Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

True Life Stories: The Homecoming Peyton Place

By CosmicConservative
One of these days I'm going to pull a George Lucas and write and direct a movie about the late 70s teenage high school scene... I have no idea how "normal" my high school social life was, but I suspect that what I thought at the time was a unique source of pain and frustration in the history of the earth, was actually quite common. Well, after this story you can be the judge... I really don't have clear memories of the specific dates, and this "story" may actually combine a couple of homecomings and maybe even a prom into one story, but as a Democrat might say, the events may be wrong, but the story hits the essentials of the homecomeing dating dynamic just the same. I had a sort of odd social situation in High School. I was sort of involved in several social "circles" in some capacity or another. I wasn't really a central figure in any significant social circle, but I did have a core group of friends that I spent most of my time with, both in school and out. So to set up the participants, without using real names, I will just describe the characters in this story as follows:

Cosmic - That would be me. I did not go by "cosmic" at the time, although some folks did call me "Spock" for various reasons.

The Best Friend - That would be the guy I hung out with the most and with whom I shared more of my personal information and desires.

TwinA - One of the two twins that TBF and I spent much of our time with. TwinA was the first of the twins that I met, and he was a serious, scholarly liberal-in-training who viewed himself as my mentor and confidant, and who spent much of his time with me giving me advice about how to live and act.

TwinB - The other twin who was similar in some respects to TwinA but who was much less serious and who had flashes of a wicked sense of humor.

The GirlFriend - This was my "girlfriend" at the time, although this is not nearly as clear a distinction as it would seem, especially in the circumstances of a homecoming dance. More on that below.

The Smart Girl - This was the smartest girl in our high school class, who just happened to also be quite beautiful, with an especially well developed chestal region.

The Good Girl - This was TSG's best friend and is still one of the nicest human beings I've ever had the good fortune to call a friend.

The Hot Chick - This girl was actually a year behind rest of us (well, except The GirlFriend, who was also a year behind us) but had one of the most incredible gluteous maximi that I have ever had the pleasure to behold. The Hot Chick and I had no mutal social circles, so I had very little actual interaction with her, but her circles included circles that TBF and especially the Twins moved around in. She and The Twins were in the band.

The Sweet Girl This girl was shy and rarely asserted herself. She was an accomplished student and was a member of several clubs and social circles, but she was always the quiet one.

The Cheerleader Nuff said, I think.

A bit of exposition about me and my girlfriend... Our relationship was rather unusual in some ways. Although we dated for almost three years, and much of that time we did just about everything together, there was always a sense of distance between us. A major reason for that was that we went to different high schools in two different cities (just across the river from each other though) and her parents were adamant that she not "commit" to any boy before she went to (and presumably graduated from) college. They were fairly well off, and I was pretty poor, so I always got the sense that I just didn't quite measure up to her parents' expectations. Still we dated more or less exclusively for months at a time in between her sporadic insistence that we "see other people" for a while. This went on until she actually moved to a city 400 miles away. In particular she felt that I should take a girl from my own high school to any really important dance like homecoming or prom. This is important to understand so that the readers don't immediately realize what an actual cad I was in High School. OK, so here we go.... I was hot for The Smart Girl. In fact just to be in her presence would turn me into a stuttering, mumbling, clumsy fool. I have always been a sucker for a chick with a brain, and throwing in a beautiful face and big bazoongas just exacerbated my hopeless infatuation. I really, really wanted to ask her to homecoming. But at that time TGF and I were in one of our "back together again" phases, so I assumed I would take her to the dance. The Best Friend was hot for The Cheerleader. He would wax eloquent about her beauty and good nature. He was right of course, The Cheerleader was not merely beautiful, but was among the nicest people in the world. She had nothing like the stereotypical cheerleader personality. TBF also had a standby in case of any problem with The Cheerleader, although I didn't know it at the time. His next choice was to be The Good Girl. TwinA was hot for The Hot Chick. As a fellow member of the band, he felt that among our group, he had dibs on The Hot Chick for any date. He desperately wanted to ask THC out, but found it very difficult to do so. The Hot Chick, on the other hand, was sending signals to TBF that were so obvious that only TBF could miss them. This didn't help TwinA's disposition re: TBF. TwinB seemed to mostly be casually interested in girls at that time, I don't recall him having any raging hormone-fueled crushes of the type that TBF and I suffered. Perhaps he just hid them well. He seemed to mostly just enjoy watching the dating game as it consumed his friends. Now it is only fair to say that I was fairly generous in my potential affections at the time. While I was sure that I was deeply in love with TGF and I sincerely adored her and cherished every moment with her, I could not deny (nor probably conceal) my raging crush on TSG. But even so, I also had a similar powerful desire to enter into romantic negotiations with The Religious Girl, who was also a year behind us, but who caused my palms to sweat and my ears to ring when I was in her presence. And there was also The Other Smart Girl, who was a junior and who eventually became my next girlfriend after TGF moved away. And I'm sure there were half a dozen other females whose wake when they passed sent my hormones into a whirling vortex of desire. Still, as the big day approached, I continued to assume that I would take TGF to the dance. That is until the night we were out under the moon, enjoying all the good things in life that a boy and girl can do legallly, when she disengaged herself and with the purest innocent look on her face asked: "So, who are you going to take to homecoming?" "Uh," I stammered... "You?" "No, you need to take a girl from your own school, that's the right thing to do." "I don't want to go with a girl from my school" I lied. "I just want to go with you." Which was also true somehow although it was directly contrary to my other thought. Oh youth... "No, really, I won't mind. You know how we are, it isnt' any big deal for you to go out with another girl one night." No matter how much I cajoled, begged or cried, she resolutely refused to go to homecoming with me. Now I was in a fix. The dance cards were filling up fast. So, of course my next move was to strategize with TBF. "Heck just ask TSG." He said, as if it was that simple. "She'll never go with me." "You don't know that. Just ask her." "So, who are you taking?" "Uh... I haven't asked anyone yet." "What about The Cheerleader?" "Uh... well.... you see..." "Oh, so it's that easy is it?" "Shut up." That went on for about a week probably, until desperation started to kick in. And when it did, it kicked hard. The day it all came down was much like any other day. The rising sun gave no indication of the frantic panic and angst-laden grief and recriminations to come. I hate the sun. So, on the way to school TBF and I commisserated and planned. We decided where we would locate our targets and how we would pop the question. We met with TwinA and TwinB to coordinate activities, with no idea whatsoever of how such plans suddenly be seen as opportunities by desperate homecoming date seekers. So I planned on approaching The Smart Girl at lunch. TBF was going to approach The Cheerleader before lunch. TwinA had some plan to approach The Hot Chick, but I didn't pay much attention to that since for all her undeniable feminine charms, The Hot Chick never really got on my list of infatuations. Strange that.... But something happened that changed all plans. I don't recall why his plans to ask The Cheerleader went awry, but as this was unfolding, TwinB suddenly entered the scene, asking The Good Girl out. When she said yes, TBF's standby was gone. Seeing the opportunities dwindling away, he decided to ask The Hot Chick, and The Hot Chick said yes. Which led to TwinA learning that his first choice was no longer available. So he turned to his standby option, which happened to be The Smart Girl. Who also said yes. Now TwinA had never shown any indication of having a thing for The Smart Girl before, so when I finally dredged up enough nerve to stammer out the fateful question, I was stunned beyond measure to discover that she was going to the dance with TwinA. I was crushed and humiliated to be turned down, and to learn that my date had been stolen by TwinA was a cruel, cruel blow. But over the course of the next few hours, I managed to drag myself out of the sewers of human teenage angst and realized that my last class of the day included The Christian Girl. So I gathered up my shredded dignity and managed to corner her for a moment to ask her the fateful question. "Didn't you just ask The Smart Girl?" "Uh... yeah." "Well, if you had asked me first, maybe I would have gone with you." "......" Double barrel to the chest. I picked up my barely beating and bloody heart and jammed it back into the gaping hole of my chest and managed to make it to the end of the class despite being so red and shamefaced that the teacher asked if I needed some help. In retrospect, I should have immediately gone to The Sweet Girl and asked her to homecoming. To this day I beat myself up about not doing so. She was such a sweet girl, and she was plenty cute herself, but for whatever reason she never really fired up my afterburners, and now my mind was full of nothing but recriminations and anger at TwinA so all thoughts of The Sweet Girl fled my mind. As it turned out, The Sweet Girl never got asked, because I finally convinced The GirlFriend to go after all. I sure wish I had asked The Sweet Girl. I'm sure she and I would never have had any romantic entanglements, but she was nice, smart and really, really should have had an opportunity to go to the homecoming dance. Again, please don't attack me if I got some of this wrong. I don't pretend to have a perfect memory, all I recall is that day of musical date chairs and how I got blasted twice, and ended up missing an opportunity to make a sweet young girl a happy girl for a day or so. uh... that's assuming The Sweet Girl would have said yes. ... I suppose she might have turned me down too, in hopes of catching a cuter boy...

Comments (11)

Andy
Cosmic, I'm pretty sure I pegged about 5 of the characters in your soon to be released "blockbuster!" Funny, huh? Those memories are just as fresh as this evening's Iris blooms. I definitely know TBF...and Twins A & B are a "given." TSG with her well-endowed self had me a bit puzzled...but I'm guessing BB. And her best friend "The Sweet Girl," I'm guessing LR. All guesses...I'm sundowning earlier and earlier these days. I guess I was lucky. My prom date was "set in stone." Still dating her, btw! I think we stayed at the prom for about 45 minutes, and then left to do something more interesting... :)
CosmicConservative
Andy, not quite. "The Sweet Girl" wasn't "The Smart Girl's" best friend, that was "The Good Girl." I'm guessing you can probably guess "The Good Girl" but I doubt anyone will guess "The Sweet Girl." She was too quiet and shy I think.
Dadman
Well, I know who I am... I think you may have fused some of the drama associated with both Homecoming and Prom our senior year. I took DM, The Hot Chick who is now btw a physician with a frenchy last name I can't recall, to Homecoming and asked to her go with me right in front of TwinA. Nyuk. He was livid. I asked DC (a year behind us) to prom. I asked her in full Evil Eye Fleagle make-up - painted green from head to toe - after the choir's performance of Li'l Abner. I think TGG was probably AM and I really wish I had asked her to prom. I believe she ended up going with TwinA. The Cheerleader, if I remember correctly went to both Homecoming and Prom with DL, the sax playing band dude who is now one of my Facebook friends (for what that is worth :) ) The Cheerleader remains a very good friend to this day. I'm not sure who TSG is. Give us a hint. I love these old stories...keep sending them out way.
CosmicConservative
Well, there are two "TSG" one is The Smart Girl, and Andy pegged her, I will go to my grave with the image of her striding out of Cypress Lake in that white bathing suit she must not have known would turn transparent when wet. The other "TSG" was "The Sweet Girl" and even if I give hints I doubt you would get it. Her initials were VB for whatever that's worth. No Andy, it wasn't LR, who was the only person in our class younger than me, by a week.
Cullen
I don't think your experiences are inconsistent with others. I will say, for my age group anyway, it was far more common for girls to be "going out" with someone than not. Girls would "be with" a guy for some time then they'd break up and almost immediately hook up with someone else. In this regard, it was very difficult to randomly ask girls out. You had to get to know their situation and then time your question to their breakups.
CosmicConservative
Cullen, based on my observation of my brothers and my children, I think what you describe is the far more common social interaction. For some reason in High School, the group I hung out with for the most part did not develop long-term boyfriend-girlfriend relationships, and that was true of both the boys and girls. At least that's my recollection. Andy here was a classmate and he clearly was in a long-term relationship, and his buddy who sometimes posts here was also usually involved with someone, but TBF, TwinA, TwinB, The Smart Girl, The Religious Girl, The Good Girl, The Other Smart Girl and The Sweet Girl never had a long-term obviously committed boyfriend-girlfriend relationship in high school that I can recall at all. There were some short periods of heavy dating with specific folks, but on a given weekend that group was more likely to be out as a group than broken up into pairs. I was probably the exception in that group in that I did have a long-term boyfriend-girlfriend relationship, as unusual as it might have been. But because it was that unusual and living in different cities and going to different high schools created some significant barriers to being together all the time, I ended up spending a lot of time with my HS friends even though I had a girlfriend myself. It probably was a much stranger situation than we realized at the time. Especially since most of that group were very attractive and dynamic people. I'm sure I was the homeliest and least interesting one of the bunch.
CosmicConservative
... on the other hand, most of the folks in our group, especially the girls, had high ambitions and were involved in lots of activities designed to improve their odds of pursuing an interesting and profitable career. If I were to psychoanalyze some of them, I'd suggest that most of the girls were deliberately avoiding long-term commitments at that time as they didn't see that as conducive to their future plans. As an example of that, of our immediate group that hung out together, I don't believe a single one of them still lives in the Shreveport/Bossier area. We are in Phoenix, Denver, Washington DC, Houston... we're all over the map. I think all of us knew that we wanted to "kick up our heels and wipe the dust of this town off" or whatever the "It's a Wonderful Life" quote is. Most of us were Air Force brats and considered our situation to be a completely temporary one.
Dadman
I know who VB is. Let's just call her Vicky. In high school, I was too impetuous, immature, self-conscious, and any number of adjectives that describe someone not ready for a primetime, long-term relationship. Girls liked me, however, and I liked them even more, so I just dedicated myself to enjoying the company of as many of them as possible. My first serious relationship was with my lovely wife. We've been married now for 26 years. I do recall being the maven of unrequitted love in high school. I would get seriously fixated on a girl regardless of how they felt about me. This happened several times and lasted for months. And while I was fixated on a particular damsel I would learn via the grapevine that some of the hottest girls in the school wanted me to give them a call. I didn't, of course, because I was hopelessly fixated on someone else. Glutton for punishment I was... :)
CosmicConservative
Heh, my problem was the opposite. I tended to have crushes on several girls at once. But my attentions didn't wander around very much. I either was attracted to a girl or I wasn't, and if I was attracted to one, I was pretty much eternally attracted to them, even if I was dating another girl. But I've always been totally and diligently monogamous, so I could not pursue those desires. I sometimes wonder how my dating life in high school would have gone if I had not developed my relationship with The GirlFriend of this story. The main reason I didn't go on many dates with the other girls listed here, in spite of my obvious interest, was because I was really hooked on TGF. But she was not equally hooked on me, and as I said, she would periodically insist that we not see each other for a while, and in those times I might ask some other girl on a date, but without fail, within a month TGF and I would be back together. But then the cycle would repeat itself. Had that not been the case, I probably would have been much more direct in pursuing my interests at my own HS.
Dadman
I found The Hot Chick doing some googling. Drop me a line if you want me to send you her contact information....
CosmicConservative
Heh, no thanks, as I said, she wasn't really even an acquaintance of mine.