Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Miers redux

By CosmicConservative
I have attempted to stay out of the Miers thing, there's enough going on that is bad for Republicans right now without this self-inflicted immolation over Miers. Up until now I have tried to remain more or less neutral on the need to confirm Miers, although I do believe the nomination was a disastrous political miscalculation. But once nominated my position has been "let's see how she does in the hearings." But the more I learn about her meetings with Senators and her weak and incomplete answers to some pretty basic constitutional questions, the more concerned I am about the hearings themselves exascerbating the political damage that has already been done. I suppose it is too late to ask, and it is probably unlikely to occur, but I am now officially in the anti-Miers camp. I don't want to see her defeated in a confirmation hearing so I hope she will withdraw herself from consideration thereby allowing GW Bush to save face and appoint a more credible person to the SCOTUS. My main reason for deciding not to support Miers as a SCOTUS justice regardless is my fear that her written opinions will not provide the clarity of conservative thought that can win converts in law school, even when the case at hand is lost. I believe it is imperative that conservatives on the court be able to write opinions that appeal to the rational mind and use steel-trap logic as much as possible. After reading what little there is written by Miers, I am afraid that I don't believe her to be up to that task. If I could write the script on this, I would write it this way. Get two or three conservative Senators on the Judiciary Committee to publicly request documents that they know will not be coming from the White House. When the White House refuses and Miers is caught in the middle, she can plausibly claim that her nomination puts the Executive and Legislative branches at an impasse and for that reason she is stepping down. This is good also because it will set a precedent that will discourage future Presidents from nominating their own counsel in the future.

Comments (2)

CosmicConservative » Joining the blog poll on Miers
[...] I oppose the Miers nomination. My reasons are listed below in a post from this weekend. [...]
CosmicConservative » Harriet Miers resigns
[...] This is pretty close to what I had hoped for. Particularly this comment: “If I could write the script on this, I would write it this way. Get two or three conservative Senators on the Judiciary Committee to publicly request documents that they know will not be coming from the White House. When the White House refuses and Miers is caught in the middle, she can plausibly claim that her nomination puts the Executive and Legislative branches at an impasse and for that reason she is stepping down. This is good also because it will set a precedent that will discourage future Presidents from nominating their own “ [...]