Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

WOW Update of the month

By CosmicConservative
So, I'm very seriously considering quitting my raiding guild. There are a lot of reasons for this, some of which I have mentioned in previous WoW updates. Basically I'm not happy with the way the guild treats newer members, and I don't like how they approach recruiting and training new raiding members. The last straw was yesterday when one of the guild members in guild chat announced an ad-hoc raid in one of the new raiding areas (IceCrown Citatel 10-man), but did not invite me to join them since my gear is not yet top level raiding gear. I pointed out to him that my gear was listed by a couple of WoW character ranking sites as being optimal for the raid he was running, but he said he didn't want to have any party wipes so was looking for characters with higher level gear. I pointed out to him again that it was through these guild raid runs that guild members acquire the gear he is looking for, and pointed out that I had a long and successful raiding history with the guild, but he was unmoved, and soon I saw him trolling in the general channel for DPS to run his raid with. As it happened another guild was putting together their own ad-hoc run in the same raid (ICC 10 man) and they needed a DPS and invited me. Their gear was mostly similar to mine, and in fact I ended up being second overall in damage output during the raid and was top damage output on every boss fight we had (Rhlyssa is optimized for boss fights so she doesn't do well on "trash" mobs where area of effect spells can really ramp up a character's damage output). In fact the other guild was very appreciative of my participation and were very forgiving of the one major error and several minor errors I did commit. So when we finished I thought about how my own guild had treated me compared to how a random guild had done so and I came within a single return key press of quitting the guild. But I thought "I better sleep on this" and escaped out of the quit command. But I'm still pretty sure I'm going to gquit tonight. I'm just debating now whether I should post something on the guild's website about why I am leaving.

Comments (6)

Drax
Unless you have some strong interpersonal relationships with some of your guild members, I'd jump that guild in a second to another where I'm appreciated for myself rather than my gear. If you can't find a guild filled with people who enjoy playing with you because you're you, I'd jump WoW for a different game where the play is enjoyable because you enjoy playing with people with whom you spend your time.
CosmicConservative
Drax, well I think your comment would be much more appropriate if it were anyone but me we're talking about here. I've never been much good at building "interpersonal relationships" and at best I'm a sort of stand-offish figure who tends to fire off a biting ironic comment or (hopefully) humorous quip from time to time. Otherwise most of my interaction with other guild members is pretty specific to class or profession discussions or offering to help someone finish a quest or create a specific item. I don't "pal around" well in real life or in the virtual world. Most of what people seem to like to chat about strikes me as inconsequential and most of what other people seem to find hilarious strikes me as juvenile or worse. So for me it's not so much about being pals with the guildies, it's more about whether the guild is an actual, you know, guild, as opposed to a club or a clique, which is what my current guild really is. And I've never been very good at cliqueing.
Drax
The point is that you can, and should, find a guild that has members that you enjoy spending time with. If the point is to defeat the game without regard of your play-mates, you might as well play a first person shooter or some other game not designed for group play. Certainly, there's enjoyment in whatever accomplishment is achieved in WoW, but, that enjoyment is heightened (or should be) by sharing it with people that you actually like. And, believe it or not, you're a likeable guy... and, at some point, just playing a game to play a game doesn't cut it and doesn't justify the insane amount of time invested in doing so. Compare the real life D&D to WoW. It's all about the people in the end.
CosmicConservative
True, and I've many times made the point that the enjoyment I get out of D&D is more about interacting with people than in beating encounters that are literally designed for you to beat them. I should take that approach more to WoW too, I suppose. And there are some likeable guild members too, it's more the guild leadership and general attitude I find unfulfilling. In fact I think the situation I described above is actually an anti-guild sort of situation. The whole point of a guild is to provide a place for people to interact and to grow as players and for their characters to grow as characters. When guild members literally ignore guild members who are perfectly capable of performing their role in favor of strangers who simply have better gear, I think that's the complete antithesis of the purpose of the guild in the first place. That's what ticked me off. Yeah, that's why we have a guild, so we can boost the experience and gear of non-guild members instead of our own guild members! Makes sense to me...
Drax
Yeah. That would have ticked me off horribly.
Boyd
TL;DR version: /gquit now. Life's too short.