Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Tyranny of Good Intentions

By CosmicConservative
As the Health Care battle enters its end game, we are seeing a lot of last minute changes and jockeying for position on both sides of the debate. Obama has finally played a decent political card (his first) on this by releasing a new bill from the White House (as opposed to letting Nancy Pelosi or Harry Reid write it) which incorporates a couple of good Republican ideas and which whittles down the scope of the bill enough that it will certainly get the attention of an Olympia Snowe in the Senate. I don't know whether to be pleased that our President has actually shown that he has at least heard a whisper of the complaints of the American people, or dismayed at the prospect that Obama may actually be learning something about how things work in Washington. Still, I haven't seen the text of Obama's new bill, but it does have the possibility of being a game changer simply because it would likely be treated as a new bill instead of some effort to use reconciliation. I don't see how something that radically different from what is in the current House or Senate bills could fall under the "reconciliation" rules. One of the provisions that appears to still be in Obama's new bill though is the criminalization of people who choose not to purchase health care. I won't support any bill that has the potential to foment armed insurrection in this country, so I'm still opposed to it. And that brings me to the concept of the Tyranny of Good Intentions. Why would any President or political party in America propose and turn into law anything so blatantly opposed to this nation's founding principles? The "logic" of the Left is that health care is a shared responsibility that everyone in the country owns a piece of. In other words, from the perspective of the Left your neighbor's health care is absolutely your problem. This is because they consider it to be a basic human responsibility to share the load for the health care of others. This is so deeply ingrained in their world view that they literally cannot see how anyone could object to the concept without being a literally evil person. And so, because they believe it is self-evident that everyone should pitch in to share the overall health care burden, they have no problem making criminals of those who disagree. This is the same logic that says that using incandescent light bulbs is a "crime against humanity" and therefore prosecutable. It's the same logic that says that people need to be protected against their own eating habits. All of this is for your own good. The fact that it is the very definition of tyranny is something they quite literally don't care about. It's good tyranny after all.

Comments (9)

Drax
It doesn't matter what good ideas it has in it. If there is a framework for a federal bureaucracy which has any control over any health care and/or insurance, then, eventually it will crowd out private health care and/or insurance. The only "good ideas" are ones in which the government gets the hell out of the way. Those good ideas are utterly inconsistent and incompatible with any governmental bureaucracy, so, even if there are what COULD be "good ideas," those ideas will flounder and be consumed by the ravenous appetite of bureaucrats who have no other function than perpetuating their existence.
CosmicConservative
Drax, my point was that Obama doesn't have to convince you or me, only Olympia Snowe, and he may now have actually played a card that might achieve that. This is the first example I've seen in his entire Presidency that he is beginning to understand how to play the game. That is totally apart from whether or not I agree with the bill or not. That's why I titled this "The Tyranny of Good Intentions". I should have been clearer that good intentions or not, it's still tyranny.
Drax
I understand. I disagree pretty heartily, however. Remember, he PASSED Cap & Trade in the House. Remember, he PASSED Health Care in the House came within 1 vote (due to the DEATH of an absolute CERTAIN vote of PASSING health care (insurance) take-over. Remember, he has gotten EVERY PENNY that he has asked for up until now. Every one. It is only now that he HAS to cajole and woo that he is making this meager attempt to do so.
CosmicConservative
Hmmm. You are using the same examples to show how effective Obama has been that I would use to demonstrate how ineffective he's been. He didn't get "his" bill passed by either body for either cap n trade or health care. He let Pelosi pass what she wanted and Reid pass what he wanted and the end result was endless wrangling and no combined bill in either case. His incompetence was exposed when Kennedy died, that's all. Had Kennedy survived all that means is that Obama may have been successful in spite of his incompetence. To use a sports metaphor, nobody thinks Barry Switzer was a competent coach, but he won a Superbowl due to the team Jimmy Johnson built. Obama was playing with a huge advantage in numbers and still couldn't get the job done. If he knew anything about how to get legislation actually signed into law, we'd have had health care "reform" 8 months ago.
esox67
Good intentions will always be pleaded for every assumption of authority. It is hardly too strong to say that the Constitution was made to guard the people against the dangers of good intentions. There are men in all ages who mean to govern well, but they mean to govern. They promise to be good masters, but they mean to be masters. – Daniel Webster (1782-1852)
Foobarista
Two one-liners that I like about intentions... 1. Intentions are irrelevant. Only results matter. 2. The most damning three words in the English language are "they meant well".
esox67
Nothing like a good reminder from our Founding Fathers. You know the ones who thought it was important to have two legislative houses so that mob rule of one vote over 50 in the Senate would not rule the day. Just like the socialists running the show NOW, thought back in 2005 on judicial appointments.
Old Goat
We don't have a thing to worry about with this Health Care stuff. After all, just look at how well the Post Office is doing, while all the private mailing industries fail, the Post Office which is Government run is doing so well they are raising the rates while cutting back on services. Seems like a win - win there folks.