Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Can you sell a house in this market?

By CosmicConservative
OK, so last year the Cosmic Family had decided that we were not going to move in 2010, that we wanted the Cosmic Son to graduate high school before we moved. At that time the move we were contemplating was to move from the mountains back into the city. We're getting a little old for the cold and snow. For that reason we went ahead and refinanced due to the lower interest rates, figuring that we'd get a payout of the difference between our lower payments and the closing costs after about eleven months, and the rest would be gravy. Now if we move this year, that will end up having been a bad decision. Oh well, story of my life and all that. Right now our latest appraisal of the house puts the value of the house roughly 30% above the mortgage payout. But that appraisal is about six months old, and housing prices have continued to plummet. It could easily be the case that we can't sell the house for much more than it's worth, and in that case we may end up paying more for the real estate agent than we'd get out of the deal. Which would basically mean that we'd just walk away from the house with nothing in our pocket for a down payment on a new house. This is my biggest fear right now. The housing market is so depressed that selling now could be the worst time possible. Had we moved a year ago, we probably would have been able to get almost 40% of the value of the house as cash in our pockets. Now we may not be able to get much at all. And of course that will impact what we can buy in Atlanta. The end result is that we are likely to see a significant degradation in the quality of house we can buy, if we can buy one at all. Sigh.. thanks Clinton/Bush/Obama and the whole frickin' US government for making my family a casualty of the housing bust...

Comments (10)

Cullen
What are your other options? Can you rent a place in Atlanta and wait for the house to sell? Is is possible for you alone to go to Atlanta, ahead of the rest of the Cosmic clan, and rent a place while you wait for the home to sell (or you get an offer that's within your liking)? What will it mean to not move?
CosmicConservative
Yeah, good questions Cullen... That's more or less exactly where my head is at, plus "will my company help with this since they are the reason for the move anyway?" I could go to Atlanta, but I think I would tell my boss that my company would have to put me up while waiting for my family. They may even have some pre-paid lodging for this sort of thing. I dunno. I know some companies do that.
Cullen
I hope your company has some kind of program to help you out. I'm in a position now, were I to be faced with a move, I would have to leave the family behind for about three years (the wife just started nursing school). It's all speculation on my part, but I am always watching the federal job site for potential positions.
CosmicConservative
Like most companies, my company used to have a program for helping people move if the move was something the company supported or requested. That program is currently suspended due to the economy. This strikes me as unfortunate because an economy like this is when you need that sort of support, but I do know that a mid-level VP had to deal with the same thing, so it's not just us grunts that are affected. When the potential for a move first came up, my family reacted very negatively. But over the last six months the idea has grown on them, and now they are not merely supportive, they are actually wanting to move. I was pretty surpised that the Cosmic Son would want to move between his junior and senior year of high school, but his autism is a factor in this as well, and he really doesn't have any social ties to the school. Plus he has been told by our therapist that Atlanta has much better support for autism than our tiny mountain town has. The Cosmic Daughter is pretty much a college girl and on her own, she's not thrilled, but it's not a huge deal to her. And the Cosmic Wife has no family and only a few friends in Colorado, so she feels that she'll have a more active social life, and better job options in Atlanta. So other than the problems of selling the house (and all the time and money associated with fixing it up to be salable) there's not much else to do but figure out how to make it happen.
Andy
Is leasing your house in Colorado until/if the market comes back an option? Maybe you can lease it to someone with very good references for enough to pay the mortgage, and find a decent rental for your family in Atlanta. I've rented before. I don't like it, but I have on a short-term (year or two) basis. And, I've rented my property to others. It's not always a nightmare. Just a thought.
CosmicConservative
Ug, the idea of leasing a home in Colorado while living in Georgia appeals to me about as much as having hot pokers stuck in my eyes... I'm not terribly opposed to renting, I've done it before, but I don't like it because I'd rather be building equity if possible. But I'm told that's an old fogey view of modern finances.
OLd Goat
Just a thought, but while selling the home might not be a great thing timing wise, buying a home now is helpful for the buyer. It could be that the two offset each other enough to make it equitable for you. The big thing is if the housing market is the same in both areas. A real estate agent should be able to give you an indication of where things stand I would think.
CosmicConservative
I did some research on the housing prices in the area I would probably want to live. There are three or four neighborhoods and the prices vary wildly, from about 125% of my current home price to about 40% of it. I'm assuming I probably don't want to live in the 40% neighborhood. Based on that though, I think that the price of a comparable home in a decent neighborhood with a decent school is probably going to be very comparable to my current house. And the problem with that is that I can only use for a down payment what I can actually sell the house for in excess of what we owe (plus what we pay the vampire er... real estate agent). Three years ago that was looking pretty good. Our mortgage balance was just about 60% of what our house appraised for. We would have walked away with a substantial amount of cash. But since then we have (unwisely, no doubt) used a second mortgage to fund most of our daughter's college and have seen our home value drop at least 20%. Between the increase in what we owe, and the drop in what the house is worth, suddenly we are looking at a very small amount of cash in our pocket, and that, unfortunately, will be the primary driver of what sort of house we can afford. So even though it's a good time to buy right now, you still have to have something to work with, and our resources are quite limited at the moment. Sigh...
Andy
"Ug, the idea of leasing a home in Colorado while living in Georgia appeals to me about as much as having hot pokers stuck in my eyes…" Well...it was just a thought. :) Ya' know, there are real estate management firms that handle the bad junk for owners that live 2,000 miles away. But, I know what you mean. So, forget what I wrote...
CosmicConservative
LOL, I appreciate the advice, and who knows, leasing a house might turn out to be an investment and a new career. But I'm a lazy slob.