Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Peak Oil, another alarmist exaggeration

By CosmicConservative
One of the reasons I'm such a committed and avowed skeptic about pretty much everything is because virtually every doomsday prediction I've ever seen has been bogus. I've had long drawn-out arguments with "Peak Oil" proponents for almost fifteen years. Their claim is that we are always on the verge of a "tipping point" where the world will run out of oil virtually overnight. And every year the actual proven reserves seem to grow, not shrink, and that's not even taking into account the ability to convert coal to oil or to extract oil from the virtually endless supply of oil shale, oil sands and other unconventional sources of oil.
Exxon Mobil (XOM) announced today that in 2009 the company's proven reserves increased by 133% of the amount of oil produced. Exxon now has 23.3 billion oil-equivalent-barrels of reserves comprised of about half liquids and half gas. It's the largest amount in the company's history. via Exxon Hits Peak Oil... Reserves.
And yet Peak Oil proponents will continue to scream "the sky is falling" and accuse Exxon and Mobile of lying about their reserves as if it is in the best interest of oil companies to pump themselves out of business as fast as they possibly can.

Comments (12)

Drax
Well, two possibilities: Either what oil that exists is all that will ever (naturally) exist or nature continues to make oil. If the first is true, then, if we keep using it, we'll run out of oil eventually. If the second is true, then we may run out eventually (if use outstrips creation). Either way, prudence would seem to demand that, if civilization depends upon oil, then we do what we can to ration its use. At least until we find an alternative to its use. (I guess we can make it now, but not economically...so, maybe we've already found the "alternative...")
Old Goat
The thing about oil that puzzles me is how was it ever determined that it came from dinosaurs? At least that is what I've always heard and been taught. Given that, how is it that some known oil supplies are growing and causing problems because they are leaking out into the ocean or fields? Also, why only dinosaurs can produce oil and not the decaying animals and humans and plants of today? While the construct of our bodies are different, and theirs were obviously much larger, you would think the volume of animals and humans would make up the difference. Didn't Germany use a good deal of synthetic oil during WWII? I thought I read that in past but could be "mis-remembering". There are alternative oils out there, but they don't last nearly as long. Vegetable oils can probably be produced to match viscosity needs, but they break down faster and go rancid. Oil is also able to be recycled to an extent, but it isn't done as much due to costs. It just seems that there are always "new" oil locations that are found, and that makes me think oil is consistently created rather than it being a finite supply.
CosmicConservative
Goat, I'm not a geologist, but I do know a bit about the processes that are theorized to generate oil. It's not just dinosaurs, there are oil fields that are from other periods of earth history. Oil is (theoretically) produced when a large area of highly concentrated organic material is buried under a sealed layer which prevents oxidation while also leading to tremendous heat and pressure. It just so happens that a lot of that was laid down during periods when dinosaurs were the dominant land animals. But there are significant dissenting opinions on the origin theories of oil. There is a vocal minority of geologists who claim that oil is a natural mineral, generated through geologic processes which don't require the crushing of entire ecosystems. According to those theories oil is a natural byproduct of plate tectonics and the geochemical processes that occur deep in the crust and in the mantle. Discoveries of complex hydrocarbons in vast quantities in clouds of space dust provide some support for those theories. Regardless of whether there is new oil being generated, the reality is that we still have vast areas of the world that have not been explored for oil drilling, including most of the Arctic and Antarctic. A little known fact is that US oil reserves which have been deemed off-limits by Congress are comparable to the oil reserves in the middle east. We just can't drill or explore them. We're not running out of oil any time soon.
CosmicConservative
Drax, I have in the past pointed out that the USA decision to not drill oil and instead to import oil can be seen as a long-term strategic ploy to eventually corner the market on the remaining oil in case we can't come up with an alternative. I am all in favor of conserving what we can and working diligently to provide alternate sources of fuel, but my point in this post is that we are not remotely near any "tipping point" with oil, and there is no sign that we will reach that point for decades. I'm pretty confident that within a few decades we won't be using gas or diesel as our primary transportation fuel.
Drax
CC: I agree. Even with India and China becoming members of the "1st World," I doubt that the rate of consumption will deplete oil reserves for much longer than it takes to figure out how to run cars on water ... or something...
Andy
I am now, and have always been a believer in the abiotic oil theory. The old fields continue to replenish themselves. The seas are awash in oil...bubbling up from the ocean floor. The earth is making it. I am the dullest pencil in the box, but I have read a gazillion articles, a couple of dozen books, and The Enquirer. The earth is making it...not dead dinosaurs, or trapped organic material. What we were taught as youngsters was a full truck-load of dookie. That being said, I'm a big HOPER when it comes to fuel from water, efficient wind power, solar power, hydroelectric, "steam from the earth power (I can't remember right now what it's called), wave power, and of course Nukular! Whatever works cheaply is cool with me. But, I doubt we'll ever run out of oil. The earth is making it. So, we'd better get busy about drilling for more of it. I have also always believed that we are heading in to another ice age. We're gonna need the fuel to stay warm...probably for centuries.
kevin in WI
I think you guys are missing something here. Please note that Exxon is referring to their total reserves, which are both liquid and gas (i.e. oil and natural gas). Thanks to new "unconventional gas" (i.e. horizontally drilled gas from oil shale deposits), the reserves of natural gas are going through the roof. I watched a panel of global oil leaders at the world economic summit (on CSPAN - thank insomnia), and they were in unanimous agreement that the energy future of North America has been totally changed thanks to "unconventional natural gas". They were also divided on whether they will be able to increase oil production over the next 20years as will be needed. Basically, they need to add 20mil barrels a day to global production, while replacing about 35mil barrels a day of declining production. We're not at peak oil yet, but increasing supply is getting much harder (it basically comes down to tripling Iraq, adding Brazil, and adding 50% to Saudi output. Exxon's announcement is a bit of a shell game (no pun intended). Total reserves are way up, but oil reserves not so much.
kevin in WI
I guess the best way to summarize what I said above is: We may be pushed hard to keep oil production up with demand, but thanks to natural gas, there is no energy shortage in our future.
CosmicConservative
Kevin, you're correct, the new techniques for horizontal drilling for natural gas have opened up vast new reserves of natural gas which are coincidentally more or less situated right underneath the nations existing gas distribution system, so it's not only available, it's available right now, and will be available anywhere in the nation that we need natural gas. However I will challenge your comments on oil. Yes we are not seeing oil reserves in drillable locations increase that much in the United States. However there have been major new oil reserves discovered just recently in the Gulf of Mexico, in the Arctic and off the coast of Brazil. On top of that, known oil reserves in the non drillable areas in the USA are close to matching the known reserves in all of the middle east. The USA has the oil. The oil companies are forbidden by law from listing known reserves in areas mandated as un-drillable by Congress. We've got the oil, Congress just won't let us drill for what we have, or look for new fields. This is a conscious decision by Democrats to force the issue on other forms of energy, and it is my belief that a lot of savvy Republicans are going along with it because the long term result is that the USA will have a strategic advantage in oil production when the reserves outside of the USA eventually are depleted. If they ever are.