Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Major mistake

By CosmicConservative
Johnson walked to the back of the Whistling Straits clubhouse, entered the scoring room and sat in disbelief as Mark Wilson, the co-chairman of the PGA of America rules committee, performed an autopsy of the bunker incident. Minutes later Johnson scribbled his name on the scorecard -- making it official -- and that was that. "He was disappointed," said Wilson. "He couldn't have been more a gentleman about it." via PGA Championship: Dustin Johnson's error will haunt him forever - ESPN.
Golf. It's a weird game. Most casual golfers don't even know the rules of the game. I've seen golfers break golf rules multiple times in a single round without even any knowledge that they've done so. In case you haven't seen the story, golfer Dustin Johnson had a one stroke lead on the 18th hole of the PGA Championship, one of golf's four "major" championships. Winning a major championship is considered a career-making event in golf. There are precious few golfers who have ever won more than one, and winners of more than five pretty much make up the list of elite golfers in the history of the game. So winning a major championship is a Big Deal. It means the difference between obscurity and immortality in golf. And here was Dustin Johnson on the 18th hole of the year's last Major, with a one stroke lead. Make par, and he's the newest golf Olympian. So he walks up to his ball, which is in a little depression with sand at the bottom, and addresses the ball, then, ever so briefly, places the head of his iron in the sand behind the ball. Then he hits the ball and walks towards the green. As he heads towards the green, a tournament official jogs up behind him and says "Um. Mr. Johnson? We've got a problem." Or words to that effect. See, that little bit of putting the club's head on the ground behind the ball is called "grounding the club" and it is against the rules of golf to ground your club in a course hazard. There are many kinds of hazards, but these days you usually only see bunkers, usually filled with sand. Yes, there are many, many casual golfers who have no clue about the basic rules of golf, and I have even seen golfers take practice swings in a bunker (also against the rules), but for a PGA professional to not realize he is standing in a bunker on a Major championship golf course is inexcusable. Right now the press is doing everything possible to make Johnson into a martyr to the "esoteric" rules of golf, and he is becoming golf's latest "hero" because of his, and his caddy's, basic inability to read and follow the rules of golf. This is exactly the same thing as if a receiver in the NFL caught a ball with one foot out of bounds, or if an offensive lineman blocked with his hands outside his elbows, or if a baseball pitcher twitched on the mound before delivering a pitch... all "esoteric" rules of the game, but rules that players are expected to know, understand and follow. Dustin Johnson has nobody to blame but himself. I don't understand why people are blaming the tour officials for this. He was in a bunker. He grounded his club. That's the rules.

Comments (15)

Dadman
We live in a society that less and less likes to follow the letter of the law. People prefer to go with what FEELS right to them. This reminds me of something...oh yes, the recent no hitter that was taken from a pitcher due a seriously botched call at first. People were screaming for Selig to reverse the call and were quite angry when he refused to.
Boyd
I wish I could find a video of the incident, but it doesn't appear that the network that broadcast the tournament (wasn't it CBS?) has it posted. Anyway, from everything I've seen and heard, nobody is saying that the rule against grounding your club in a hazard is dumb or wrong or stupid or obscure. Johnson said that he knowingly grounded his club since he didn't think he was in a hazard. What folks appear to be complaining about is the proliferation of bunkers on that course, even in out-of-play areas, and the local rule that even bunkers with spectators walking through them are still considered in-play hazards. But not having watched the tournament and with no video available, it's tough to draw any conclusions. Rules are rules, but it's certainly possible for weird local rules to be too much of a "gotcha."
Drax
Um...I'm not putting this on the golfer. The rule is that you can't ground your ball in a "bunker." Because there were so many hazards, this course decided to classify all "hazards" as "bunkers." Accordingly, there were like TWELVE HUNDRED "bunkers" which, in great part, looked like, not a "bunker" but a "dirt patch." In this case, at the time he came to the ball (and even while he was hitting the ball) THERE WERE SPECTATORS IN THE "HAZARD." I've watched a bunch of golf tournaments, but this is the first one in which spectators were allowed to STAND IN THE BUNKER. It's certainly up to the player to know the rules (including whatever weird-ass course rules there may be). The PROBLEM is that it was left up to individual golfers to IDENTIFY which of the dirt patches on the course were "hazards." And, call me insane, but letting spectators STAND IN THE HAZARD would lead most golfers to conclude that the ball was, in fact, NOT in a "bunker." Rules are rules, but -- this was a very poor example of course management (by the management -- not the golfer.)
CosmicConservative
Drax and Boyd, as I understand it, every golf tournament is played under local tournament rules which are published before the tournament begins. This is true for weekend amateur tournaments and professional tournaments. Special circumstances and things the golfers need to know about are published and given to the golfers before the game begins. In this case the tournament went the extra step to post placards in the locker room explaining that the golf course has 1200 bunkers and that many of them are not in the fairway. The statement explicitly said that bunkers could be anywhere on the course and that they could have footprints and tire marks in them, but that golfers were expected to follow the rules for bunkers regardless. As if that isn't enough, the last time a major was played at this course another PGA player was penalized exactly the same way. For the golfer not to know this is inexcusable. For the CADDY to not know this is base incompetence. That is why golfers pay their caddies. To know the local rules and make sure they follow them.
Drax
The point I was making is that the golfer could know the rules, but not be able to IDENTIFY which of the dirt patches were classified as a "bunker" and that allowing spectators to stand in the "bunker" -- unraked, trash in it -- would lead most golfers to conclude that they were indeed following the rules and his ball was NOT in one of the 1200 dirt patches this club's management classified (due to LAZINESS) as "bunkers."
CosmicConservative
I saw a picture of the offending bunker. It is a depression with sand in it. After having read the placard posted in the locker room I'd have thought it qualified as a "bunker" and would not have grounded my club. And I'm not even a casual golfer, much less a professional. These guys make their living playing golf. They can read the damn local rules, and if they have any doubt, then they can not ground their club or they can ask one of the local tournament officials who roam the course. I played in two golf tournaments in my life. Just casual weekend golf tournaments, and I didn't do well, but I DID read the tournament rules addendum. And in both cases it was important to do so. In both cases each course had specific local rules about play that not only were important, but that came into play in the tournament. In both cases there were rules about play in specific areas of the course that were either under construction or were being reseeded. These guys aren't casual golfers who happened to be playing at this golf course because their regular course was booked. They are professional golfers playing at a Major tournament and it looks to me like they couldn't be bothered with reading a rule that was not only in the tournament literature handed out to all golfers and caddies, but was prominently displayed in the locker room itself. I have no sympathy. Knowing the rules of the game, both overall and local conditions for a particular course, are why they get paid to play the game.
Drax
I stand by what I said, but... He didn't even READ the rules. So, no sympathy for him.
CosmicConservative
My point all along has been that he didn't read the rules.
CosmicConservative
Here's an interview with the official who had to give the ruling after a video review. Some interesting quotes:
But Price had dealt with two other questions from Johnson or his caddie about bunkers the previous few holes. On No. 14, Johnson hit into an area just past a bunker and asked if he could take some practice swings for that shot in the bunker. Since the ball wasn't in the bunker, Price told him he could. Then, on No. 16, Johnson's caddie asked if he could remove some stones near the ball. Price told him they were in a bunker and by rule they can move loose impediments as long as the golf ball doesn't move. But there was no doubt to Price that Johnson was in a bunker. "All he had to do was ask," Price said. "He'd asked me before that. He'd been in a bunch of bunkers. You don't remind a player on every hole that you can't ground your club."
So on two previous holes with similar bunkers, Johnson apparently realized they were bunkers. Maybe the pressure just got to him on that last hole, I dunno, but again, that's what golfers pay caddies for. Seriously I don't understand why more people aren't asking where the caddy was on this. The primary job of a caddy is to keep the golfer from making mistakes because they are too focused on making a shot.
CosmicConservative
Oh, one thing I find interesting is that Price said he advised Johnson that he could remove loose impediments in the bunker. I think this is wrong. I'm trying to open an official golf rules file, but I can't get my Adobe reader to work and I can't seem to download a new version. But I have always thought that you can NOT remove loose impediments in a hazard, and a bunker is a hazard. You can remove loose impediments OUTSIDE of a hazard, and I did so myself in my last round of golf, but in a bunker, you have to play as it lies, you can't even ground the club or use any other tool or device to test the consistency of the lie (that's where the "you can't ground your club" rule comes from, grounding your club allows you to test the consistency of the sand which helps you to gauge the shot). If you can't make the shot in a hazard because of the conditions, that's why it's called a hazard and your option is to take a penalty stroke and drop the ball back a club length from where it entered the hazard. That's the rule as I understand it. I think Price got that rule wrong. Also, interestingly enough... the rule about practice swings in a bunker is hazy, but I know you can't take a practice swing if your ball is in the bunker. I always assumed that you can't take practice swings in bunkers period. But now I'm not so sure. But then again, since I think Price got the other rule wrong, perhaps he's 2 out of 3 wrong on bunker rulings. If so that doesn't say much for the PGA, does it?
CosmicConservative
Sigh... actually there are slightly different rules for water hazards, vegetation hazards and bunker hazards. If you are in a bunker (sand or grass) then if you have an unplayable lie, you still have to drop the ball IN the bunker. Other hazards you drop the ball where it crossed the line of the hazard. So you can't take a stroke and drop the ball behind a sand trap. Some people might like that option... but sadly, it's against the rules.
JeffSullins
This is exactly how I lost the British open! Imagine it happening twice to two different golfers!!
CosmicConservative
Heh, the British Open is usually played on a Links course....
CosmicConservative
LOL, it would explain why you lost the British open the way you did...