Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Ancient stone building technology

By CosmicConservative
I am always trying to explain to people that our ancestors were not stupid. This shows how a smart architect could figure out how to move, raise and stand on end huge blocks of stone. If you think about this for a bit you can see how this technique could be used to build even something as massive as the pyramids with a reasonably sized labor force and without the need even for the huge dirt ramps that some other archaeologists have speculated must have been used. Even the massive blocks of the Pyramids could have been moved from the quarry to the site with probably no more than 20 men, working in reasonable, although still somewhat risky, conditions. No back-breaking labor is required, just some steady patient labor, a smooth road, and sticks and stones. The only time sheer brute force was probably needed was in the final positioning of the stones from where the two-pivot walking technique would have left them, maybe only needing to nudge the block into position by a few feet or so. This could also be done with levers easily enough. Then, once the entire bottom layer was complete, all you have to do is lift it up to that level using the lifting technique shown here, raise it maybe a foot or two above the level, and then rotate it onto the next layer using the technique Wally Wallington used here to flip it 90 degrees where it could then be moved into final position with the two-pivot technique. Yes, it would require patience, but it's totally conceivable, in fact it is far more conceivable than the assumed massive whip-driven slave labor that has been proposed by some, and of course it is far more likely than the idea that aliens must have helped. In fact, if they were clever enough they could have moved the blocks from the quarry to the building site much, much easier if they built the road as a block-rolling road. Then it might only take a handful of workers to move the stones very rapidly. Another suggestion is that the Egyptians built round wooden casings around the stones and simply rolled them on flat roads. That's probably even more likely. Anyway, I am totally convinced that Mr. Wallington has shown us a completely plausible technique for the huge ancient techniques of building massive monuments out of huge chunks of stone. It may well have been the case that there were more workers quarrying the stone than were involved in moving and placing them. Especially since those ancient builders only had copper or bronze tools.

Comments (6)

Andy
Yeah Cosmic, I saw this a while back, and was just fascinated by it. Thanks for posting it. To think that a "retired construction worker" could figure this out is pretty amazing. But maybe not so much...they know a lot about wedges, leverage, etc. I'm pretty sure that any "chief engineer" in ancient times would have grabbed these concepts. Without cranes, backhoes, front-end loaders, the internal combustion engine, etc., I am almost positive that their reliance on the pull of the earth itself, and such things, was much more a part of their thinking and planning. Our ancestors certainly were not stupid. In many ways, they MUST have been required to stretch their brainpower in ways that modern man is not. Not only just to "survive," but to progress. Heck, I think my Great-Grandmothers (who I had into my 30's) were MUCH smarter than I am. And, the stories they told me about their grandparents...the clever, and innovative nature of past generations...well... Maybe we're the idiots! ;) Great video...once again, thanks for posting it.
CosmicConservative
I used to be a big fan of the Discovery channel and shows like "Nova." I remember watching one show where they were trying to figure out how ancient Egyptians had raised the giant Obelisks that dotted the ancient Egyptian temples and royal palaces. Many of these obelisks were over 60 feet high and were carved from one piece of solid rock. They put the challenge to an engineer and an archaeologist, as I recall, asking each to not only propose a method for the installing of the obelisks, but also to hire a team and demonstrate the effectiveness of the method proposed. It's been a long time, but my recollection is that the archaelogist came up with this highly complex system of ropes and pulleys and had something like 50 volunteers acting as labor to get the obelisk lifted. The obelisks were made of high-strength concrete and were, I think, 60 feet long. The engineer's solution was similar to Wally's, except that he used a large pile of sand and hauled the obelisk up the sand. But once he had it on top of the pile of sand, his solution was almost exactly what Wally did, he had a hole dug and filled with sand, and a deeper hole dug next to the foundation hole where the sand from the foundation hole would drain out as the weight of the obelisk settled in the hole. It worked perfectly, and he managed to set his obelisk at a perfect 90 degrees. The archaeologist never managed to get his system to work and eventually the volunteer labor took over his effort but their efforts also failed. Wally's solution here was simpler than either of theirs, but I actually wonder if Wally saw that same show I did and that's how he got the idea for the sand-filled foundation hole. The major advantage of that approach is that it provides a natural shock-absorber which kept the fragile obelisk from cracking or breaking as it settled down into place. Before then one of the great mysteries of the obelisks was not how they had been carved, nor how they had been hauled, but how such huge, fragile pieces of stone could be placed in so many places with virtually no examples of cracked or broken ones to be found. Well, sand filled foundation holes answered that question.
Old Goat
I did see some of the programs that showed both what you mention above from Discovery and from Wally's. If you look at early tools that were used, many of today's tools have the similar principles to them but have been improved upon. Sometimes we tend to over think a problem rather than going with the most simple method. I guess its possible that Wally's method would work on Obelisks but would the horizontal strain of the thing being balanced in the middle of something so long cause it to break in half? Levers and wedges are things even children start to discover and figure out uses for them. The amazing thing is how large a scale they are used on to do things like Egypt had. Archaeologists might become guilty of making things overly complex, as they put their own imprint on that which they are studying. Its been long refuted that the Egyptians had to use slave labor in tremendous quantities to build their various structures.
Andy
Well, I missed the Discovery Channel show that you guys mentioned. However, as I said before, Wallington's work really fascinated me. Maybe it's because I grew up working around an appliance and TV store...where there was always something very heavy to move from one spot to another. I learned early on that a 12 year-old boy can move a 400 pound side-by-side refrigerator by himself...if the dolly is balanced correctly, and the sales floor is smooth enough. I also learned that a 130 pound, 12-year-old boy can lift a 200 pound Friedrich Air Conditioner into a window by himself if he uses his knees to brace against the bottom, and pulls his weight against it...I'll always be grateful for old George Dupree making me do that 'til I learned it. Leverage...balance...experience... Pyramid mystery solved! Levers and wedges...I've watched a bunch of construction guys work miracles with 'em. Thanks again for posting that video, Cosmic. Good grass for chewing...
Paul Beckford
Fascinating video. Reminds me of a TV show I once saw (can't remember if it was In Search Of or Ripley's Believe It or Not) about the "Coral Castle" in Florida. Coral Castle was originally named Rock Gate Park, and was built singlehandedly by Ed Leedskalnin, a 110 lb Latvian immigrant who moved over 1000 tons of carved coral blocks using only hand tools and human ingenuity over a 20 year period. http://coralcastle.com/ Over the years, people have spewed all kinds of outlandish theories about how he managed to move the blocks but when he was personally asked how he managed the feat, Leedskalnin replied only that he understood the laws of weight and leverage. Sure beats the snot out of all those "alien", "antigravity" and "earth's flux" theories. Once again, Occam's razor prevails.
CosmicConservative
Very true Paul. Other people have made the connection between Wally and the Coral Castle. I think it's a virtual certainty that Ed Leedskalnin used the same techniques as Wally.