Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Been expecting this news for a while now...

By CosmicConservative
WASHINGTON (AFP) – US astronomers said Wednesday they have discovered an Earth-sized planet that they think might be habitable, orbiting a nearby star, and believe there could be many more planets like it in space. The planet, found by astronomers at the University of California, Santa Cruz, and the Carnegie Institution of Washington, is orbiting in the middle of the "habitable zone" of the red dwarf star Gliese 581, which means it could have water on its surface. via US scientists find potentially habitable planet near Earth - Yahoo! News.
Of course "habitable" here only means that it's within the "goldilocks zone" of the star. Yes, that's an actual scientific term to describe the orbit around a star that is "not too cold, not too hot, but just right" for water to be in liquid form on the surface. One of my biggest criticisms of the "SETI" effort is how completely random it has been. I have said all along that the search should focus almost entirely on close, stable stars because those are the aliens we're most likely to either develop trade with, or go to war with, and frankly I'd rather know that sooner rather than later. Still, good news and yet another indication of the likely commonality of "goldilocks zone" planets in the galaxy. If we found one this close to earth, that makes it highly plausible that there are literally millions of them in the galaxy.

Comments (3)

ASEI
One of the main problems with SETI proper is that it is looking for signals that aren't likely to be there. From the standpoint of building an interstellar transmitter, you would have to ensure the signal was highly directional if you wanted any detectable signal strength at your target star system. This means, first of all, that we won't be intercepting anything that isn't pointed specifically at us. (The consequences of an omni-directional signal source detectable lightyears away is that the transmitter would be absolutely lethal anywhere near the source - terrawatts of energy would have to be poured into it) Second, it means that any transmission would have to be highly collimatable. With the relationship between wavelength, apeture, and collimation, this means that interstellar communication probably isn't going to be happening in the radio at all. Optical wavelengths are far more likely. I think we would do far better with something like terrestrial planet finder looking for other planets. Too bad that was cancelled - it would be great to have actual light from the planets we are just getting bare hints of now.
ASEI
PS I was pretty sure there was something about this in the news 2 years ago. I don't see anything new about the Gliese 581 planet.
CosmicConservative
There was indeed a news release a few years ago about a habitable planet in the Gliese system. However, it was shortly thereafter refined to suggest that the planet was slightly too far out for liquid water, and so was removed from the "potentially habitable" list. This is a new planet that is calculated to orbit right in the center of the "goldilocks" zone. This sort of obscures the scientifically important discovery of a multiple planet system with nearly circular orbits. I think this is the fifth or sixth planet with such orbits around this one star. This dramatically increases the odds of there being a lot of stars with planetary systems in nearly circular orbits just like our solar system. That's an important discovery in itself.