Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Let's play "Spot the logical fallacies"...

By CosmicConservative
According to this story "science has proven" that men choose casual hookups by body shape and long term partners by facial characteristics. You'll have to read the whole thing to speculate on whether "science" has "proven" anything.
Participants were asked to look at an image and decide whether they would consider this person for a one-night stand or a marriage partner, but the image was covered by two boxes. In order to make their decisions, they were allowed to uncover only one box; either the face or the body. The research determined that most men opted to see the body in cases when the mate was to be considered for short-term relationships, but when considering potential marriage partners, the box was removed from the face. via Science says men like shapely ladies | The Daily Texan.
What, if anything, do you think is flawed about this study, the analysis or the conclusions?

Comments (5)

Dadman
One of the things I enjoyed most about grad school was a course dedicated to the critical analysis of published 'scientific' studies. One limitation that leaps to mind in this case is the conditions simply do not match reality in any perceivable way. Men just don't assess women as disembodied heads/faces or vice versa. Additionally, men consider other variables beyond faces and bodies when choosing both short term and long term relationship partners. I didn't read the full article so there is likely much more to criticize...
CosmicConservative
Dadman, that is my take as well. I have other issues with this "study" but the absolutely bizarre and arbitrary conditions which bear no relationship whatsoever with reality is by far the biggest problem with this study.
Dadman
I've become very disillusioned with 'science' the past few years. My expectation is that science be dispassionate and objective when all too often it designed to serve some kind of political agenda. And all too often it is flawed due to faulty assumptions and methods.
CosmicConservative
Well, most of this human behavioral psychology stuff is pure unadulterated crap anyway. Most of it seems designed to promote a particularly ideology or else seems designed to "prove" a wacky theory about people. Another study just released "proves" that men don't notice a woman's shoes when she walks by. Um... duh?
Tom DeGisi
> Another study just released “proves” that men don’t notice a woman’s shoes when she walks by. That depends on the man, the woman and the shoes. Yours, Tom