Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: Secretariat

By CosmicConservative
I remember Secretariat, of course. Who above the age of 10 in 1973 could ever forget the summer of the "Super Horse"? Secretariat didn't just win the horse racing "triple crown" the big red horse set a new official Kentucky Derby record, a new unofficial record (more later) at the Preakness and in setting a new record at the Belmont Stakes, delivered a demolishing performance against the field (winning by 31 lengths!) that was so astonishing that a survey of sports editors ranked Secretariat's Belmont Stakes performance as the second most amazing individual athletic performance in history, behind only Wilt Chamberlain's 100 point NBA game. Frankly, I would put Secretariat's destruction of the best horses in the nation ahead of Wilt's "everyone feed Wilt the ball because he's six inches taller than his opponent" game. I remember the sheer jaw-dropping astonishment of that Belmont Stakes victory, a victory that turned the triple crown watch into a royal coronation. But this post isn't about Secretariat, it's supposed to be about the movie. The hero of the movie is not the horse, but the horse's owner, one Penny (Chenery) Tweedy. Penny is the daughter of a horse breeding/racing family who has become the mother and housewife of a Denver attorney. When her mother passes away leaving the horse raising business in the hands of a father portrayed as in the early stages of Alzheimer's Disease, Penny has to intervene to avoid the total ruination of the stables. The business is in shambles, and their horse trainer is apparently a shady character attempting to bleed off the remaining value under the nose of the near-comatose father. The first action Penny takes as her father's replacement is to fire the long-time trainer and hire a new one. Penny decides to take the reins of the business (neat pun, eh?) at least long enough to restore it to a salable condition to avoid financial ruin. As this is playing out, one of her father's last (literal) gambles results in the birth of a gangly red foal that is simply called "Big Red" as it grows into a powerful, if lazy and gluttonous, racehorse. This, of course, is the horse that will one day be named "Secretariat" and will provide the financial windfall necessary to save the farm, save Penny's marriage and show Penny's children the value of determination and hard work. There's not much to spoil here since the end of the story is commonly known history. Penny arranges a revolutionary syndication of Secretariat's breeding rights to raise the six million dollars needed to save the farm after her father passes away, leaving the farm victim to exorbitant estate taxes. (Yeah, a Hollywood movie shows how an entire multi-million dollar business can be totally destroyed by estate taxes right at a time when Congress is supposed to be debating the restoration of such taxes.) To entice the syndicate investors Penny essentially had to guarantee a triple crown so that the breeding rights would be worth what the syndicate paid, so most of the movie's drama and suspense comes from the lead up to each race as Secretariat has to overcome a series of difficulties to be at his best for the key races. One loss and Penny's guarantee would be void and her family would be financially ruined. The high points of the movie are mostly the scenes of the races themselves. The camera work on the running horses is pretty spectacular. The sound editing for those scenes is also academy award worthy, giving a real visceral feel for the races and the horses. The interpersonal scenes of Penny's family, both her immediate family and her brother, are surprisingly understated, allowing the audience to project into the scenes the level of angst, anger and betrayal that they feel. There is very little overt emotional heartstring pulling, except in a few scenes between Penny and her oldest daughter. I recommend it, especially as a heartwarming family movie, or even a date-night movie. Chicks will probably love it. Now, about the movie itself. I was surprised after reading up on Penny Chenery how much the movie misrepresented the facts that were really central to the movie's plot and theme. It was not actually Secretariat who "saved" the horse breeding business. In fact Secretariat had a one-year older stable mate named "Riva Ridge" a reference to Penny's husband who served in the army in WW2 and participated in a critical battle of the same name. Riva Ridge won the Kentucky Derby and the Belmont Stakes and was favored to win the Preakness but a rain-soaked muddy track led to his being upset. The money and stud fees Riva Ridge gained were the real financial windfall that saved Meadow Stables, Penny's father's business. Also Penny's father was afflicted with kidney disease and spent several years in the hospital, dying just before Secretariat's Super Summer. I find no indication in the news reports and stories I find on the internet that her father suffered from Alzheimers or any other form of dementia. He was bedridden for the final five years of his life though. The movie in effect blended the two horses' careers and financial impact into one, giving Secretariat full credit for what Riva Ridge and Secretariat accomplished together. I find that sort of sad, actually. Riva Ridge deserved better. Riva is also in the horseracing Hall of Fame, so it's not as if Secretariat was the only superstar from Meadow Stables. Oh, about that Preakness "record." There were three separate times recorded for Secretariat's run, with two "unofficial" timekeepers each individually recording a time of 1:53 2/5, the track clock recording 1:54 flat, and the track's official manual time-keeper recording 1:54 2/5. Neither of the 1:54 readings would have been a new record, but the 1:53 2/5 would be the record still today. After a drawn out dispute where television replays of the then-record and Secretariat's run were compared side by side using the film as the timekeeper (a perfectly reasonable approach since movie film requires highly accurate synchronization of the frames to match the audio, and the synchronized video results showed Secretariat crossing 2/3 length ahead of the record-holder) but the Preakness officials instead accepted the disputed manual time kept by their official timekeeper, thus denying Secretariat the distinction of holding all three triple crown records for 37 years now....

Comments (4)

Cosmic Daughter
Wow! I knew Hollywood loved to Twist history but that's ridiculous. I still like the movie, but it's irritating that my generation will probably believe the events in the movie to be true because it is based on a true story. They should have said "Loosely based on a true story" or "Barely based on a true story" Still, I liked seeing Secretariat run they way he actually did in history.
CosmicConservative
Well, to give them as much credit as possible, they did present Secretariat's races pretty factually. They just wanted to heighten the suspense and tension by making it seem that Secretariat was the only hope of saving the stables, and that's, unfortunately, just not the case. Still, I enjoyed the movie.
Dadman
Reality is always more complex than what is depicted in both history books and, of course, movies. For example, did you know Frodo had a domineering older brother who tragically died in a fireworks accident? It is speculated Frodo took on the suicidal quest to destroy the One Ring to prove his worth to his late older brother. None of this is referenced in either the books or the films and is known only through the personal journals of Sam Gamgee... ;)
CosmicConservative
Poor Frodo, his parents die in a boating accident, and now I learn his older brother was a victim of Gandalf's sweatshop, hobbit-labor fireworks factory. Well, the truth is sometimes hard to hear... That does explain the crafty old wizard's interest in Hobbiton for all those years... He clearly coveted those nimble hobbit-fingers packing his fireworks. No wonder he was known as the "fireworks robber baron" throughout middle-earth...