Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

So sick of "green"

By CosmicConservative
I am so sick of "green." I've pretty much decided not to buy any product or service that I can do without if they advertise "green" nonsense. Energy companies are among the worst, but perhaps the single example of "green" advertising that really makes me snarl is the IBM campaign "building a smarter planet." The sheer opportunistic disengenuousness of the campaign is breathtaking. I guess all the PR specialists have focus group evidence that pretty much forces companies to flaunt their illusory "green" credentials. But as for me, it just makes me want to barf. Much as I have to ask how the American people can be so gullible that they elected Barack Obama to the nation's highest public office, I have to ask if those same American people are so gullible that they'll believe the hyperbole that advertising firms spew about companies whose only commitment to "green" solutions is the bare minimum needed to make a grab for as many government handouts as they can get their hands on. I haven't done an actual count, but my anecdotal analysis based on my limited TV viewing is that at least half of the ads on TV have some claim to "green-ness" from companies as disparate as fast food and airline companies. But even worse are all the kids shows and documentaries I see where "green" ideology is pushed like a drug. Disney may be the worst, but I'm sure "worst" is a hard title to claim right now. There is no surer way to turn me off from a TV show or an advertisement than to spew some "green" nonsense that is clearly nothing but allegience to the current politically correct mantra by people whose actual awareness of environmental impact is roughly equivalent to that of a single-celled flatworm. Just one more reason I don't watch TV. But unfortunately, more and more often in my casual web surfing, I find the same messages shoved in my face by flash advertisements and other things which are already pissing me off even before they start preaching green nonsense at me. Ug...

Comments (15)

mtnlurker
It always makes me laugh when I see a gas station or grocery store say that they are powered by some percentage of wind power or some other "green" technology. I am sure that the power company sold them a bill of goods so that the company could say they were wind powered. How do they know where the electrons came from. What a rip.
CosmicConservative
mtn: They claim that because they are charged a surcharge to make that claim. And that surcharge is supposed to be applied by the energy company to the distribution of the higher priced "green" energy. THEORETICALLY they can't claim to sell more "green" than they produce, but I would be willing to bet real "green" that nobody checks.
Andy
Cosmic, it's enveloping us. But, I have a feeling that the onslaught of it all will turn so many people off that it will subside. I mean, you've got GE (which was once a great American company), and GM, and youknoweverybodyelse...even WalMart planting gardens on the top of their new stores and bragging that they are "green." I share your chunk-blow with all of it. Pam loves to watch the "home improvement, fix this old house, turn a dump into a fortune" shows on Saturday morning. I swear, 95% of the ads are touting how "green" the manufacturer of some paint, or plywood, or toilet is...and OF COURSE, their retailers are too! I'm hanging on to hope that just as the public has put "global warming/climate change" far down their list of worries, this "green" crap will subside. I could be wrong, but I believe that "overkill" is the worst enemy of a cause.
Dadman
The 'green' hype we are presently witnessing reminds me a lot of what was going on in the 70s. 'Green' sentimentality was big 30+ years ago. Remember the crying injun and the anti-DDT hysteria (which has led to the early demise of perhaps millions of human beings... but that's a another story) I suspect we'll see this latest round of universal green obsession run out of gas (pun intended) like it did in the 80s. 'Green' hype is destined to be cyclical, because it's simply not practical at this point in time. Tossing cookies with you... And, by the way, how dare you disparage our friends the Flatworms.
Cullen
I think a lot of companies do it because if they put the "Green" stamp on some products they can charge twice as much for a product that works less than half as well - laundry soap and dishwashing detergent are the worst offenders I can think of off the top of my head. As for children's programming, I'm not opposed to teaching/reinforcing being a responsible consumer/steward of our resources. It's the Big-Brother-esque "Get your parents involved." "Make sure they're recycling." "Talk to your parents about cutting your water use!" How much further do you have to go before it's "Report violators to the Energy Enforcers!"
Andy
Dadman...Yep, I remember the crying injun... If my memory serves me (which it usually does not), that was Iron Eyes Cody, in the Keep America Beautiful campaign. I could be wrong. I usually am. Actually, at that time pollution really had ravaged much of the urban population of America. And campaigns like that may have spurred some valuable public sentiment, govt. regulations, etc. But as you know...those concerns were based on concrete observations. Heck, people could see dead fish floating in rivers. This whole "green" movement these days is based on a fear of what "might happen," and it is putting enormous bucks in the pockets of the guys that orchestrate it (or at least play fiddle in the band).
Dadman
Andy: You highlight an important distinction. When environmmentalism was about clean air, clean water, conserving beautiful natural places, saving species on the brink of extinction, and the like, I was (usually) in complete support. Today, true conservationists have been replaced by anti-capitalist radicals with bare naked political agendas...and the foundation of their movement is based on bogus science and, as you point out, GREED. It truly is nauseating. Time to blow some chunks again...
Andy
Well said, Dadman! I was trying to say it like that, but I don't write so good... That thing about blowing chunks again just brought a tear to my eye. :) You are (we are) right! Dangit!!!
CosmicConservative
Like Dadman, I wholeheartedly supported environmentalism when it was about the environment. The bulk of environmentalism today is a thinly veiled form of Ludditism and atavism. Most of the rest who are somewhat rational are preservationists not environmentalists. It has been my experience for some time now that apart from a very few examples, the most effective and knowledgeable "environmentalists" are the hunters, fishermen and other outdoor enthusiasts who not only pay the fees which pay for most of the actual programs which protect the environment, but who volunteer their own valuable time to clean up national and state parks while the "urban environmentalists" as I like to call them leave piles of trash in their wake after every protest.
Keith S.
It's peaking now. I'm confident that in 1-2 years we'll look back on the green movement with the same quaintness of feathered hair and pet rocks.
Cosmic Daughter
These are the green people that forget global warming is cow gas -_-
ASEI
I'm anti-environmentalist. The sort of world I'm solving for is fundamentally different from what the environmentalists think they want. They want to starve civilization of energy, because having energy allows people to live lives they disapprove of. I want to ensure civilization has extremely abundant energy, because that is the only way we will be able to recycle and produce the resources needed to make everyone rich. A sustainable society is one that can afford to burn more, not less energy turning matter from waste back into resources. The environmentalists want to cull most of humanity and have the rest living pastoral lives in the countryside. I'd rather not return to the dark ages, and court eugenic/genocidal program having the political power to decide who gets to enjoy the sustainable future. I want to see us with the advantages that extremely energetic devices at our disposal provide - the ability to produce work, to automate production, to have transportation systems vastly more capable than anything at the level of solar/plant fibers/animals can provide. I'd rather build the infrastructure to support the people we have. When environmentalists look at a steel mill, or a chemical plant, or really anything that has a technological function, they see something ugly and evil. When I see them, I think they're beautiful expressions of human ingenuity, sources of our amazing wealth. Even the non-photogenic guts of a city, the water treatment facilities, the paper plants, ect, are necessary for the comfortable clean lives of the people milling about their campus-parks and office towers. Without them, their cities could not exist, most of them could not exist, and their beloved pastoral countryside would be paved with subsistence farms of the survivors.
CosmicConservative
So.. I was roaming the intrawebz the other day and came across an article on some magazine's blog about using algae to create biofuels, and how that was turning out to not be quite so "green" (pun intended). The comments were all from people saying how we needed biofuels to save the planet so I asked them how biofuels are going to helps us colonize the Solar System or get to Alpha Centauri. Didn't get no responses...