Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

High School Yearbook comments...

By CosmicConservative
So while performing some sort of archeological dig in our closet yesterday, the Cosmic Wife uncovered our long-lost high school yearbooks. (Yes, the Cosmic Wife and I attended the same high school, although she was a lowly freshwoman when I was a high and mighty senior. As a result we have six years of consecutive yearbooks.) So there were a couple of things I wanted to check out, mostly looking up some photos of folks I had some recent interest in, but as these things happen, I happened to come across some schoolmates' comments and ended up reading every comment in my senior yearbook. I don't remember having done that since a few years after graduation. Let's just say that reading those comments was an education in itself. Here are some fictionalized reproductions of some of the comments. These aren't actual comments but they are reasonably accurate compilations/reproductions of actual comments. From a male classmate, not in my social group, but who was in several classes over the years:
Well, I waited all year for [teacher name here] to smack you or expel you, and I guess it will never happen now. You are one strange dude. Even if you hated the football team, I guess you're OK.
From a female classmate, not in my social group, but who was in several classes over the years:
I can honestly say I'll never forget you. You sure made [random class name] fun. I've never met anyone like you before (and I'm not sure I ever want to meet another one in the future - just kidding!).
From a male classmate, in my social group:
What can I say about you that hasn't already been scrawled in here? Yeah, you're strange, you're weird and you're going to get yourself in a lot of trouble one day with your mouth, but it has been mostly fun knowing you.
From a female classmate, in my social group:
I've never met a more unique person. I'm not sure if that's good or bad, but it's been interesting for sure! I really enjoyed the long conversations and how you listened to my problems. You sure have some interesting ideas about the world. You've got to quit being so hard on yourself. Don't forget me when you go to college, be sure to write!
And finally, from one of the many females I was totally smitten by, but with whom I at most shared nothing more than a single date or kiss.
Wow, what do I say? I can't really figure out our relationship. You sure are strange, but in a weirdly almost good sort of way. You've got so many talents I hope that you do something good with them. Learn to accept yourself as you are and just be yourself. Don't forget me. I sure won't forget you.
In a few cases that last category included a "call me" or "let's get together this summer" comment. I dunno what sort of comments other people get in their yearbooks. Are these fairly typical? Maybe there's a web page out there somewhere which compiles yearbook comments...

Comments (8)

esox67
Sorry, I cannot help. I have never read the comments in my yearbook, and have not been to a single class reunion either. Somehow I received invitations for my 20th & 25th reunion, so somebody has obviously outed me but I have not tracken down the culprit who gave my address away.
Dadman
Wow, esox, you're one sentimental dude (or dudette...who knows)... Cosmic: I have some very interesting comments in my yearbook and may have even been called 'weird' a time or two myself. AM called me a 'hiney hole'. I think that's my favorite comment of all. ;) My impeccable, Kelso-esque hair got a few comments as did my artistic/acting prowess, such as it was in 1977. I'd be very interested in seeing an excerpt of what I wrote in your yearbook. I'm sure it's the epitome of stupid. :)
CosmicConservative
Hmmm... The manufactured representative samples listed above were the "run of the mill" sorts of comments. I was frankly surprised to see multiple comments about my dislike of the football team, as well as multiple comments indicating that someone felt I was on the verge of being physically attacked by certain teachers. In fact the teacher most frequently mentioned as one who was out for my blood was a teacher I remember defending from disrespecting behavior from my classmates. I think people just assume that if a student and teacher get into a discussion, that the teacher is angry or upset, when in fact I thought that my conversations with most teachers were truly exchanges of ideas and opinions that the teachers respected and enjoyed. At least several teachers told me exactly that. Odd that people saw that as me being attacked by the teacher. I'm sure that I could analyze that more deeply if I wanted. I also had some truly weird comments, including one from PR that started off vaguely insulting and wandered into a free-association free verse about kidney beans. If there is one overriding quality of the comments I read that surprised me it is that the vast majority of the comments seemed to me to be thoughtful comments. I had virtually no "Have a great summer!" or "Keep it real" sorts of comments with a signature under them. The vast majority of them referred to my "uniqueness" and many reflected on how much more they enjoyed classes with me in them, even when they didn't necessarily say that they liked ME that much. But the football thing... I guess that's a reference to my botched editorial where I tried to get people interested in the team after they lost a few games, but wrote it poorly and it came out as being critical of the team instead... But I didn't think people would remember that enough to comment on it in my yearbook six months later.
Andy
I looked at mine not too long ago. Man, were those idiots ever wrong about me, and my future. Triple wrong! I went to high school with a bunch of monors. Obviously. :)
esox67
Yea, yearbooks, reunions & facebook are just not me. I grew up in a very small one factory dying industrial town. I knew once high school ended, that any opportunities for me were well beyond that town. I do visit about once a year as I have relatives nearby, but I have not run into a single person I graduated with since 86 anytime I have visited.
CosmicConservative
Based on my experience with friends and family over the years I am convinced that the circle of friends I hung around with in the 1977 Bossier High School senior class was singularly special. The relationships that were built during those few years as we transitioned from children to adults have been strong enough to overcome the thousands of miles of geography that now separate us. And I'm probably the least socially connected of the whole group. I didn't realize then how rare such a group of people really are.
Andy
Cosmic, it was a rare group. Seriously, I have enjoyed discovering just how close many sets, or groups of buddies (male and female) have remained over the years. I've been guilty of letting some of my closest buds drift away...all my fault. But, it's fascinating to see how many others have not. I think it may have something to do with the military aspect of it all. So many in our class had moved around their whole lives. At the end of those high school years, the cord to Mom & Pop was being cut (for the most part), and those "recently made friends" could not be taken away by Dad being stationed elsewhere. That was a new thing to a lot of kids in our class. Maybe that has something to do with it. I'm getting lost here trying to explain what I mean, so I will quit.
Drax
Heh, my high school buddies are well left behind, or, from their perspective, well to have left me behind.