly to the American people that convinced the American people that Reagan was not the illiterate dunce that the New York Times portrayed him to be. In fact Sarah Palin's "Alaska" series, along with her Fox News gig, are quite comparable to Reagan's public appearances. That's why, two years ago, in my open letter to Sarah Palin, I recommended exactly that sort of direct appeal to the American people. That's what Reagan did and it trumped the attempt of the media to paint him as an extremist, a senile old man, a dunce and a shoot-from-the-hip cowboy. Comparing 1978 to 2010 I would actually say that Palin is ahead of Reagan in that regard. And one other thing. Reagan was not remotely the "insider" candidate in the 1980 election. The "Reagan revolution" that everyone talks about now was not simply a general election thing. The first part of the "Reagan revolution" was the part where Reagan re-invented the Republican party itself. Palin is attempting the same thing and with the Tea Party success of a few weeks ago, she can make a pretty compelling case that she's well ahead of Reagan's pace in the 1980 cycle. People continue to underestimate Palin, just as they underestimated Reagan. And in almost exactly the same way, using many of the same words and accusations. Reagan was an idiot. Reagan was unschooled. Reagan was unsophisticated. Reagan represented the "extreme right wing". Reagan was a warmonger. Etc. etc. etc... Those who say that we need another Reagan seem blissfully unaware of how similar Palin's history already is to Reagans. Yes Reagan had six more years of being a governor, but if you were to ask Reagan today, I would bet he would say those six years did little but give him practice in exercising his principles. His principles didn't change through those six years. Palin is still on track to being a powerful candidate in 2012. All the sniping and whining I'm hearing so far is doing nothing but convincing me that the same people or same sorts of people, are making the same mistakes all over again.

Comments (9)

Tom DeGisi
This article contains the best argument I've heard for getting behind Palin: Tea-Party President In 2012. In short, we have to keep the stupidest people (the Republican establishment) in the stupid party from giving us another Bob Dole or John McCain. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom, heh. I don't buy that argument either, I don't consider the BCCW ("Beltway Country Club Wing") of the Republican party to be "stupid." They aren't stupid, they are just completely infected with the same sort of "Walmart redneck" condescension that infects the leadership of the Democrat party. They want to nominate candidates who will continue their gravy train, which is not surprising, that's what people do. A world where Obama wins a second term by defeating Mike Huckabee is a better, more profitable, world for the Peggy Noonans and Karl Roves of the party, than a world where Sarah Palin reinvents the party as a neo-Reaganesgue conservative party which puts people like Jim Demint in charge. Peggy Noonan realizes that in such a world her influence will drop to virtually nil. The Republican leadership is, in my humble opinion, much closer to the Democrat leadership in philosophy and strategy than they are to the Tea Party. Republicans like Karl Rove have been promoting big-spending, big-government solutions for problems for decades. There's a reason the Tea Party respects GW Bush but does not defend his policies. GW Bush was almost a clone of Bill Clinton in his actual governance. (Of course I consider Bill Clinton post-1994 as a slightly left-of-center President and Bush as a slightly right-of-center, but on social policies, both were big government advocates).
Tom DeGisi
Cosmic, Did you read the linked article or just my stupid summary? I don't consider them stupid either. That's just me flaming. My summary was stupid because it completely threw you off. The article basically says we must stop the Republican establishment from picking the candidate, and talks about how. Key graf:
Defeating the moderates in 2012 will require two things. First, the disparate groups will have to settle on one candidate, and do so fast. Second, they will have to work together, united and coordinated, grooming activists at all levels including the Tea Party Youth, Tea Party Students and Tea Party Centenarians. Hey, pull out all the stops! Right?
And right now it looks like the best candidate to settle on fast is Sarah Palin. Mitch Daniels hasn't volunteered, and the other current candidates I know about are no good, although I don't know anything about Haley Barbour. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
I had actually already read it before you linked it Tom. I don't disagree but it implies a much larger element of coordination between these groups than exists today. I think Palin's plan is to beat the moderates from the inside so in 2012 the Republican Party IS the Tea Party. At least in all the key positions.
Tom DeGisi
Well, I think the article agrees with you in that way too. The Palin plan you describe actually sounds like the third sentence ing money graf I quoted above. It would be really bad if the establishment split the Tea Party or fooled some of the Tea Party people into supporting an establishment candidate. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Yeah, OK, I guess I can see how it could be interpreted your way too. I guess I was reading it as more being another confrontation between moderates and Tea Party folks in 2012. I might point out that one of my first posts on the Tea Party impact on the 2010 elections was that if the Tea Party won, that would lead to a civil war within the Republican Party. I think that war is underway.
ASEI
Hm, wrt my comments in your earlier post: Perhaps you are right. It would give me some hope to see Palin accumulate a base in spite of all the hate. I don't remember 1978, because I was -3 at the time. PS - was politics always this insane?
CosmicConservative
ASEI, I guess the short answer is "yes." I grew up in the late 60s and 70s. My memory of politics includes Vietnam, Watergate, the "legacy of Camelot," Jimmy Carter's "malaise" and the insanity of the Cold War. The GW Bush years were pretty bad, but they compared pretty well to the Reagan years. I still remember Reagan being accused by sitting Senators and Congressmen on the floor of the US House and Senate of wanting to start a nuclear war, of deliberately starving senior citizens and of trying to start an empire of his own for invading Grenada. The nation seems to remember the Reagan years fondly. I can tell you that being a Reagan supporter at a university was no more fun then than being a Bush supporter was three years ago. Reagan was HATED. When he left office the NY Times ran a story where they polled History Professors at major universities across the nation to rank all Presidents. Reagan came in dead last. He left on a down note too, due to the Iran-Contra affair, but the hatred from the Left was based primarily on his "aw shucks" cowboy image and his willingness to call the Soviet Union an "evil empire." Jimmy Carter was simply despised and pitied by the time Reagan kicked him out of the White House. Clinton's term was awash with right-wing stories about him murdering people in Arkansas, running a secret army of "black helicopters" and (my personal favorite) draping "chemtrails" across the skies of America to make the people more susceptible to government control. Yes, it's pretty much always been insane. You could go back to Jefferson vs. Madison to find similarly insane examples of politics.
Tom DeGisi
> You could go back to Jefferson vs. Madison to find similarly insane examples of politics. Try ancient Rome and Greece. It's part of the human condition. Yours, Tom