Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

What now?

By CosmicConservative
OK, so I've spent a night of bitter introspection on the Health Care debacle. I can't say that my analysis and contemplation has given me any real boost in spirit, but it has allowed me to look over the corpse-strewn Health Care battlefield and there are some positives to glean, and a lesson for moving forward. Obama did get his bill, and it's a horrible bill. But there are some portions that are likely to get overturned by the SCOTUS. In particular I expect the mandate for everyone to be forced into buying health care to be a bitter battle in the SCOTUS and it could go either way, so that battle still has to be fought. Several states are challenging the unfunded mandates that this bill dumps on the states as well. And the abortion debate will only grow more contentious as Obama's Executive Order and the bill's mandate for health professionals to perfrom abortions regardless of their conscience are tested in court. So there are battles yet to be fought and there are some slight victories in the battle that are worth noting. Most importantly is the lack of an overt government single-payer system, which still remains the Democrat's real goal. Yes this puts us far closer to such a system, but we're not there yet, and as long as we aren't there, we can still fight to not get there. But more importantly, conservatives must remain energized to oppose Obama's remaining agenda items, most notably the upcoming Cap & Trade legislation. In this case at least we have the fact that the House has passed a version but the Senate has not, and Republicans can effectively filibuster that to stop it from becoming law. And we have the November elections. Instead of despair, we conservatives need to convert our anger and outrage over the Health Care debacle into effective efforts to support conservative candidates in key House and Senate elections in November. The fight is not over, and this setback should only strengthen our resolve to resist further incursions into our rights and liberties. As bad as it is, it could have been much worse, and there are still many areas where it could get worse still. Hang in there folks, the game is not over, and the loss of a battle does not necessarily mean the loss of a war.

Comments (15)

Old Goat
I just don't have any faith left in our government. I don't care if the Dhimmicrats are voted out in huge numbers come November, we have lost the Republic. The Usurper in Chief will hold on to power, heck, he'll probably just sign an executive order making dictator for life. What would make that any different than his "Stupak EO"? Nothing. Yes, there will be token fights, but the Republicans won't strike this mess down till its far too late to save the USA. If they even do it then.
esox67
"Republicans can effectively filibuster that to stop it from becoming law" I thought the Senate Democrats changed the voting rules so only 51 votes are needed ???
CosmicConservative
esox, if they did that, I missed it. I would be surprised to discover such a huge shift in Senate politics could occur without me noticing it, but maybe I did. Senate Democrats, much like House Democrats, have been playing fast and loose with procedural issues to avoid the potential for a filibuster, but so far as I know, despite the success of those blatantly unconstitutional activities in the House, the Senate has so far not been able to game their rules effectively to shut out the Republicans.
esox67
I thought they did because of Scott Brown, but perhaps a couple RINO's have already defected to the dark side and there is no need or Brown himself has. I thought this was set as part of reconciliation.
CosmicConservative
As I understand it, reconciliation itself is a process that requires only a majority vote. But reconciliation is, by rule, restricted to portions of a bill that are purely budget or revenue related. If I recall the Senate Republicans asked for and were given a ruling by the Senate Parliamentarian casting significant doubt that reconciliation could resolve the differences between the House and Senate versions of the bill. But I may be wrong. Unless I am mistaken the Senate will take up the bill tomorrow and we'll see the first efforts to use reconciliation and how the Senate Parliamentarian rules. Even if they do use reconciliation on this bill, that's only this one bill. All the existing Senate rules are still in effect for all other bills as far as I know. Reconciliation can't be used for Cap and Trade because the Senate never passed a version of the bill in the first place.
Old Goat
I'm not quite so convinced that these thugs are going to stop with health care. They have shown a willingness to disregard the Constitution and the public to pass this thing. Heck, they are trying to have Executive Orders now over turn law (at least if Stupid, err, Stupak is to be believed) and create law. Are we that far away from Herr Obama declaring something by Executive Order stopping elections? I wouldn't put anything past these thugs. There is also the exhaustion of having fought against this horror of a bill, only to lose. Meanwhile the thieves got away with it. Which side do you think is energized? Certainly not the Republicans, even if they are fired up and angry, there is burn out to be concerned with. These Dhimmicrats don't care. They will have their way regardless of the rules or some silly little piece of paper like the Constitution. If armed conflict were to start up tomorrow, though, I would be first in line. I fear it may come to that. Its that bad.
Janelle
I really like this post! You are 100%! We felt despair but now we will be loud and strong. Don't tread on me! I am fired up to win the war sir! God Bless You and the USA!!!
Dadman
In terms of the November elections, the Dem victory on this health care bill could work against a Republican landslide. The libsters will now have something to protect with their votes which will no doubt get more of them out to the polls. Expect the Dems to use this as a political rallying cry... Conservatives need to stay engaged and resolve to vote out as many Democrats as possible in the November election. If they are successful, and some semblance of checks and balances is restored to Congress, I think we might witness a conservative ascendency in America similar to what we saw with Reagan... ...if the right candidate emerges. A big if I'm afraid.
Andy
Cosmic, I could be wrong, but I am hearing that Biden can just overrule the Senate Parliamentarian on any ruling he makes. I believe the plan is to go the 51 vote route. But what do I know? Other than that the whole thing is a mess.
CosmicConservative
I think you're right Andy, and with this bunch they would probably have no shame and let Biden do just that. But as other people than me have pointed out, Democrats are setting a series of dangerous precedents that Republicans will be sure to exploit when (if) they ever regain power.
Old Goat
Hey, maybe the Republicans can make Obama and the Democrats illegal through this type of method. Its nice to dream, but these thugs don't care. Watch for cancellation of elections to be next.
Drax
As I indicated many times, many Democrats will have made the political choice that, of the two choices (yea or nay) the only one which offered any political shelter was to vote "yea." We'll see if that was a good choice or not in about 8 months. In the interim, the Republicans have to get educated. We CANNOT allow the Demorats to frame the debate. Is it "good" that insurance companies can no longer cancel your insurance if you get sick? Is it "good" that insurance companies can no longer limit the amount that they will pay for either yearly or over the life of your contract? Is it "good" that insurance companies can no longer turn you down if you have a pre-existing condition? If the debate is framed in this manner, concentrating on those "feel good" provisions of the law, then the Republicans LOSE the debate. They better have the answers to those questions because you can be DAMN sure that the Demorats will attempt to frame the debate in this fashion.
esox67
The problem is the answer to all those questions is that only the socialists are stupid enough to think that the government will be any different. They will limit services also, but I guess people will feel good about hearing that from their congreessman. Who will they complain to then ??? Idiots. Maybe if people READ their insurance contract they would know the limits of the policy they are paying for, NOT some unlimited slush fund that covers any operation, any condition, or any sickness they come down with. Not even our government who uses our tax money to buy votes with programs like this will be able to afford this. (We are now Greece) Evidently having your cake and eating it too is still alive in american politics.
Drax
Understand. It is a moral imperative that people who need health care receive it, regardless of their ability to pay. Any other thinking is to say that one's health is dependent upon one's social/economic status which is simply unacceptable. There IS no compelling moral argument to the contrary. THAT is the argument that the Republicans will have to overcome as, over the next months, they attempt to repeal this monstrosity.
esox67
Well, I wanted to buy a new Ranger Boat with a 200 HP Verado engine, but for some reason I could not afford it, so I did the right thing and did not buy it. Maybe the government should try the same thing with new programs s using real accounting methods to project costs. The same people using Drax's argument have no problem not defending our country with a strong military. What good it is to have health care with no security. Pretty much the same ones who balance local budgets by cutting police and fire departments. I do not want the government running my life cradle to grave, but that is just me.