Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Dog and Pony Show (AKA the "Health Care Debate")

By CosmicConservative
So today the President deigned to descend from his azure throne and move among the heathen to demonstrate to the awed public how the intellectual confronts the bestial. Here's a link to the video. The final score from the reports I've seen from both sides is pretty much a draw. Obama scored some points, the Republicans scored some points. The only real loser in the room were the Democrats who have to face reelection this year. But the thing is, a draw is a huge political win for the Republicans. What strikes me most about this event is how decidedly un-Presidential Barack Obama is. I truly think that he has no idea what it means to be President. Presidents don't keep the clock in a debate. Presidents don't get into pissing contests with mere Representatives. Presidents don't try to mediate and dominate the same nationally publicized debate. Well, smart Presidents don't. Republicans did well today I think. They may not have done much to interfere with Obama's agenda, but they had no real chance of doing that anyway. But what they did on national television was appear rational, reasonable, intelligent, prepared and able to go toe-to-toe with Obama and battle to a draw. That's real bad for Democrats whose only strategy for the past decade has been to convince the gullible American people that Republicans are mouth-breathing, redneck, religious fundamentalist neanderthals. There's a reason the media skews the news the way they do, they want to promote that sort of image of Republicans. Republicans being normal, reasonable people who don't thump Bibles to make a point is an image a lot of people will literally be shocked by. Some fraction of those people today blinked and came away from the TV thinking "Huh... that's not what I thought a Republican was like." And that's not good for Democrats up for re-election who really have no other strategy to count on. Not good at all.

Comments (18)

Old Goat
The President came off arrogant as usual. His put down of the Republican, I forget who off hand, who was reading from the fricking bill, and calling it a prop should be played over and over again. The Zero and the Dims talked almost twice as long as the Republicans, and they came off as unwilling in most cases to be unwilling to work with the Republicans. This was set up by the BHOzo as a means of him being in a campaign. He failed. Trouble is how many even saw it? How many could stay awake for it? How many could just sit there listening to the crap being spewed out of various mouths without blowing up? I am sick of hearing politicians naming single cases of a tragic event for their own ends. Tort reform would go a long way toward curbing costs. I couldn't listen to a large portion of this farce. I did hear some saying why can't we work on getting the things we agree on into a bill and use that as a starting point. I saw some snips where the Zero looked down right pissed at what the republicans were saying. And he needed to be advised on how to answer. If he had a competent Vice President, that is who should have been running this farce.
CosmicConservative
Goat, I agree completely that it would have been more appropriate to have the VP run the show, but that still would have been a partisan act of image control, which is why Obama had to run it himself. A proper debate is mediated by an objective outsider. That Obama (or theVP) ran it proved that it was just a dog and pony show. But it was a show that Obama lost control of many times. And his anger is showing much more frequently now, and people are surprisingly quick to pick up on emotional cues, and many of his marginal fans will see this and come away with a lowered opinion of him. By the way, he was caught on camera actually picking his nose. Geez, I don't even know what to say about that. I don't even pick my nose in low-level corporate meetings.
Drax
It wasn't a "draw." It was a clear and convincing "win" for the Republicans. In addition to the diminution of the Presidency as you noted above, the Democrats came off as condescending and arrogant, letting the watching world know that they were going to ram it through anyway -- that this WAS just a show. But, more importantly, the Republicans presented reasonable and rational ideas which, for the most part, anyone who gets their "news" from the lame-stream media was exposed, for the first time, to Republican ideas. This not only highlighted the incredible differences between the parties, but showed the Democrats for the liars they are, i.e., their constant refrain that Republicans had no idea and were simply the "party of no." All in all, a good day for Republicans.
Old Goat
I've been frustrated for a long time with how the Republicans have been while they had the majority power, but seeing how things are when the Democrats are the majority is far worse than I imaged it would be. The people are (finally?) waking up to this administration and our government. There was a "shock" poll by CNN that showed 56% are afraid that Government has gotten too large and powerful and it threatens their rights. Only 25% in one poll showed that they want this healthcare bill passed. Watching the Dems vs. Repubs is like watching children vs. adults when it comes to the rhetoric and actions.
CosmicConservative
What I love is how people are more and more realizing how effective Bush was at getting things done in Washington.
Cullen
Doesn't matter how well we did, they're going to move forward with reconciliation anyway: Obama To GOP: It’s Over Obama listened politely for six hours, with occasional flashes of temper, but in the end, the message was clear: It’s over. We’re moving forward without Republicans. Whether Obama and Dems will succeed in passing reform on their own is anything but assured, to put it mildly. But there’s virtually no doubt anymore that they are going to try — starting as early as tomorrow. That was the subtle but unmistakable message of Obama’s closing argument. After hours of hearing Republicans repeat again and again that only an incremental approach to reform is acceptable to them, Obama rejected that out of hand.
Old Goat
Bush did get things done and that is in part what led to BDS. Obama really doesn't have a clue how to lead or be president. Not. A. Clue. I wonder how people with buyers remorse feel about their poor choice for a leader. I wonder even more about the idiots who keep running around with "We Did It" stickers on their cars... When I do come to a stop light and one of them is sitting next to me I roll down the window and ask them "How's that Hopey Changey working out for ya?" They don't answer. Which is an even bigger answer.
Cullen
I have a book that ranks presidents based on their effectiveness as an executive. Proabably one of the best readings about presidential power and arguably the best way to rate a good president.
Old Goat
Obama wasn't exactly polite during that farce. Flipping the bird, picking his nose, putting down a republican for using the printed out bill (which he was quoting from) as a prop. I wonder how "polite" Governor Patterson thinks the Zero is.
Cullen
Yeah, I think the author kind of used politely sarcastically.
Andy
What do you think will happen IF the dims do move forward and pass this thing through reconciliation? Just how far do you think the public will go to express outrage? Protests? Violence? Civil Disobedience? Serious question.
Drax
I don't know Andy, but the opposition to this is visceral and abiding.
Old Goat
There might be some protests, but the Dims have so much that won't take affect for years in this bill that it won't lead to much more than that till the people see for themselves what this has wrought. The divide in this country is sharpening.
CosmicConservative
I think that would cement the Tea Party movement as the most significant force in the 2010 elections.
Old Goat
CC, I'm not so sure. If the Tea Party was unable to stop this socialist take over of Health Care it could be a set back for the movement. Its hard to continue momentum like that for long as well. If they see they haven't influenced this important legislation it could go either way.
Andy
I guess I should have been more "personal" when asking my question. I do not have health insurance. I have not for about 20 years. I have paid for every single medical procedure that my family has required out of my own pocket in that time. I would REFUSE to buy health insurance. As I understand the bills that are proposed, I would be penalized for not doing so. I'll admit ignorance as to whether a physician would be penalized if they decided to treat me, or my wife, and our last son still at home because we don't have health insurance, but are willing to pay cash. I'm wondering just how small a minority I belong to. I'm wondering if there are hundreds of thousands, or maybe a few million folks just like me that would REFUSE. And, I'm wondering how many doctors would tell the Feds to "stuff it." And, I'm wondering what the response from ObozO's IRS, Justice Department, and Health Care Screw You Czar would be...toward resistors (patients, and physicians). I can see real trouble here. I can truly envision riots, local Sheriffs stepping in to stop Federal action, Governors pitching a shoe at DC, and bullets (real bullets) flying from both sides. Drax said, "...the opposition to this is visceral and abiding." He's right. I'd just as soon not see if this is the straw that breaks the camel's back. I hope it all goes away. But, in my lifetime, I haven't seen anything (no war, or issue) that has stirred the pot like this one (at least among sane people).
Old Goat
I can see legal moves being brought up against this. While these dims talk about car insurance, it isn't the same thing. You don't have to drive a car, driving is considered a privilege not a "right". I find it mind boggling that so much of this would come into effect after the Zero is out of office as well. If its as all fired important as they are saying it is, why isn't it being enacted right away? Off topic, but man it seems there have been more substantial earthquakes lately. I wonder if its that the quake from one place causes a weakness in another place to be exposed.