Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Review: Dead Man's Chest

By CosmicConservative
Yesterday my wife, son and I went to see "Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men's Chest". It was a movie we had been anticipating since our daughter had already seen it and had given it a good recommendation. So we were anticipating a good movie going in. And it was definitely a movie worth seeing for the special effects alone. It probably isn't going to be possible to talk about the movie without spoilers, so if you haven't seen the movie, you may not want to continue reading. It's an odd movie. Part drama, part romance and part slapstick farce. It starts slowly with Will (Orlando Bloom) and Elizabeth (Keira Knightly) being arrested for their helping "Captain" Jack Sparrow escape the hangman's noose in the first movie. Will is given a chance by the head of the "East India Company" to save Elizabeth by hunting down Jack Sparrow and returning with his "broken" compass. Will takes him up on this and soon finds himself tracking Jack Sparrow through the ports of the Caribbean where Jack seems to be a notorious figure. Jack, in the meantime, has been trying to figure out how to save his neck from an eternity of servitude on the "Flying Dutchman" the ghost ship captained by none other than Davey Jones himself. Seems Jack had gained control of the "Black Pearl" by bartering his soul with Davey Jones for 13 years of being Captain of the Black Pearl. So much for the plot. The rest of the movie details Jack's schemes to avoid his fate on the Dutchman while avoiding a giant squid called "The Kracken" which is tracking him through a mark placed on his palm by Davey Jones. Apparently Jack is so attached to his hand that the thought of sacrificing his hand to save his, his friend's and his crew's lives from certain death was too much to bear. Well, had he chopped off his hand it would have been a much shorter movie anyway. With a lot less swordplay. The movie is a lot more fun when it drops all pretensions of seriousness and simply devolves into comic farce worthy of a good Three Stooges movie. The last 30 minutes of the movie are the most fun by far, even if they seem to have been written and directed by other people than the first two hours were. It made me wish the whole movie had been conceived as farce instead of such earnestness. The end of the movie has Jack facing off against the Kracken mano a mano. Er... mano a squido I guess. How this will end with Jack serving his term on the Dutchman is left unexplained, as well as how Jack will survive the encounter at all. But no worries, apparently death is simply a holiday in the Caribbean as the "twist" at the end of the movie reveals. So as unlikely as it seems, Captain Jack will definitely be back in the third and final movie. If you want a movie that is consistent, well paced and intelligent, you should probably see another movie. But if you are willing to patiently sit through two hours of setup to get to 30 minutes of hilarious bedlam, then you'll probably enjoy this a lot. My biggest complaints: Jack is no longer played as Keith Richards, instead Jack is played as over-reaching self-parody which is sometimes funny but usually tiresome. Keira Knightly is boring. Now there are four words I never thought I would type. But there it is. For the bulk of the movie she is simply uninspired. She pouts a lot, and she flirts with Jack unceasingly, but she doesn't really light up the screen the way the only female in an otherwise all-male cast should. The special effects were fantastic, but the denizens of the Flying Dutchman are so overdone that it just becomes tedious trying to figure out what sea creature they are inexplicably morphing into. Davey Jones himself seems some sort of squid/octopus thing, with a huge crab claw and a tendency to blubber when he talks. Sometimes it's funny, but mostly it's distracting. What I liked: Orlando Bloom somehow manages to keep a straight face throughout the movie. The ships themselves are magnificent. The texture of the ropes is palpable, the timbers creak and groan with strain, the sails billow and bloom with the wind and the sea crashes against the ships with authority. I want more of those ships, especially I want more of them fighting. I don't want to be too negative because it was a fun movie when it finally got around to it. I won't go into the disgusting black teeth of the voodoo princess, or the gory opening scenes, or the gratuitous cannibalism or the silliness of the central plot device itself. All of those are endurable in the end. Just don't expect everything to make sense. After all, it's just a movie based on one of the lamest DisneyLand rides. I can't wait for the final movie. ;)

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.