Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

What makes a good sci-fi story?

By CosmicConservative
My shameless plug for comments post had caused me to wonder what it is that makes a sci-fi story a "good" sci-fi story. I will take it as a given that all the elements of good literature are assumed. In other words "good characters" don't make it sci-fi, nor does "a good plot." Those make a good story, but they don't distinguish a sci-fi story from another story. And a sci-fi story that has good characterization and a good plot can be a bad sci-fi story if it lacks something critical. What is that critical element? In my mind it is the exploration of some social or technical breakthrough that takes the story in unexpected and interesting directions. In "Foundation" that premise was the "Psychohistory" of Hari Seldon. In Dune it was the implication of the time-penetrating effects of the spice. In Hyperion it was the exploration of what it meant to the human soul to be ripped apart and thrown across the galaxy by a teleportation device. In neuromancer it was what happens when the human mind begins to merge with an electronic neural net. In Frankenstein it was what happens when you discover the spark of life can be reintroduced to dead flesh. Yes, I do consider Frankenstein to be science fiction. In fact this is what distinguishes science fiction from fantasy. For example, Star Wars is properly classified as "fantasy" in my mind because the central thematic element in Star Wars is "The Force" which is essentially a supernatural magical force. It's a fantasy story based in a technologically advanced society. Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep (Bladerunner) is pure sci fi. What happens to your society when you can manufacture human beings to specifications and they realize they are created and seek their creator? Of course this all gets a bit confusing when you take into account Arthur C. Clarke's maxim that any sufficiently advanced technology is viewed as magic... Still, this is why I prefer "hard sci-fi" when I read sci-fi. I like fantasy too, but I do think there's a difference.

Comments (7)

CosmicConservative
Ringworld is sci-fi. At least the first book was. The concept in Ringworld was that you could use the raw materials in a solar system to build a ring at a habitable orbit, and use magnetic induction on a massive scale to cause an asymmetric flow of gases from the star, which essentially provides thrust to move the star system. The major engineering hurdle was the creation of a material strong enough to hold together under that sort of stress. That's much less of a stretch than FTL travel, and there are lots of good ol' sci fi stories that employ FTL travel. That's my thought, anyway.
Friday Johnson
Thx ! Your advice really helped me out keep it up :)your good
Allan
I am, or working through a sci-fi story. I was concerned that it might turn out not that good of a story. Although its full of of twists, emotions and a plot that can just continue even after the end. But your belief of the critical element is definitely something I can work in. Its full of technological advances, but also how the human race has altered very little (as in governments, crimes, conflict etc) The sort of things that have occurred for countless years.
Drax
"Good" science fiction, generally, is the same as any other fiction and must have the same elements -- good plot, believable characters one cares about, etc. But... Science fiction can be published and read when most elements found in other fiction are barely recognizable IF the "science" part of the story is compelling enough to those who care about the "science" more than they do the "fiction." (I've read enough "hard SF" to testify to this.) On the other hand, some of the best SF (in my (who else's?) opinion, is of the Star Trek (original series) variety, i.e., where the "science" is really just barely disguised magic. The continuing popularity of the series rests on the strength of the characters. For me, I would MUCH rather see Kirk solve a problem with a punch or a kiss -- or Spock infiltrate and seduce a Romulan captain for the story's denouement than Data whip up some "scientific" solution that I have no hope of understanding, but attempts to achieve something akin to actual "science."