Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

McChrystal, Patraeus, Obama & Afghanistan

By CosmicConservative
I was a bit surprised by Obama accepting McChrystal's resignation. I figured he would see this as an opportunity to deflect the charges of being petty and thin-skinned, and he would say that removing the Afghanistan Commander just before the peak of the "surge" activity which is supposed to dislodge the Taliban forces from their strongholds would not be in the best interest of Afghanistan, Pakistan or the United States. If I try to give Obama credit for actually thinking this through instead of just being a petty tyrant, I would have to assume that he felt he had to show he had some male reproductive organs and the only way to do that was to fire McChrystal. Of course the truth is that it would have taken more gonads to leave McChrystal in charge. As far as I know, General Patraeus is not being asked to give up his other 24x7x365 job, which I believe is CENTCOM. That's just the job that led to Patraeus's collapse in Senate hearings last week. No reason he shouldn't be able to shoulder the burden of rescuing a failed military strategy in yet another far-flung hotbed of violence and corruption while continuing to head our Central Command offices. Remember, when Bush appointed Patraeus head of the Iraq War, the Left responded with one of their most vile and disgusting spectacles by posting the "General BetrayUs" ad in the New York Times (which gave MoveOn.org a discount to publish that ad). Now that Patraeus is the only hope for salvation for Barack H. Obama, you can bet the Left will be busily erasing all evidence of that ad and hoping (perhaps "knowing" is a better word) that the average American will forget how they brutalized and slimed Patraeus in Senate hearings, where one Senator Barack H. Obama preened and posed for the cameras while heaping disdain on the general he is now asking to save his political fortunes. It is important to note in this situation that Afghanistan is really a tough problem to solve. Iraq, for all it's internecine violence, tribalism, aid from Iran and other obstacles, was at least geographically fairly easy to manage. Afghanistan's remote mountains have few roads and fewer airports. Moving massive amounts of military hardware around Iraq is child's play (for the US military anyway) compared to Afghanistan. If anything the local people of the area are less trusting of the USA than Iraqis were, and that's saying a lot. People are right to point out that the Soviet Union bankrupted itself attempting to invade and control this area. If Patraeus pulls this off, he should be immediately promoted to the head of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and should form his exploratory committee for a run at the Presidency. I wonder if Keith Olbermann will lead off his show today with a reprise of his famous "General BetrayUs" smear. Somehow I doubt he will.

Comments (7)

Mitchieville » Blog Archive
[...] Read more at the Cosmic Conservative [...]
Cullen
Had Pataeus stayed at CENTCOM commander, he might have had a shot at CJCS, but I don't think he has enough time left in his career. He's already at 36 years and I don't think he can do more than 38. Also, there's a lot of "insider" talk about him seeking public office after his military career is over. Patraeus will not be doing both the CINCCENT and Afghan commander positions. Right now it's looking like Marine General Mattis is in line to take the Tampa Bay job.
Cullen
OK, that was a weird formatting thing. There shouldn't be any space between "...a lot of..." and "insider" and "talk about." Odd.
CosmicConservative
Cullen, you had put asterisks on each side of the word "insider" and apparently WordPress sees those as line breaks. I fixed it for you. ;)
tfhr
While GEN Petraeus is a good choice for the task at hand, unless the diplomatic team is swapped out and the artificial (2012 election driven) draw-down date is changed or eliminated, the change in the military component leadership just won't make enough of a difference. My worry is that those two things will not change or change enough and that the removal of McChrystal will be the blanket excuse used by this administration and its supporters for its failure to execute the war.
Cullen
Thanks. I've gotten used to doing the internet thing of using the asterisks as a form of emphasis that quotation marks don't quite seem to imply. Anyway, I haven't been able to find any documentation backing up my 38 year statement above, so, who knows? Patraeus could very well wind up becoming CJCS, but I just don't get the feeling that he's going to look for (or get) that job. Time will tell. He is the best person for the Afghan job, thouhg.
esox67
It is no surprise that McChrysal was removed. While he has the right to disagree with our current executive branch privately, he knows he cannot do it publicly in any fashion. Especially with a president that has such a fragile ego. That being said, considering that Patraeus was thrown under the bus by Obama and friends less than 2 years ago, I am surprised he took this on, as he has to know that same bus is a coming to run him over again in the near future..... Personally if given the option I would have said, thanks, but NO thanks to Obama and friends for a 2nd run.