Piling on...
By CosmicConservativeSo while GW Bush was at the G8 summit this weekend, pretty much every Democrat from Howard Dean to Newt Gingrich (waitaminute, Newt's not a Democrat!) was piling on GW Bush accusing him of dropping the ball on the middle east and that's what led to the Hamas/Hezbollah aggression. In particular I was sad to see the comments of Bill Clinton who has been going around repeating the mantra "The more the U.S. leads talks, the fewer people die".
What I want to know is, why people let them get away with this? I'm in my mid-forties. I have been paying close attention to the news and the middle east for at least 30 years. I have looked into the history of the middle east conflicts going back for generations before that.
When Hillary Clinton (in a moment of supremely unintended irony) says "We need to bo back to the policies that worked" in the middle east, I have to ask "What are you smoking Hillary?" There is one overriding historical fact in middle eastern politics. That is the absolute certainty that the Arab nations have as their primary goal the extinction of Israel as a state. There have been multiple wars fought over this, and Israel has won every one. How do we know Israel won? Because if Israel had lost just one of them, there would be no Israel. The "successful" policies of Hillary's husband from 1992 - 2000 (continued by the Bush administration until recently) were a continuation of fifty years of dismal failure to get Islamic extremists to accept Israel's right to exist. Bill Clinton and (to a lesser extent) George W. Bush twisted arms in Israel while coddling known terrorist Yassir Arafat so thoroughly that Israel gave up the Gaza strip, retreated fully from Lebanon and abandoned settlements in the West Bank. I'll give Bush credit for at least refusing to negotiate with Arafat.
The result of Hillary's husband's "successful" policies? Improved rocket launching platforms for Hamas and Hezbollah to attack Israel.
That's Hillary's idea of success?
Newt's criticism is more pointed and more accurate, but still overly simplifies Bush's policies. I understand that Newt is running for President now, and there is much to criticize in Bush's middle east policies, but I wish Newt would wait until after the midterm elections to start his Presidential rhetoric.
Joe Biden gets the "huh?" of the day with his comments that seem to be simultaneously charging the Bush administration for doing too much, and doing too little. He goes back to Bush's famous "Axis of Evil" speech and after attacking Bush for over-committing us to a disastrous war in Iraq, then is able to perform the mental contortion to declare that Bush has "done nothing about this Axis since that speech," overlooking somehow the very war in Iraq he had just spent some time calling over-zealous. I guess in Joe's mind, military action against Iraq is too much, while negotiation with North Korea is too little. That's a pretty good deal, pretty much covering all the bases so that anything Bush does is wrong.
What drives me nuts is how people let them get away with it. Why didn't the interviewer of Joe Biden simply point out these contradictions? Why doesn't someone ask Hillary "Uh, Hillary, if Bill's policies were so successful, why was Hamas sending suicide bombers into Israel while you and Bill were so successfully 'talking' to Yassir Arafat? Does the word 'Intifada' mean anything to you?" Why doesn't someone ask Newt "If you are so brilliant about the middle east, why aren't you working with this administration in a substantive role to deal with the problem? Is running for President more important to you than saving lives in Lebanon?"
Some days it has to be hard for GW Bush to get up in the morning....
Comments (3)