Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Evolution ruminations

By CosmicConservative
Here is a post from MagikalOutcast who wanted to post this while I was on vacation but I wasn't checking the site.
MagikalOutkast Said: July 4, 2006 at 10:29 pm | Edit Ok, Cosmic I apologize about this, but since I can’t make a post I’m placing something I want you to post up….as a new entry….. These are two videos which pretty much both say that Evolution is a load of crap…..and it is kind of right. More Scientific Vid. http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-8438721530266145746&q=evolution More Religious Vid. http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1077170043893992263&q=evolution They are very interesting…I want you to listen to both…and I do want to hear your opinion. It’s very persuasive, but I still believe that evolution exists through mutation (i.e. radiation from astral or cosmic rays from supernovas). Many of the ideas I still feel are crap, but it only makes you wonder. You really can’t find an inbetween of any species,and although you can find different species, there is no inbetween. Eager to hear response. Later
I'll leave this up for other responses, and I'll try to respond later. I'm still unpacking at the moment. No need to apologize Magikal, I'm running a blog, I shouldn't let it go fallow for six days.... You should have gotten a response earlier.

Comments (4)

qwerty182764
Astral rays? I don't understand the absurd resistance to what should be obvious by now - the animal and plant kingdoms are arranged by nested heirarchy, with organisms that are tightly related, in groups less tightly related, in groups less tightly related and so on. This is undeniable to anyone who looks at a field guide. It's undeniable to anyone who looks at their DNA. Now why is this? Evolution offers an explaination. Creationism doesn't. It also handily explains the transitional fossils and extinct organisms of which we have mountains of evidence. The only thing creationism offers is yet one more tribal origins myth. Every single primitive people on the planet have their own origins myth, involving God. Why should Genesis be elevated above the Egyptian, or Greek creation myths? Why should we continue to deny our senses for the sake of insisting on the literal truth of a collection of stories? I personally know evolution, as a hill-climbing algorithm works just fine. I've used it before to solve problems! If it didn't work, I would expect my ascent trajectory optimizer, or my generalized function fitter wouldn't provide me with correct answers to tough problems.
qwerty182764
Which is more likely, most of the scientists on Earth, for the past 150 years, across continents and cultures, have conspired (in many cases without direct communication and influence over each other) to cover up "the Truth", or that the Hebrew people have their own creation story that they made up for social/religious purposes thousands of years before they knew the Earth went around the sun? The insistence on something so irrational is annoying. It's doubly annoying, because most of it comes from the conservative side of the political spectrum, with whom I agree on almost everything else.
qwerty182764
You really can’t find an inbetween of any species,and although you can find different species, there is no inbetween. For a modern example (within the scale of human history) look at the differentiation of dog breeds over time (admittedly, with our influence, but differentiation nontheless. Is a Chihauhau even a dog anymore? :-) ) . Also look at the close relationship between speicies of cat. Also, what about that wooly mammoth? It certainly looks related to the modern elephant, but is adapted for life in a cold climate.
CosmicConservative » On Evolution
[...] Evolution Ruminations [...]