Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

How the Electric Car Lobby spins the data

By CosmicConservative

So this weekend I did some catching up on the state of electric car technology due to all the hoopla over the Chevy Volt. In doing so I noticed a few assumptions about electric cars that are blatantly untrue in some cases and are cynical spinning of the facts in others.

The first thing that leaped out at me was the near universal comparison of electric cars to gas cars which get 25mpg. On the surface this appears to be reasonable because that's about the average gas mileage of a new car these days. But that presupposes that people buying an electric car would have purchased a gas car of that mileage when every study done shows that electric car buyers disproportionately purchase higher mpg cars. In other words, the Chevy Volt competes directly with the Mini Cooper and the Toyota Prius, not the Ford F100 pickup truck. To be more realistic, the mpg value electric should be compared to is more like 35mpg than 25 mpg. Using those more realistic numbers the supposed CO2 advantage pretty much disappears entirely.

The next assumption is that the cost of electricity won't rise when the demand caused by electric cars hits the grid. In fact the comparisons typically use laughable government goals which somehow defy the laws of physics in projecting energy costs declining to about 20% of current values. To call these projections "optimistic" is a serious understatement.

The next assumption is that electric cars will pull their power according to the overall energy production distribution that exists today. That means for countries like Canada or France which have a high % of power generated from nuclear or hydro, the CO2 output is much less than in a country like the USA which uses coal and natural gas for the bulk of energy demand. What this sort of analysis overlooks is that electric car recharging is a net new power request and even in countries like France and Canada, additional demand is usually met with coal or natural gas. Especially in America where hydro and nuclear have been stalled indefinitely by the wacko environmentalist lobby. In other words all of that additional demand is likely to be met by burning more coal and natural gas.

Finally, none of the analyses I saw factored in the cost and environmental impact of the battery pack production, yet all of them factored in the cost of refining and transporting gasoline. Even with all these assumptions electric cars are barely beating gas cars on CO2 and energy costs. If the comparisons were honest the outlook for electric would be quite a bit less rosy. And that's not even looking at how much work has to be done on the grid infrastructure to support a couple million cars sucking up electricity like sponges all night long...

Comments (17)

CosmicConservative
Wow, entering on my droid loses all paragraph formatting... sorry folks.
CosmicConservative
I manually entered some paragraph tags....
Neil
I'm a conservative, and I just want you to know that what you just wrote is an embarrassment. The ICE is a highly inefficient method of propulsion. The reasons we still put up with it are consumer laziness and self-preservation on the part of the oil companies, who have systematically stymied development of alternatives. This is the 21st century! Why are we stuck with a system that can run out of fuel while standing still?? With an EV, you can choose where your electricity comes from. With an ICE, you are guaranteed to be sucking on BP's teats for the life of the vehicle. Rational Conservatism? I can't believe that American conservatism is this short sighted.
CosmicConservative
Neil, I'm not embarrassed by it, in spite of your comments. I stand by every word. Just because I point out the excessive hype and truth-stretching of the current electric vehicle lobby doesn't mean I'm a pawn of the oil industry. Let's look at your comments to see how "embarrassing" they might be. "You can choose where your electricity comes from." Oh really? How? Do you have some switch on your wall that says "Solar/Coal/Natural Gas/Hydro/Wind"? I thought not. You get what power the electric companies deliver to you. If you are suggesting that with electric you can get the sort of power society chooses, well then, in this country, thanks to the irrational fears of the environmental wacko lobby, that choice has been made, it's pretty much "coal/natural gas". As I said in my original post. If this country wants to make an investment in sustainable, scalable alternate energy sources, I'm all for that, but up until now the choices that exist are pretty much coal or natural gas. And since the supposed "crisis" that electric cars are supposedly trying to "fix" is the generation of CO2, those choices pretty much mean that CO2 will continue to be spewed out to run our cars in perpetuity. If you are one of those who believes that we are on the verge of running out of oil, I don't agree with you. Sure there is a finite amount of oil in the crust, but the hype about it running out next week is just that, hype. We've just barely begun to explore the vast majority of the earth's surface for oil. And so far everywhere we look, we find loads of oil. Just last week an announcement was made of massive oil reserves found in the northern Atlantic near Iceland. Iceland, being a rational society in some ways, immediately started plans to drill, baby drill. Antarctica hasn't even been touched, neither has the vast majority of the deep ocean. The ICE is currently cost and efficiency competitive with electric, particularly in terms of range and refueling convenience which is the big, big, BIG problem with electric. And this doesn't even begin to address the problems of our electrical grid infrastructure which simply can't support replacing our ICE vehicles with electric. To believe otherwise is simply ignorant or naive. Another wrinkle in this is the continued improvements in ICE efficiency. There are several very promising technological improvements to the ICE in progress right now which will improve efficiency into the future just as it has been improved in the past. I'm quite comfortable in how rational my conservatism is Neil. You're going to have to do a lot better than that to convince me otherwise. One more thing. I don't have any problem with replacing the ICE. I have repeatedly on this blog predicted that it will get replaced. It will get replaced when there is something more effective, efficient, cost-effective and maintainable. The electric car isn't remotely close to being there yet. Not by a light year.
Kevin in WI
Neil, An ICE is less inefficient than electric when you look at the whole picture. All types of locomotion come from converting chemical to mechanical energy. In the case of an ICE car, 25-30% of the energy in the fuel (oil) gets converted into mechanical energy at the crankshaft, and about 90% of that gets to the wheels. In an "electric" car, about 30% of the energy in the fuel at the central power plant (mostly coal or uranium) makes it to the car, of which about 85% gets to the wheels via the storage batteries. The result is that "electric" cars are little different from old fashioned ICE powered cars in terms of system efficiency. I sincerely wish it weren't so, but Cosmic is correct. The only thing battery electric vehicles can reduce is total CO2 released into the atmosphere, but only if using electricity produced using low or no carbon fuels (nuclear or high efficiency combined cycle natural gas). Whether that's important of course, is debatable.
Kevin in WI
I meant NOT less efficient than electric. Dang iPad keyboard!
CosmicConservative
Kevin and Neal, in some countries there is a net reduction of carbon released into the atmosphere because they have the political will and common sense to build dams and nuclear power plants. Here in the good ol' USA that's not gonna happen for a while thanks to the lawsuits and protests of ignorant atavistic morons who haven't got the sense god gave a rutabaga. Here in the USA virtually all of the additional demand electric vehicles put on the grid will be met with coal and natural gas. Anyone who thinks wind and solar is going to contribute more than a token drop in the energy bucket is simply ignorant or a fool. Oh, and one more thing, that additional demand will only be met up until our grid infrastructure starts to literally burn itself out since the current grid is ENGINEERED to require evening cool down periods for the massive ultra high voltage transformers to not melt their innards and short out. And those transformers aren't cheap, and more to the point, the USA doesn't build them anymore because unions priced their labor right out of the market. Those are now built in China, India and other places. To even purchase one today requires several months of lead time and estimates are that it could take years to upgrade even a portion of the grid to support the demand needed by millions of people plugging their cars in and sucking down peak electric loads 24x7. Electric isn't gonna do it Neal. Not by a long shot. Not for a long time. ICE will be here for 10 years at least, maybe 20, barring some MAJOR technological breakthrough, like, say, nuclear fusion coming online next week. Eventually the ICE will be replaced, but again, that's not going to happen just because people think it SHOULD happen. It will happen when economic realities are met.
Reggie Wooster
when someone offers an electric car that I can charge and drive all week without recharging, will go 75 MPH on the freeway, and not look like a flawed art project I might consider one. Oh and not cost as much as a Porsche
ASEI
I keep advocating some sort of nuclear beta-voltaic battery - that way you get 90 years worth of fuel. I suppose even that has the power density problem to overcome, but it is at least a new approach. In terms of chemical storage of energy, you can't do much better than hydrocarbons. (Well you can, but stuff like flouride reactions are toxic) There was some sort of metal-water-hydrogen evolving reaction that was interesting. Powdered aluminum + water + electricity -> Aluminum oxides + hydrogen. But then you'd have to drop off the whole tank of alumina and water and swap it, because local reprocessing wouldn't be possible. In any case, what our society needs is a decent nuclear prime mover - then we will have energy resources on an order that we can play with chemistry to our hearts content.
ASEI
PS - I'm with Bill gates on the thorium breeder reactors - that would give us essentially unlimited energy. (Not actually unlimited - I suppose if we really splurge, we could run out of thorium in a few thousand years).
Keith
I could care less about the supposed issues of CO2. I care a great deal more about energy independence and the use of domestic energy sources for transportation. Electric vehicles allow this by making coal, gas and nuclear, viable alternatives to oil, a large portion of which we must today import. I have no problem with gas engines, and I think the efficiencies being thrown out in this thread for ICE vs. Electric are approximately correct. There's not a huge difference between the two. But then, to me, it's not about efficiency. It's about promoting competition amongst energy sources and energy independence from foreign sources. EVs are also simpler by design with fewer moving parts. I certainly expect the green movement to oversell the potential of EVs, but it makes good economic sense to support them. That said, I'll not be buying a Volt or any other GM product as I have no intention of supporting an organization which stiffed its lenders and shareholders in favor of the very unions that are in large part responsible for the company's demise.
CosmicConservative
I've blogged on thorium nuclear reactors before. I'm a big fan. The only reason the USA went for the less efficient option of uranium back in the 50s was because of the need to generate materials needed for nuclear weapons.
CosmicConservative
I've got no ideological "favorite" in this deal. What I have are practical demands and recognition of reality. A vehicle with a range of 60 miles which then requires hours to recharge is simply impractical to me and the vast majority of Americans who can't afford to own two cars, one that meets their actual needs and one that makes an ideological statement. Until something appears on the market with the range, power and convenience of fossil fuels, fossil fuels will continue to rule the highwyays. That's the simple, practical reality of the matter. Everything else is just a bunch of talk.
Kevin in WI
Keith, We don't need electric cars to use domestic energy resources. CNG and fisher-tropsh method created diesel (from coal) used in cars with high efficiency internal combustion engines and we'll be free of imported oil in less than a generation.
CosmicConservative
... or we could just, you know, drill our own...