Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Gooble is unfair

By CosmicConservative
So I've been sorta idly wondering for a while why Andy's Place seems to get so much google linkage when my own blog has been around much longer and gets very little google traffic in comparison. I suspected that perhaps Google was favoring it's own product since Andy's blog is on Blogspot (also known as "Blogger") which is a blog farm owned by Google.
Been joining several SEO contests in the last couple of years and only recently did I noticed that Google seems to be giving favors to its own products and services. Take for example YouTube. When it was not yet bought by Google, you don’t see videos in the search results. But now, just look at the Google search results. via Does Google favor its own? (BlogSpot) | YugaTech | Philippines, Technology News & Reviews.
I wasn't really upset about this since I long ago stopped trying to compete with the big blogs, but the more I think about this, the more angry I get. Google loves to swagger around bragging about how moral and right they are (let's ignore that little thing about helping China censor it's own citizens for a minute here, just stick with me) and all the time they are funneling traffic from their monolithic search engine into their own blogs instead of indexing existing non-Google blogs. I mean seriously, how lame is that? The Gooble is evil.

Comments (7)

Andy
Cosmic, The Gooble is not just unfair, and evil. It's WAY WRONG! Seriously! Probably 90% of The Gooble searches that land at my place have absolutely nothing to do with what the searcher is obviously looking for. I have wondered about this, too. And, you are probably right. Feeding the "homefolks" is probably good business. And, if I understand correctly, The Gooble is one of the few corporations that is still increasing in value. Still, my traffic is puny compared to most...probably 1/3 of yours. But, I know where you're coming from.
Andy
And oh, btw...one reason Gooble searchers discover useless content when they land at my place is because that's all there is. ;)
Andy
Cosmic, one more thing, and I'm finished for the night. I truly have been fascinated by, and have tried to wrap my brain around the way that The Google search works. A couple of other bloggers that I know on "Blogger" also have experienced similar curiosity. It seems that Google search tends to pick up the constants that are in the sidebar. For example, I have "nigger lover" in my sidebar. I get untold hits from people searching for something to do with "yada yada yada nigger." The search result will send them to a page with the "yada yada yada," yet the highlighted words in the search will contain the "nigger lover" from the sidebar. That's not the only sidebar word that gets picked up. But, you get my drift. Also (and my other Blogger friends have noted this, too), The Google search seems to pick up keywords in Blogger comments. I noticed that since I went from getting 0 to 2 comments a day...to a healthy 10 to 20 or so...that some of the searches done actually pick up the "comment content," and shuffle a searcher to that blog post (whether it's relevant to what they are looking for or not). It probably has a lot to do with, as you theorize...and the linked article does, The Gooble weighing results toward their own product. Just thought I'd throw that at you.
CosmicConservative
Andy, I actually know a fair bit about how the google search engine works. I used to work for a company that was building its own relevant search model. On top of that we worked with a couple of specialized Search Engine Marketing firms who provided us with their rules for optimizing google search results. Here are some things that you may or may not know. Google is context sensitive. Among other things that means if you have a word in large type, bolded and italicized, it ranks higher on google's relevency. Second, Google uses a plain english filter to rank higher words or phrases used in a plain english manner. In other words if you have the word "anchovy" on your site it will rank higher if it is in a sentence like "I hate anchovies." Third, Google searches through your site's meta tags looking for what you WANT your site to look like to Google. So if you have meta tags that are reinforced by the organic search results, you rank even higher. Fourth, Google looks for links to a page from other pages. Pages that are linked from higher ranked pages rank higher in the search results. (which may actually be the "technical" reason that Google's own blogs rank higher, they are all linked from Google itself). There's a lot more. Google publishes a lot of this. But what they don't publish is reverse-engineered on a monthly basis by Search Engine Marketing and Search Engine Optimization companies. One thing I'm lazy about is not filling in all the details on images I put on my site, and that hurts me on search results too.
Andy
Interesting Cosmic. I've read a good bit about SEO...but it was a LONG time ago. And,I knew that you were hip to SEO stuff from previous conversations. I definitely believe that your point about Google's own linked-to blogs would likely get higher rankings in their searches.
Andy
Cosmic...just curious. Do you get hits from "googlebot" Simi Valley, CA?