Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Why the Republican establishment fears Palin

By CosmicConservative
So, I think the conventional wisdom is that the Karl Rove/Peggy Noonan wing of the Republican Party (we can call them the "Beltway Country Club Wing" if you like) are afraid that if Sarah Palin runs in 2012 and wins the nomination, that will give the Democrats an easy victory in the general election. But more and more I think that's not quite right. I'm sure that is part of the driving force behind the constant effort by the BCCW of the party to discredit her and pressure her not to run. But I think they have a far greater fear that is truly driving most of their hatred and condescension. That fear is that Sarah Palin could WIN the general election. That terrifies them beyond words.

Comments (29)

Reggie Wooster
I wonder who the BCCW has lined up to run...who's "turn" is it this time? I would rather have Palin than another Dole or McCain
CosmicConservative
I still remember 2008 when Peggy Noonan went out of her way to lecture us mouth-breathing Walmart rednecks about how reasonable, centrist and thoughtful St. Barack was. Based on that she's probably hoping Russ Feingold makes a run at the Presidency.
ASEI
I'm not overly enthusiastic about Palin running. I don't know enough about what she would do with office. That, and I really do suspect she is unelectible. No fault of hers - but the level of hatred for her is extreme and almost universal outside of the conservative base. We really can't afford to lose another election if we want our country to remain recognizable. If she had difficulty handling that insane hatred when she was governor, how will she be prepared to do it as presidential candidate?
CosmicConservative
ASEI, Alaska has some rather ridiculous laws about how sitting governors have to fund their own defense against charges of ethics violations. As soon as the Democrats realized this they filed dozens of frivolous ethics charges against Palin with no intention of gaining convictions on any of them. The goal was to bankrupt the Palin family and tie Palin up in defending herself, or force her to resign. The strategy worked brilliantly. Not only did it force her out, but it led even a lot of Republicans to consider her a "quitter". At this moment Palin has every bit as much chance to win in 2012 as any other Republican potential candidate. Who do you think is better? Romney? Huckabee? Gingrich? All of them have equally high negatives to Palin. Maybe not in the polls, but in the general election. Romney and Huckabee will be the victim of vicious anti-religious attacks and accusations of being religious fanatics, Gingrich is a totally lost cause... McCain? Who is more electable than Palin?
JSullins
*I AM* Oh, sorry, you just left that baited hook and I had to bite :D
JSullins
Seriously though, I would prefer Palin to Romney, Huckabee, Gingrich. I detest Huckabee in fact, and Romney just seems too slick to me. And Gingrich, he's not seriously running is he?
CosmicConservative
IMHO Gingrich still maintains the delusion that he could be elected President. I keep hearing Republicans talk about how un-electable Palin is, but I have yet to hear anyone say "and [insert Republican name here] is totally electable!" It's completely an anti-Palin spin. It's not really about someone ELSE being more electable, it's just about dissing Sarah Palin. Mostly, IMHO it's so that the speaker can preen and pose about how enlightened and intelligent they are by bashing Palin. When someone comes up with a candidate who is clearly more electable than Palin, I might start listening to this anti-Palin drumbeat. Until then I'm with Sarah. If someone comes along who is conservative and more electable, I'll get on board. Until then Palin actually looks to me like the best chance the Republicans have right now.
Tom DeGisi
> Seriously though, I would prefer Palin to Romney, Huckabee, Gingrich. I detest Huckabee in fact, and Romney just seems too slick to me. Romney is too liberal. I will never forgive him Romneycare. Huckabee is too liberal and spends too much. Gingrich should have run for Governor somewhere first. Palin is the best of that lot. But Mitch Daniels and Tim Pawlenty look pretty good to me. OTOH no one has pointed out their negatives to me. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tim Pawlenty is a global warming alarmist who has expressed approval for crushing taxation on the coal and natural gas industries. He fails my smell test for two reasons. 1. He has fallen for the Global Warming alarmist hoax in spite of common sense, evidence of criminal corruption and competing scientific evidence showing that warming is happening but is much less than the alarmists claim, and that the consequences are not remotely dire enough to call for this sort of destruction of our energy sector. 2. He would propose or support any such centralized government solution to ANY problem, much less a made up one. As far as I know Mitch Daniels has only been elected to one government job and otherwise doesn't have executive experience. He may have some conservative credentials, but he's also proposed some bothersome tax increases. He might be a good candidate, but I don't see anything there that puts him head and shoulders above Palin and he's repeatedly claimed that he's not a candidate. One of the core considerations I would have in supporting a candidate is that they have expressed at least a possibility that they will run. Daniels has not, so far as I know, done that.
Tom DeGisi
> Tim Pawlenty is a global warming alarmist who has expressed approval for crushing taxation on the coal and natural gas industries. ... OK. Nix Pawlenty. > As far as I know Mitch Daniels has only been elected to one government job and otherwise doesn’t have executive experience. Elected twice. > He may have some conservative credentials, but he’s also proposed some bothersome tax increases. So have I. We have to get rid of the deficit and it is politically impossible to do so with spending cuts only. We are a center right country, not a right only country. > He might be a good candidate, but I don’t see anything there that puts him head and shoulders above Palin He balanced a difficult budget in a purple state. > and he’s repeatedly claimed that he’s not a candidate. One of the core considerations I would have in supporting a candidate is that they have expressed at least a possibility that they will run. Daniels has not, so far as I know, done that. OK. Give him time. Our biggest need is to stop the Republican establishment at all costs - which may mean a candidate that sucks away some of their support - or it may mean a candidate more like Reagan or Palin. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
I could potentially get behind Mitch Daniels. But first he has to run. I haven't seen enough of him personally to know if he's got the charisma he'd need to beat Obama. Maybe he does.
Tom DeGisi
> But first he has to run. Yes. > I haven’t seen enough of him personally to know if he’s got the charisma he’d need to beat Obama. He's very short and I'm not sure he has charisma. But the anti-Obama might be just the ticket to beat the always tall, occaisional all charisma always no substance Obama. What do you think of Fred Thompson or Haley Barbour? Yours, Tom
ASEI
Well, you have a point there. All the other choices are worse. And I really have nothing against Palin personally. However, in the weird social bubble reality that most American's live in, Palin has been predefined by her enemies. I've never seen anyone successfully get out from under that sort of mark in the public conciousness once they have been singled out. I wish the Republicans would cough up something other than a least bad candidate someday.
ASEI
PS - not Huckabee. I read one of his rants against "soulless capitalism". That's exactly what we don't need right now, when we are on the doorstep of a complete government takeover of American life.
CosmicConservative
ASEI, I did a whole post on how Reagan "got out from under that mark in the public consciousness once they had been singled out." I will repeat the essence of it here. I was very active in politics in 1978 and 1980, and I watched Reagan get cast in ways that are virtually identical to how Sarah Palin has been cast now. Reagan was routinely portrayed as too dumb to read a teleprompter, led around by Nancy on a string and shuffled off to long naps so that his handlers could do all the real work of campaigning. This went well into his first term in fact. I still remember Garry Trudeau publishing a book of Doonesbury cartoons called "In Search of Reagan's Brain". Reagan overcame it. Palin can too.
Tom DeGisi
I might backtrack on tax increase. It seems they don't decrease the deficit. Maybe we need a constitutional amendment that says whenever spending goes over 20% of GDP, you can increase taxes by 1% every time you cut spending from the previous budget by 1%. I'm playing with incentives here. Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Tom, one of the reasons I've never been a fan of tax increases to balance the budget is that every study I've ever seen shows that tax increases lead to more spending, not less.
Tom DeGisi
Cosmic, That's what the article says, but that's not sustainable over time. There must be some kind of corrective action. It could be default. It could be revolt. It could be collapse. Are there any historical examples of corrective action which aren't catastrophic? Yours, Tom
CosmicConservative
Well, I'd like to put the Reagan or Bush tax cuts in that category, but the truth is that we didn't cut spending then either. So I dunno. One of the things that worries me about the future is that all the history of the past compels me to the conclusion that our nation is in irreversible decline.
Tom DeGisi
If that's true it's time to start a new one, Aeneas. Yours, Tom
Drax
There is not a single person in the Republican party who energizes the base. Except Palin. There is not a single person in the Republican party who can deliver a speech which articulates Conservative principles while, at the same time, mesmerizing the audience. Except Palin. There is not a single person in the Republican party who is able to inject humor and style into barbs as did Reagan. Except Palin. There is not a single person in the Republican party who is able to utilize new media to drive public opinion. Except Palin. Palin has it all. Unfortunately, she also has the highest negatives among Independents and Democrats (but the highest positives among Republicans). If she uses the next year (she has a new book coming out) to push back on those negatives and raise her positives, she can win. (Although, right now, if the choice were presented, I would take a Palin/Rubio or Rubio/Palin ticket.)
Tom DeGisi
Drax, Dunno about all that. For example, Christ Christie, "is able to inject humor and style into barbs as did Reagan". He also energizies this member of the base, and I don't think I'm the only one. I'm pretty sure I wouldn't vote for Christie in a primary over Palin - I can't remember the issue I strongly disagree with him on. Perhaps Palin is the only one who does all those things. If so the Republican stable of candidates is pretty low quality. I don't think that has been shown. I have too many people whom I respect who say otherwise. The only one I can sort of name is one of the Power Line guys - not sure which one. Since I respect you as well, would you care to show your work? It could all be intuition on your part. Is it? I respect intuition. It's really fast thinking where you aren't sure what the details really are. The Power Line guys seem to like Pawlenty. I know he buys the Global Warming bit, which does nix him for me, but that does not contradict any of your points. After all, preserving the globe from catastrophe is a conservative value, which is why I was willing to listen to the Global Warming Alarmists before it became apparent to me that they were only Alarmists. I truly believe there are people of good will and good sense who agree with the Alarmists. In fact I believe nearly all Alarmists are people of good will and good sense. They just wildly over estimate the efficacy of the science they do / believe in. This is really easy for a hard working scientist to do, having swung that hammer at those nails all his working life. Too much doubt would be really debilitating for a working scientist. That is trivially true for some values of 'too much'. Whether it is true for any practical values of 'too much' is certainly an open question. I'm going with my own intuition here. Sorry for all the memory based failures in this comment. Maybe you can relate. Yours, Tom
Drax
Not sure what you mean by "show your work." I watched Palin from her selection as VP candidate to date. She draws more people than anyone else. She is able to shape national debate with a face book posting. Is there someone else who "energizes the base" to the extent and the depth that Palin does? As to my other assertions, they appeared to me to be self-evident. (Anyone else moving the national meter with facebook postings? Any one of the nominal candidates ever given a rousing speech even in the same ballpark as Palin's? Don't see it.) Christie? Um.... He has some good points, but... He ain't a conservative. And, he doesn't engage the other side with a smile as does Palin (or Reagan) he attempts to eviscerate them -- and, as much as possible -- does so with cameras rolling. I'm not sure that I've seen any "humor" out of him. Every other one of the potential candidates (with the exception of Huck) are STIFFS. None of them have an ounce of charisma. Every one of them have some issues with the base. (Romneycare, Newt and his affair(s) - his loss of the House; Huck his overspending and his evangelical roots; whatever. The only one on the horizon who has the sheer charisma of Palin and the potential to engage (and widen) the base, to me, appears to be Rubio.
CosmicConservative
There are rumblings from Florida about a Jeb revival... Jeb Bush/Marco Rubio?
Drax
Of all the Bushes, I like Jeb the best. But, he's a Bush. We've had enough of them already. Rubio/Palin. Palin/Rubio. I'm easy.
CosmicConservative
I just don't understand the "I'm tired of the name Bush" attitude. If Jeb is the best candidate, I'll support him. I'm not going to vote for a lesser candidate just because he happens to be the brother of one President and the son of another. I particularly find the statement laughable coming from liberals who worshipped at the sacred altar of "Camelot" for 50 years and who repeatedly elected an incompetent manslaughtering sexual predator to the US Senate based strictly on his last name alone.
Drax
Bush = Baggage Every evil thing Bush did will be attributed to ... Bush. (Of course, Bush went to war to avenge the assassination attempt on ... Bush.) Rubio is "Hispanic" (whatever the hell THAT is). Palin is a woman. Either way, it would be a first with the potential to widen the base by attracting new voters to the Republican party. (AKA "stealing from the Demorats") Both together? Hmmmm... Enough to make up for the idiots who watch the LSM and would not vote for Palin simply because Stewart told them she was an idiot? Dunno. But they would get the BASE invigorated which should translate into a huge turnout -- resulting in even more gains in the House and Senate. But...My crystal ball looking hasn't been that great lately....
CosmicConservative
LOL, well, my crystal ball looking has been pretty good, for whatever that's worth... Rubio is intriguing, but he's still mostly untested. I could get into a Rubio/Palin or Palin/Rubio ticket. I also think Christie is able to use humor very well but he definitely has a sharp edge to it. I personally like that though. ;)