Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The virtual "drug" economy?

By CosmicConservative
The company behind Mafia Wars and Farmville doesn't like to talk about the sad addicts who fuel its profits. But it does quietly run a special store for them, where imaginary credits are bought with very real bank transfers. via The Secret Dealer for Farmville Addicts.
The article is about how Zynga, the company that produces Farmville, Frontierville, Mafia Wars and all those other annoying Facebook games has a near-secret store where you can exchange real dollars for virtual products or cash. The minimum purchase at this store is $500. Yes, you read that right. $500. And it only accepts direct bank-to-bank wire transfers. No credit cards, no PayPal... just direct bank-to-bank wire transfers. The author of this article, and the bulk of the commenters hammer the "drug addiction" meme. Of course the discussion ranges over a whole host of "virtual" products or services that people pay real money for, ranging from online games like World of Warcraft to watching a movie. As any regular reader here knows, I play World of Warcraft, and I played Everquest when it first came out. Long before either of those existed, I played (and still play) Dungeons and Dragons which is a paper and pencil game that is based around imaginary characters adventuring in imaginary worlds and gaining imaginary loot. I pay something like $150 a year for my WoW subscription. I probably play the game about ten hours a week, so easily 500 hours per year. I don't watch TV, and I'm sure most "normal" folks spend a lot more than ten hours watching TV. So I don't feel like my time is any less productive than most other folks. And I enjoy the game, and that's what I pay for. When you boil it down to the bottom line, I'm paying a bit less than thirty cents per hour for my entertainment. Throw in the original cost of the game and the two expansion sets, and that probably brings the cost up to a bit more than thirty cents per hour. A typical 2 hour movie is more than ten times that expensive. A round of golf is more than twenty times that expensive, and that's not counting clubs, bag, balls, tees, etc... I've said before on this blog that I try not to be judgmental about how people spend their time. I've endured more than enough scorn and ridicule for playing D&D. In fact WoW is probably much more socially acceptable than D&D, even though the cost of D&D is probably only pennies per hour overall. Heck, the cost of the gas I spend to go play D&D is probably orders of magnitude more than the money I've spent on the game itself. And let's not even start on fishing or my telescope hobbby.... In the end I guess if people can afford it and it gives them enjoyment that is worth the money to them, who am I to judge? But $500 minimum purchase fee for online Farmville junk? Seriously?

Comments (6)

Foobarista
Since I have a Mafia Wars session running on the next browser tab, I'm one of the "guilty", although I never actually spent money on the game. My impression is that people who spend money on FB games tend to play the least.
CosmicConservative
In the case of most online MMORPGs like WoW or Everquest, the game publishers generally make purchasing in game items, including full-blown characters, a terms of service violation and they will cancel an account if they feel the abuse is beyond their tolerable threshold. However they now have an "online store" where they sell, for real money, a wide variety of items that are not supposed to impact game play, things like special mounts or pets for example. In the case of WoW at least, you still can't buy your way to the elite level of game play without violating the terms of service, but there are a lot of elite and non-elite WoW players who have purchased several of the in game items that cost real money. This is, once again, a benefit of my general disinterest in social status. I really don't care if someone has a "celestial mount" or if they've got the latest pet gerbil or something. I just want to play the game.
CosmicConservative
In World of Warcraft there are people who play it a lot more than I do. Several of my guild members have six or more level 80 raid-capable "toons" (what you call your characters). They have every "achievement", have done every quest and have completed every raid. They do every special event (the current one is called "Gnomeregon" and you are helping the gnome king regain the kingdom he lost to his evil gnome enemy years ago). The reward for completing the "Gnomeregon" quest is that you can change into a gnome for a short time once every four hours. For some reason these silly things are desperately sought after by those sorts of players. When the "ooze" pet came out, everyone had to have one. (Oozes are seriously disgusting animated slime puddles.) Anything that is hard to get is especially desirable. It's not even about whether it's the coolest looking thing, it just has to be different. So, yes, a pet gerbil would be very desirable in WoW. As would a pet cockroach (I am pretty sure you can get a pet cockroach). As I said, I generally don't do those things. For some reason I got suckered into doing the Gnomeregon quest so I can turn into a sort of gnome in a spacesuit now. Believe it or not, such things can sometimes be useful in PvP. Turning into a gnome, and then using a "nogginfogger" elixer I can shrink Rhlyssa down to the size of a beer can, since most top level gamers select their opponents with their mouse or game input device, that can give you an advantage in a big battle such as you have in Wintergrasp. Plus it's sorta cool sometimes to be as tiny as a mouse....
Andy
Cosmic, this is an interesting thought piece. When Pam and I were a young couple, I can not imagine how many dollars we spent going to movies, dinners "out," bowling, putt-putt, etc. Golf, fishing, hunting (especially hunting), and other things are expensive and time consuming. Not to mention the hundreds of hours we spent with other young couples playing Canasta, or spades, etc. When video games came along, we began to spend real dollars on Frogger, Lode runner, etc. And, many, many hours of time playing. I'll admit that I've been a tad judgmental about adults that play Farmville, or the other virtual stuff. But, I spend my free time as I like, so why should I be? I shouldn't. Some guy likes to sit and listen to Opera for hours on end, while reading a classic. Some guy likes to play WOW. Cool. Good piece, Cosmic.
CosmicConservative
Andy, when it comes to entertainment, I have always been very loathe to judge. This goes back to my being criticized roundly for my interest in comic books, an interest that I continued well into my period of reading the Iliad, the Odyssey, Mark Twain, Herman Hesse, etc. Even as I was developing my interest in deep philosophical study, with writers such as Kant, Thoreau, Emerson, J. Stuart Mill, etc., I was also devouring literal stacks of science fiction and even developed an insatiable interest in Louis L'Amour and Zane Grey. Many of the very same people who would sneer at my "Daybreakers" novel would not have had the slightest interest in reading "Atlas Shrugged" or "The Glass Bead Game" or any of the other books I read for "serious" reading. Let's not even talk about the reaction I might get for reading a Spiderman comic book. Back in the 80s, playing D&D was enough to make a person a social pariah. Reading Robert E. Howard or Michael Moorcock was enough to make you a likely sociopath... Reading "Catcher in the Rye" was enough to get you suspended from school... Anyway, people do stuff for personal enjoyment, and my general attitude is "if it doesn't hurt anyone, what's the big deal?" One of my coworkers is a "LARPer". I wonder if most of my readers even know what a "LARPer" is? "LARP" is "Live Action Role Playing." These are people who dress up as imaginary characters and act out spontaneous activities along with dozens or hundreds of others with the same interest. It's sort of like dress-up dungeons and dragons. I know one guy who spent $3,000 on a sword for his LARP getup. Yes, $3,000 on a SWORD. People do all sorts of crazy things for fun. And they spend way too much money on all of them. Of all my hobbies, the one that probably costs me the most money overall has been my stargazing. And that one is probably the one that most people would consider a socially desirable hobby, especially when compared to gaming. I've spent easily $7,000 on telescopes, eyepieces, mounts and other accessories. And the time you can stargaze is quite limited. If any of my hobbies deserve true criticism for the negative impact they've had on my life, stargazing is probably at the top of the list. Spending too much money, staying up too late, being off on my own when the family is in bed... I've driven 50 miles just to get to a dark site and stayed out until 5:00 am and then slep until noon or later the next day, just to see Mars at its best, or a comet. When I play WoW, I'm home, I go to bed more or less on time and I spend virtually nothing compared to my other hobbies...