Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

First speeding ticket in seven years...

By CosmicConservative
Arg... I may challenge this one in court... I was coming out of an area of road construction and traffic was moving at 35mph in an area where it should have been going back to 55mph from 40mph. Turns out a cop was driving at 35mph and the construction zone "end construction" sign was a quarter mile from the actual end of construction. So I was accelerating to 55 when I passed the cop just before the end construction sign (maybe 50 yards before) and he nailed me for doing "56" in a 40mph zone.... I may challenge this both on the basis that the construction zone is clearly way too long after the construction area and that the cop was clearly deliberately driving under the speed limit to see if he could get someone to pass him. Cop must have been 12 years old... grumble grumble... $169 and 3 points....

Comments (13)

Old Goat
In NY even if you are found not guilty when fighting a traffic ticket you still have to pay for "court fees". My wife had one and got off, but the cost of the court fee was $150. It would have been $175 without fighting it. She also had to pay parking, $10, and take time off from work. If she had mailed it in and just paid the fine it would have been $25 plus the postage fee. Tell me that isn't robbery.
pace
So ahem... I have some experience in this in Colorado. You essentially have three options. 1. You take the 'I'm guilty' plea, and send your ticket and payment in. That will typically automatically reduce the penalty down to 2 points. 2. Go to court on the date printed on the back of the ticket. How it works in Jefferson County (not sure where you got pulled?) is that on this initial court appearance, you will simply meet with the district attorney. He will look at your driving history and offer you a deal. Given your age and driving history, he's most likely going to reduce the ticket to 1 or 2 points, and about a $40 fine or some such. If you reject his offer, that is when you go to option 3... 3. You get a subsequent court date and appear in front of a judge and plead your case. Having been through this probably 5 times in the last 10 years, I would recommend option 2. The DA will make you a reasonable deal because if you reject it, you start costing them money.
CosmicConservative
Pace, that's more or less what I was planning on doing. I was going to bring pictures of the area and demonstrate that I'm not only willing, but prepared to go to court. That means they would have to take the cop off the street to testify against me. I might cop down to a smaller fine and fewer points, I was in a hurry, but that section of 285 is very poorly set up and it is not clear where the construction ends. Plus the cop driving 35 really boils my blood, I think that was a deliberate attempt to get someone to pass him. Just to be clear the ticket itself is 4 points, it will get reduced to 3 if I just pay it and go away. I've fought most of my tickets and won a lot of them. I have had better cases though, I am sure that technically I was doing 55 (I don't think I was doing 56, at least not according to my speedometer) but the construction area wasn't even visible in my rear view mirror at the time. The only argument they might have for the placement of the "end of construction" signs is that they put them where they have to stop traffic when they are blasting. That could be a legitimate point.
pace
Some years ago I got a '77 in a 30 zone' ticket on my sportbike, up on Golden Gate Canyon. It was a mandatory court appearance with a maximum penalty of 6 months in jail, a couple thousand dollar fine, and 6 points. I met with the DA, and she reduced it to a 1-point moving violation with a $30 fine. It may have helped that I took my 8-month pregnant wife into court with me. I can't help you on the pregnant wife bit, but I'll bet you get it reduced to 2-points and a small fine if you can afford to take the half-day off work to go meet with the DA. Sometimes though it's just as easy to pay the ticket and forget about it.
Andy
That sucks, Cosmic. Of course, I am the old granny type that everybody passes on the highway. I have never had a speeding ticket. Actually, I've only gotten one ticket. Period. In 34 years of driving, I got one ticket for running a red light on North Market north of SHV by a Caddo Parish Deputy back in 1977. The light was orange. I paid it. It was $18. I think that back in those days there was not such a thing as "points" on your status. I could be wrong. Interestingly (well, maybe not so much), my 3 sons have been driving probably a combined total of about 27 years. ZERO speeding tickets...several other things...but no speeding tickets. I guess it's genetic. Regardless, I'm sorry about your ticket. That sucks!
Dadman
I've been nabbed by those insipid, unconstitutional photo enforcement contraptions twice in the last year. They sent me a ticket in the mail with a lovely photo of myself behind the wheel, scowling in both instances, as visual proof of my guilt. I paid both tickets to avoid the hassle - $180 dollars and no points. Some people have taken to wearing monkey masks while driving to avoid being identified if their pictures are taken while speeding. It's pretty funny...
CosmicConservative
Cameras taking photos of speeding motorists is blatantly unconstitutional for due process and personal privacy reasons. I'm sure we'll see the SCOTUS take it up, but these days it's hard to tell if the SCOTUS is going to rule constitutionally or not. The claims that they make intersections safer has been debunked many times.
Andy
Cosmic, I'm gonna disagree with you...and I know I'm in for an intellectual beat-down...but I'll do it anyway. I can not find in the Constitution a right not to be "observed in public." Now, I'm not a fan of red-light cameras, nor do I believe that they actually make intersections safer. They have been set up as a revenue generator...this I know. But, when we step out of the privacy of our home, I figure we are fair game for observation. I don't like the idea that cameras "is everywhere, is everywhere," but they are in convenience stores, gas stations, WalMart, etc. I am of the mind that when we leave the sanctity of our own castle, "privacy" is over. What is the difference in a policeman seeing you run a red light, or a camera seeing it? Sure, one could argue that the electronic system has been set up in favor of the camera. But, is it less reliable than a cop's eyes? (especially if he/she has been instructed to bring in revenue?... I don't think it happens often, but it has in the past in many jurisdictions) And, there IS due process. At least there is here in the cities that employ them in LA. You can go to court and challenge the ticket. And, from what I understand, many are thrown out. Of course, most people (like Dadman) don't go to the trouble, and just pay the fine. And, the truth is that the great majority are GUILTY OF RUNNING THE LIGHT (I'm looking at you, Dadman :) ). We can't have a cop at every intersection. But we do have a traffic signal at most of them. It needs to be obeyed for the good of us all. I just don't see those cameras (which I do not particularly care for) as some kind of violation of privacy. Again, I don't know of a right to "not be observed in public" in the Constitution. I could be wrong. I usually am.
Dadman
Here in Phoenix we have photo speed enforcement and I was cited (by the camera) for going about 10 mph over the speed limit. I didn't run any redlights. These camera monitored speed traps are often set up just after the speed limit is reduced, or at the end of highway entrance ramps where drivers are accelerating in order to merge safely into traffic. It was this later type that that nabbed me last. Needless to say, these things are VERY controversial, but I haven't taken to wearing halloween masks, yet, while driving around town...
CosmicConservative
Andy, privacy is a very controversial constitutional issue. It comes from the "illegal search and seizure" clause primarily. But the more compelling reasons this is unconstitutional is for due process reasons.
CosmicConservative
Back to the main thread here, I went back and checked out the scene of the crime and after careful examination, I'm afraid I probably don't have a case after all. I was nabbed right about where a speed limit 40 sign was posted. I guess I just need to pay the piper...
Andy
Dadman...sorry! I was "assuming" that it was a red light camera. Yeah, there are some speed enforcement measures like that here in LA. Lafayette threw it out after an experiment. It's good to know that you were only speeding, and not running red lights. You are righteous, and you have my apologies. Cosmic, I have listened to this debate for years now. I could swallow the due process argument. But, as I said, from what I have heard, you can fight an electronic ticket just like one the po-po hands you in person. And, many are thrown out. But what do I know? I'm the guy that gets passed on the highway by old blue-hair grannies, and almost causes wrecks by slamming my brakes on when the light turns yellow.
Dadman
I believe it is exponentially more dangerous to run redlights than cruise down the road at 65 rather than 55. So, yes, I am indeed righteous and I'll noodle on accepting your apology or not. :)