"Accordingly, our own Universe may be the interior of a black hole existing in another universe." So concludes Nikodem Poplawski at Indiana University in a remarkable paper about the nature of space and the origin of time. The idea that new universes can be created inside black holes and that our own may have originated in this way has been the raw fodder of science fiction for many years. But a proper scientific derivation of the notion has never emerged. via Technology Review: Blogs: arXiv blog: Why Our Universe Must Have Been Born Inside a Black Hole.The real action is in the comments. You can sense the frustration of the commentators who see, as I do, that physics has become a realm where virtually any bizarre "theory" gains instant credibility so long as it pays proper homage to the current physics shibboleths and criticisms of those "theories" are discounted as "crackpot" or worse if they do not pay proper homage to them. The first time I encountered the concept of black holes containing a "singularity" which is usually defined as "infinitely dense" I knew that physics was losing its way. That way has led to 50 years of mental masturbation known as "String Theory" and out of that has come all manner of speculation masquerading as "theory." Physics is in a world of hurt. I think it's going to take a literal revolution in the ranks, or a complete expulsion from those parts of science that still have some connection with reality to fix it. One of the commenters here says the problem goes all the way back to Einstein, but I don't think that's fair. Einstein himself pointed out that his theories were not comprehensive and that there were serious problems with "continuity" and with reconciling the smoothness of relativity with the chaos of quantum mechanics. Einstein knew we were merely on the cusp of understanding. It's not his fault if an "Einstein cult" has grown up which has taken physics in directions that Einstein himself would not approve of. I think perhaps the revolution in physics might just occur after the "Higgs Boson" search reaches its climax. When the result of that "experiment" ends up with inconclusive results which do nothing to "prove" any current physics theory and merely open the door to more speculation, there may well be an economic revolt due to the massive amounts of public money spent on a pursuit that has provided exactly zero results after trillions of dollars spent and entire generations of physicists devoting their lives to no effect. We will see.
The State of Physics illustrated
By CosmicConservativeI have periodically stated on this blog, and in postings on other blogs, that the state of physics is best described as "dysfunctional." Physics is the father of all sciences, but for the past few generations physics has been virtually worthless as a predictive or theoretical "science." In fact it is hard to call physics "science" anymore. This article is a good illustration of why.
Comments (21)