Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Mirror Images

By CosmicConservative
Yesterday, since I was stuck inside anyway, I spent some time digging into the Deborah Frisch - Jeff Goldstein brouhaha. I posted a bit about it yesterday. In doing this I followed a lot of links to other blogs encountering a roughly equal mix of hard right, hard left and moderate sites. What I saw there is absolutely amazing to me. In the far left blogs the posters and commenters routinely describe conservatives as "hate-filled warmongers" and blame every person who voted for GW Bush for every death of every citizen in Iraq since the 2003 invasion. They say things like "We have to take the higher moral ground because we are better than them" and then turn around in the next sentence and say things like "It's okay attack conservatives because they are intolerant idiots who don't know how stupid they are." It's quite stunning to see the level of anger and the abject hypocrisy on display. Until you go to the hard right sites and you see exactly the same attitude expressed but with the opposite perspective. Those on the left are described as "traitors" and "terrorist sympathizers" and just as on the left you will see post after post saying "But we are at a disadvantage in fighting them because we are naturally better and nicer than they are." The Left uses Ann Coulter and Rush Limbaugh as examples of vicious hate-mongers (which I think goes to show that they don't listen to Rush, although I won't argue their opinion of Ann), while the Right uses Michael Moore and Al Franken as examples of vicious hate-mongers. Each side uses Google to locate specific examples of unbelievable vitriol posted on blogs to support their contention, and each side finds plenty of material to work with. But what absolutely amazes me is that each side seems completely unaware of how they are viewed by the other side. It's almost as though there is a conscious effort to attack a caricature of the other side instead of actually dealing with substantive issues. When the two sides collide, there very rarely a calm, rational discussion of the reasons for the Iraq war, the costs and benefits of the war and the likely future status of the middle east. Within two or three posts it devolves into "Baby Killer!" "Oh yeah, you're just a chairbound terrorist!" "Bush clone!" "Traitor!" It isn't hard to see how the level of discourse drops so low that somebody eventually posts something as vile and offensive as Deb Frisch did. In fact it happens a lot. I'm afraid that it's just getting worse too.

Comments (5)

Drax
Hmmm...while I understand what you're saying (and don't dispute it for the great part) when you're in the middle of a "debate," it is kind of necessary to attack the most extreme position of the other side, because, indeed, they hold that position (or they aren't really that much different from us in their thinking). For example, most liberals I know absolutely HATE George W. They BELIEVE that he is doing this for the oil and his oil friends. So, if we support the war (and Bush) then we ARE supporting "killing babies," because babies ARE killed in this effort. By the same token, most conservatives I know BELIEVE that it is necessary to "nip (terrorism) in the bud." Further, they are convinced that anyone who is outspoken against the war is, in effect, "aiding the enemy" (shades of Jane Fonda). Thus, they, in this light, they ARE "traitors." There really isn't much of a "middleground" in this debate. Either you believe that this war against terrorism is necessary, or you don't. If you do, then, collateral damage is to be expected. If you don't, then, any loss of human life is "murder." There is a host of other issues in which there really isn't much of a middle ground: abortion, gay marriage, immigration, etc. When there isn't much of a middle ground, it seems that screaming at each other is the logical outgrowth....
CosmicConservative
I understand the need to challenge the core of each side's arguments. But that doesn't have to be done by turning every "discussion" into a middle school recess experience. For example, instead of going directly to the "Baby-killer" vs. "Traitor" stage of the argument, the real issue that separates the two points of view is this. Are we truly in a "war"? I think there is room to discuss this question rationally. If the answer to that question is "yes" then Bush's actions seem fully justified. If the answer is "no" then his actions can be challenged. But if the answer is "sort of" then we need to sit down and work out the parameters of how you fight a "sort of" war. What are the limits of acceptable behavior? Most of the liberals I've discussed this with will say something like "OK, I supported Afghanistan, there was clearly a link between Al Qada and the Taliban, so going to war against the Taliban was completely justifed and I'm glad we did it. But the link between Al Qada and Iraq was not sufficient to support going to war, and that's why I have a problem with it." This seems to me to be a reasonable position to take, even if I don't personally agree with it. Bush made a judgment call on going to war in Iraq. He believed that the danger to the U.S. from a terrrorist/Iraq alliance was worth taking Iraq down. We had an election over this question and Bush won it, so in that sense his actions were vindicated. As the war continues to drag on, the question now becomes "How long should we continue to be there?" Bush says "when Iraq is ready for us to leave, we'll leave." Liberals say "Hey, I think they're ready now, let's go." So now we can discuss what the actual readiness of the Iraqi people is. It seems that there is a lot of ground to cover that doesn't resort to "moonbat" vs. "wingnut" charges. That's all I'm sayin'.
Drax
Heh. I understand what you're saying. It's just that we didn't START with the "baby-killer"/"traitor" name calling, but, it has evolved to that as the positions on each side has hardened. I remember when I first ran across "Cross-Fire" more than a decade ago and was simply amazed at how vitrolic supposed intellectuals could be on even the most unimportant of issues. (I can't remember the liberal guy then, but he had some "gravitas" as a WWII "hero" and Pat had his own) Yet, these two guys, along with their guests would literally be shouting down their opponents. (I'm reminded of the Korean Parliment's fist fight some years back....calling up memories of Sam Calhoun (I think) beating someone with his cane during a Congressional session...) Maybe it isn't the "mainstream" liberals/conservatives that act suchwise, but the "talking heads" (whether print/televised) who act in this manner....leading us non-entities to think that this is the way we're SUPPOSED to act? Dunno. It's really disheartening that, in this day of issues which may decide the future of the human race, that the level of discourse has regressed to school yard level.
qwerty182764
I understand what you're saying too. But when it comes to action, who's DOS attacking who's sites?
CosmicConservative
I assume you are referring to Protein Wisdom's repeated outages caused by Denial Of Service (DOS) attacks. As far as I know they have not pinned down the source of the attacks, and it is as likely to be Islamist hackers as it is to be leftists attempting to rescue Deb Frisch. I don't assume that it is moonbat hackers just because of the timing, although it could be. I remember during the election of 2004 listening to both right-wing and left-wing radio the incredible number of calls coming in talking about vandalism of political signs. The amazing thing was both sides were absolutely convinced that the other side was perpetrating the vandalism and that their side was the victim. It's hard to say which side suffers more from actual malicious activity the other side initiates. And soon enough it becomes justified by the whole "well, they started it!" excuse. People really should listen to and read both sides. It is stunning how similar it all is. Simply stunning.