Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Steven Hawking says space colonization essential

By CosmicConservative
I have to say I put this in the "duh" category. We either stay on this planet and run out of non-renewable resources until we revert to some agrarian sustainable existence model while we wait for some cosmic catastrophe to destroy the world, or else we move into space, exploit the resources there, and hopefully colonize new worlds where we spawn new environmental movements to protect all the species we will endanger on the new planets we inhabit. Given the choice, I pick B. But that's just me.

Comments (18)

Brian
You're not the only one who picks 'b' But it's nice when guys like Hawking come out and say so. He's not just a smart guy, he's famous. Now, if only Tom Hanks would get on the bandwagon more publicly, then we'd see some traction (grin).
CosmicConservative
Heh, Tom Hanks or maybe Julia Roberts. Hopefully not Tom Cruise though...
Drax
I have always viewed our Earthly existence as an "egg" type existence. We either choose to suck the resources slowly and die here eventually, or we suck them up at a time when there is both sufficient technology and resources to "crack the egg" and be reborn in space.
CosmicConservative
Drax: That approach raises the possibility that we have limited chances to leave the nest. If we squander our resources unwisely then we could reach a point that no matter how badly we want to colonize space, we simply won't have the resources to do so at some point. This is, in fact, my personal belief. We may only have a window of a few hundred years to colonize space before it becomes economically and technically unfeasible to do so. It will be very hard to justify major expenditures for exploiting the asteroid belt, for instance, if we are desperately trying to keep 12 billion people from starving to death.
Brian
Hopefully not Tom Cruise though… You can't always pick your friends.
CosmicConservative
You can pick your friends. You can pick your nose. But you can't pick your friend's nose.
Drax
Which, of course, is why I said: "at a time when there is both sufficient technology and resources." This implies nothing more than what it says, as there could be countless times when both of those variables exist. The longer we wait, however, expending non-renewable resources on ... whatever ... the fewer windows there may ultimately be. However, as technology progresses, it may become possible to do more with less, using, perhaps, renewable resources (solar sails or some such) to expand into space. I'm personally of the opinion that, in order to do this, that we have to get our Earthly house in order. We have to get population expansion under control, eliminate the likelihood of global war, eliminate hunger on a global scale, etc. I don't really believe that, unless we get our house in order, there will ever be the political will to expend the insanely huge amount of resources, and will likely require a global effort, both in human and natural resources, to effect this goal. Dunno if we'll ever get there.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I'm not convinced that it is critical to "get our earthly house in order" first. There is no technical reason that we couldn't build the infrastructure for space colonization while half the world is embroiled in total war. Not that I expect that to come to pass, but the truth is that such a war itself could accelerate space exploitation simply because of the strategic advantage a space station could provide one side or the other. Actually I don't think, upon reflection, that the window of space colonization is really measured in centuries. It is probably measurable in thousands or even tens of thousands of years. If fusion energy is ever mastered, then the window expands enormously. Still, it feels like we need to get moving. One rogue asteroid and mankind is over. Even if we colonize a few other planets or moons in the solar system it is not too hard to conceive of a cosmic disaster that could impact the entire solar system. Say a nearby supernova sends a highly radioactive magnetron (a neutron star with a magnetic field millions of times stronger than the sun) through the inner planets. It is conceivable that such an encounter could sterilize the entire inner solar system. The sooner we spread across the local star systems, the better. The sooner we colonize the local spiral arms, the better. The sooner we colonize the entire galaxy, the better. Have Spacesuit, Will Travel.
Drax
Cosmic: I agree that it should be possible from a resource/technology perspective to get into space even though our house isn't "in order," perhaps even by a single country...or perhaps one of the ever-growing corporations. However, I just don't think that there will be the political WILL to do so if, say, we have to spend enormous sums on defense, intelligence, or whatever. Or, when there are whole nations out there which cannot feed their own people. Maybe the most likely scenario, in the short term, IS for a huge corporation to "go for the gold" and attempt to control the resources of outer space, as whoever does it first will reap enormous wealth, and corporations don't have to worry about such things as defense...feeding Africa's/Asia's children, but concentrate solely on the potential profit. Dunno....but, it is something which should be debated at a national/global level sooner rather than later.
CosmicConservative
It's all about the Space Elevator, man.
Brian
Drax: However, I just don’t think that there will be the political WILL to do so if, say, we have to spend enormous sums on defense, intelligence, or whatever. Or, when there are whole nations out there which cannot feed their own people. There doesn't _need_ to be any political will. Just an absense of (snark) political won't. Ram the cost of space access down and it's like emmigrating to Australia. Expensive, and it's a long long way from home but doable by families or charted comanies. Cosmic: It’s all about the Space Elevator, man. Oh, so no pressure then. There are other ways to get CATS. We might not be able to get an SE to work, for that matter. Better to work on a variety of means to get up there so we don't stick all of our orbital eggs in a single basket. Plus a mature infrastructure has a variety of ways to accomplish the mundane task of moving stuff. I can FedEx a letter and ship coal on a train. I can drive or fly to Chicago. Etc. Competition is healthy, if (from my POV) potentialy annoying. Plus birds like SS1 look so darn pretty. I'd hate to give that up.
Aaron
Perhaps in the longest run, it's true. Disasters of ever greater magnitude occur ever less frequently, but still it's nonzero. But I don't think we're running out of anything important, other than oil. Everything else either grows back, or is never "expended" to begin with (just piled in a junkyard). As long as you have a primary energy source, you can recycle just about anything else - it's just a matter of chemical engineering. Nuclear power could concievably fill that bill for many thousands of years. Still, stagnation sucks. Politically, culturally, and opportun-(umm..)-istically. I'm sure there are many people that would rather we stagnate, so that they can "organize" society according to their visions and plans. (When the prey populations stagnate, the predators take over, and then a general collapse occurs...) Expanding into space is one way to ensure that there is an accessible frontier around for a very long time. But there still does have to be a motive force. I don't think resources are going to cut it. All the chemical elements you could concievably pull from the moon or mars can be gotten from earth much more easily (even if we were forced to mine third or fourth rate deposits). If there were some unique manufacturing process that we could only do in space, there might be something there. But space mining for earth consumption won't be competitive unless mining the earth is flat-out outlawed (and attacked far more effectively than the drug trade ever will be).
Aaron
I touch on these objections I have to "the usual reasons" a bit on my blog.
CosmicConservative
Aaron: What you are saying is true for current consumption levels of raw materials for use here on earth. Let us start bulding fleets of space vehicles the size of small asteroids and mining the earth will be orders of magnitude more expensive than mining asteroids or moons. It may well be that mining earth deposits will always be more effective for using raw materials for earthly purposes, but mining iron on earth to build multiple-kilometer sized interstellar spaceships is just plain crazy when the materials you need are free for the taking right where you need them.
Aaron
I was talking about earthly consumption. Because it seems like it's regularly given as a reason to begin colonization. People on earth are going to be paying for the space colonies for a long time. They'll want some greater economic return for it on Earth, or you're back to where we are now - no one wanting to pay for it. Of course a space colony would want to mine space resources. But it has to provide something to Earth to be there in the first place. Don't quite know what that would be yet.
Aaron
Sorry about being a stick in the mud. I hope space colonization happens too - very much so as an astro-engineer!
Brian
But it has to provide something to Earth to be there in the first place. Don’t quite know what that would be yet. I am not an expert. But economic reasons are not the only reason for establishing a colony. Mercantile reasons were one of the drivers for colonizing North America but not the only one. The Puritans found life in England intolerable so they left to found a city on the hill, but still tied to an Atlantic civilization. Later, Anglo-Celt borderers came, moved through the coastal screen and over the Appilachans and left civilization behind. I can see the same thing happening now. A disaffected political and religous minority, tired of seeing their middle-class privleges come under attack and eroded might decide that a New America on Mars is preferable to the altenative.
CosmicConservative
Brian: I think there is a real possibility that colonization will be driven more by social pressure than by economic opportunity. Although I do also believe that there will be economic opportunities in space beyond simply mining raw materials. Some of it will be that in space you will be able to create materials in micro-gravity that cannot be made on earth. Some of it will likely be that we'll discover some minerals that are unique to comets or asteroids and that has some commercially valuable properties. If we build a large space telescope and use it to discover an earth-like planet around a nearby star (say within 50 light years) then I believe that space travel will get the kind of boost that we saw with the U.S. westward expansion of the 19th century. It will become an exodus.